BoulderAI-written from the public meeting video

CivicCast BriefBoulder

Back to the episode

Transcript: 11-09-26 Water Resources Advisory Board Meeting

November 9, 2026

Each time links to the meeting video at that moment. Speaker names appear only where the source gives them; otherwise the speaker is shown as Unknown speaker. Open the meeting video (opens in a new tab).

  1. 0:00:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Do you want?
  2. 0:00:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: start the webinar? We did, and we are recording. Alright. Whenever you're ready. Sure.
  3. 0:00:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Good evening. My name's Amy Brun, and I serve as chair of the Water Resources Advisory Board. It's 6 p.m, and I'd like to call the November 9, 2026 meeting to order.
  4. 0:00:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: The first order of business is approval of the October meeting minutes.
  5. 0:00:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And, did Darren have a chance to review the notes?
  6. 0:00:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Okay, are there any questions or comments?
  7. 0:00:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Hearing none… Can I get a motion to approve?
  8. 0:00:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Should I agree.
  9. 0:00:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Second. Okay, all in favor of approving the September minutes, please raise your hand and say aye.
  10. 0:00:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Great.
  11. 0:00:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Katie Bridges: Bye!
  12. 0:00:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Okay, seeing and hearing none opposed, we'll approve the minutes as written, with a vote of 4-0.
  13. 0:00:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Okay, the next item on the agenda is public…
  14. 0:01:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: We'll invite, members of the public to speak. Joanna Bloom is our technical host and is going to provide the rules of engagement. Thank you, Joanne.
  15. 0:01:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Great, involved.
  16. 0:01:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Hi, my name is Joanna Bloom, and I'm serving as the technical host for this meeting. We're sharing a few slides of the virtual meeting rules that we follow to ensure a balance between transparency and digital security.
  17. 0:01:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Please provide your full name to participate in open comment. If your full name is not currently displayed.
  18. 0:01:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: You can go ahead and update it in Zoom, or you can ask me for assistance through the Q&A function. There is no chat feature for this meeting, but you may use the Q&A function for any Zoom connectivity issues.
  19. 0:01:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Video control features are limited to city officials, employees, and invited speakers. If you would like to participate in the open comment period, you may use the raised hand function in the participant box at either the top or bottom of your screen, and I'll unmute you when you're recognized to speak.
  20. 0:02:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: After I've unmuted you, please say your first and last name, and we'll begin a 3-minute timer once you begin your comments. Thank you for your participation.
  21. 0:02:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: All right, so if you would like to participate now, go ahead and raise your hand, I'll let you know, I'll call on you in the order that I see you raise your hand.
  22. 0:02:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So we do have a number of folks here. I'm gonna start with Peter Mayer, followed by Katherine Long-Gates.
  23. 0:02:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: One second, Peter. Okay, you should be able to unmute, Peter.
  24. 0:03:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I see that you've unmuted, but we can't hear you.
  25. 0:03:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: We'll give it just a second if you want to try your speaker.
  26. 0:03:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Peter Mayer: Can you hear me now?
  27. 0:03:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Yes, I can hear you now.
  28. 0:03:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Peter Mayer: Excellent.
  29. 0:03:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Peter Mayer: My name is Peter Mayer, 1339 Hawthorne Avenue, and I also submitted, written comments.
  30. 0:03:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Peter Mayer: I'm speaking today as you consider the future of Boulder's water budgets and the new utility rate structure. I'm a lifelong resident of the City of Boulder and a water professional with 30 years' experience working with hundreds of water utilities across the U.S. to improve water management.
  31. 0:03:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Peter Mayer: Customer-specific water budgets are an extremely useful and valuable management tool, and I urge you to keep and maintain and make better use of the water budgets Boulder has had in place since 2007.
  32. 0:03:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Peter Mayer: The memo I sent outlines the history of water budgets in Boulder and how they came to be used to manage water demand in both normal and drought years.
  33. 0:03:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Peter Mayer: And during the past summer, following one of our driest winters ever in our region, it was troubling to see that the city recommended two days per week watering, rather than using the existing water budget system to help manage demand.
  34. 0:04:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Peter Mayer: This is indicative that both the city staff and our community are not really aware of the water budget system and how it can be used.
  35. 0:04:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Peter Mayer: Water budgets require consistent and persistent education and information, something that Boulder has been reticent to do.
  36. 0:04:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Peter Mayer: I offer the following recommendations tonight.
  37. 0:04:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Peter Mayer: Keep Boulder's customer-specific water budgets. The city spent great time and effort developing the actual customer-specific budgets. This is an extremely useful and important information that can help Boulder manage water demands during a future drought, as well as in normal years.
  38. 0:04:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Peter Mayer: Modify the underlying water rate structure, but keep the water budgets. The current five-tier rate structure could absolutely be simplified while still including the important concept of water budgets. There are many examples available, which you could look at.
  39. 0:05:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Peter Mayer: And I also urge you to modify the current water billing email communication, which we received, to include the volume used and a comparison with a water budget target.
  40. 0:05:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Peter Mayer: That is really important. Currently, the water billing email lacks any useful information for the customer about the volume of water used and how that compares to the empirically derived water budget.
  41. 0:05:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Peter Mayer: You can log in to the customer billing portal. How many people are actually doing that? Information gives us power to manage water demands, and Boulder must regularly communicate with its customers about how they use water.
  42. 0:05:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Peter Mayer: The decision on water budgets has significant implications for Boulder's water future. As members of the Water Resources Advisory Board, you must decide whether Boulder's billing system should inform residents and engage them in responsible water management, or simply process payments with little connection to how our community water system actually works.
  43. 0:06:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Peter Mayer: Choosing the latter would undermine the city's stated commitment
  44. 0:06:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Peter Mayer: to building climate-ready, resilient systems. Thank you very much for your consideration and for your service to our community.
  45. 0:06:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Thanks, Peter. Somebody lower their hand, so next up, I see Jim knop, followed by Lynn Siegel.
  46. 0:06:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Jim, you should be able to unmute now.
  47. 0:06:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker jim knopf: Let's see, can you hear me?
  48. 0:06:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I can.
  49. 0:06:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker jim knopf: Oh, good. I'm not familiar with this particular Zoom setup.
  50. 0:06:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Agreed.
  51. 0:06:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker jim knopf: I echo everything Peter said. We work together quite a bit. After the 2002 drought, I was asked to be on the water board to help set things up. I'd written two books on water-wise landscaping as a landscape architect, so I was already working with water-wise landscaping, and I knew a lot about… I've written up
  52. 0:07:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker jim knopf: About some of the first water budget programs in the country.
  53. 0:07:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker jim knopf: Rather than repeating what, what, Peter has said.
  54. 0:07:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker jim knopf: because he really covered almost all the points. Let me just add a couple of amusing things relating to the wrong kind of creativity that happened in 2002.
  55. 0:07:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker jim knopf: When it was announced that plastic pools could be filled with water, almost every pool within 50 miles of Boulder were bought within hours. People filled them and watered their lawns by spilling it. This is not the kind of creativity, but even better than that, in North Boulder, where there are a lot of shallow wells from the old irrigation ditches, one fellow
  56. 0:07:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker jim knopf: Put up a sign, well watered on his bright green lawn. Well, it was well watered, but not with water from a well. It was city water.
  57. 0:07:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker jim knopf: That kind of creativity is not what you need. What's better is using water budgets and using meter reading. Meter reading will also… well, it allows people to focus the watering on the things that are most important.
  58. 0:08:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker jim knopf: And then also, it'll catch drip irrigation systems that are over-watering, that where you're not… you can't actually see what they're doing, unless you're really paying very close attention. So those are some extra points to what Peter had already mentioned. Thanks.
  59. 0:08:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Thanks so much, Jim.
  60. 0:08:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Lynn Siegel, you're up next, followed by Katherine Long-Gates. Lynn, you should be able to unmute.
  61. 0:08:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker lynn segal: Yeah.
  62. 0:08:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker lynn segal: Lynn Siegel here. Yeah,
  63. 0:08:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker lynn segal: I think you had better coordinate better with the Environmental Advisory Board and with the sustainability people, the climate initiatives folks, because I have a situation in my house where I have 2 years worth of $55,000 taxpayer-paid
  64. 0:09:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker lynn segal: retrofit that I won't use.
  65. 0:09:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker lynn segal: Because I was left out of it, because I revealed some corruption in the, Energy Smart program with the county, and they gaslighted me. And as a result, I'm not using any of their system, except the hot water heater, which I have to.
  66. 0:09:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker lynn segal: The other things, I just, I'm cold, again, for another 26 years, I guess. 26 years I've been cold, and I just keep it at 54 degrees, and the part of the house where I live in is more like 40 degrees when it gets really cold, and I just weather it out all winter long. And part of weathering that out is I'm really cold up when I take my shower.
  67. 0:09:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker lynn segal: And so I… and steam's rising like crazy because it's so cold in my house, and when the people put in the system, they didn't set the heat on my hot water heater hot enough.
  68. 0:10:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker lynn segal: to warm me up in a shower. So, I just use… take a longer shower than I would. Generally, I turn on the water for a bit, shh, you know, shampoo my hair, turn the water off.
  69. 0:10:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker lynn segal: You know, and wash myself, and then turn the water on again, but now I'm so cold, I can't do that. So, I'm using more water than I want. It's funny, because I saw a friend using water last night, and she's much younger, and a really very dedicated person, but her water use is just unbelievable. It took her about
  70. 0:10:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker lynn segal: a minute
  71. 0:10:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker lynn segal: for 2 minutes for washing each fork under the water running, like, and just, like, bad practices that I'm sure if she knew what she was doing, she wouldn't be doing it. But…
  72. 0:10:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker lynn segal: You know, we have a real water problem. There's no… by the way, there's no timer up. I hope you know that. So it makes it hard for a person to testify.
  73. 0:11:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker lynn segal: But our, our, you know, our whole water ability, you know, the Colorado River Compact for all this development is just uns… you know, it's not… I don't like the term sustainability, because I don't want to sustain a bad system that we already have, but to be really efficient needs to be,
  74. 0:11:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker lynn segal: moderated by the planning department, which approves every development project that comes along. And, Boulder is just… along with Sundance, we're just eating ourselves alive.
  75. 0:11:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker lynn segal: And water is at the bottom of everything. That's why I'm missing the Transportation Advisory Board testimony today, because they conflict.
  76. 0:11:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker lynn segal: Thanks.
  77. 0:11:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Your time is up, just for the benefit of the… whoever would like to speak, the timer is in the upper right-hand corner of the screen, if it helps you at all. Next up is Katherine on Gates. Katherine, you should be able to unmute.
  78. 0:12:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Catherine Long Gates: Can you hear me okay?
  79. 0:12:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: We can.
  80. 0:12:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Catherine Long Gates: Okay. Well, thank you. I'm Katherine Longgates, and I live and farm at 3240 Broadway here in Boulder, on land that my family has farmed for 110 years now.
  81. 0:12:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Catherine Long Gates: First, I'd like to say thank you to Layla Parker for reaching out to alert me to tonight's meeting, and the current look at the water budgets and rates, and for introducing me to Heather, who's been very responsive and willing to answer questions, so I appreciate staff help.
  82. 0:12:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Catherine Long Gates: I found myself thinking back to 10 years ago when I attended numerous WRAB meetings to advocate for those of us who don't necessarily fit into the usual utility customer categories.
  83. 0:12:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Catherine Long Gates: And you received an excellent email from Elizabeth Black explaining some of the challenges for those of us who are engaged in urban agriculture here in the City of Boulder.
  84. 0:12:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Catherine Long Gates: Especially if we're growing perennial crops, that means we have less flexibility to quickly adjust our water needs as compared to annual crops.
  85. 0:13:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Catherine Long Gates: Trying to determine water budgets for agriculture based on averages is just fraught with difficulties, as every year can be wildly different. And as growers, we are at the mercy of Mother Nature.
  86. 0:13:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Catherine Long Gates: Here's just one example of how the budget and the assumptions about what part of the year is going to require irrigation. My early March bill, covering most of February and early March was $1400 just for the water, and that doesn't include the service charge.
  87. 0:13:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Catherine Long Gates: We used 60,000 gallons, because if we didn't water then, we were going to be losing a lot of our crop.
  88. 0:13:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Catherine Long Gates: If we had used that same amount of water, but under the September, early October budget, which assumes that we would be irrigating.
  89. 0:14:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Catherine Long Gates: That would have… that water would have cost me $339, so only about a quarter of the cost. Just an example of how the current
  90. 0:14:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Catherine Long Gates: Timing of budgets does not work for us in urban agriculture.
  91. 0:14:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Catherine Long Gates: With the changing climate, we really need less assumptions about when water will be used for irrigation.
  92. 0:14:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Catherine Long Gates: Urban agriculture does help support the city's goals of sustainability and resilience.
  93. 0:14:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Catherine Long Gates: And during drought conditions, we're grateful for having the resource of municipal water, but we do hope for and welcome discussing how our needs to stay viable are different from other utility customers. And I thank you all so much for your consideration.
  94. 0:14:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Great, thanks, Katherine. I'll just give it one more moment in case anyone else
  95. 0:14:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Online wants to virtually raise your hand and indicate that you would like to speak.
  96. 0:15:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Okay, I don't see anybody else interested in speaking, so I think that's the end of open comments.
  97. 0:15:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Yeah, of course, and I think Joel may want to come as well. Yeah, sorry. Appreciate that. Good evening, board and community members. I'm Joe Teddyucci, I'm the Director of the City's Utilities Department. We appreciate everyone who spoke tonight, and also those who emailed into the board.
  98. 0:15:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Talking about an important topic that we'll introduce here in a second, the
  99. 0:15:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: our rate study, but I do appreciate and want to recognize, Peter and Jim's feedback. I think Jim was on the board in my, first couple… couple years when I was a staff member, and no offense to Jim or anyone else, but I think that was about 100 years ago.
  100. 0:15:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: But, appreciate that feedback on the… on the rate study, and I,
  101. 0:16:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I think we're actually aligned in some of the themes that we heard, and we do recognize the values of water budget, and particularly for our single-family customers who tend to have more of the outdoor irrigation
  102. 0:16:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: situation, and so we are planning to keep those as a staff team. We're planning to recommend keeping those when we get to that point of a recommendation to the board.
  103. 0:16:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And, and also enhance them. I think there are ways that we've seen, since they were implemented back in 2008, if I'm remembering correctly, that there are ways to make them more effective, and I think that's in our plans as well.
  104. 0:16:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And then to Katherine, appreciate the feedback there as well. Katherine was really involved in our last rate study, as she mentioned.
  105. 0:17:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: had a lot of input that actually ended up changing the way we did some of the calculations on the stormwater fund. So, appreciate that input. I do know our staff team has been
  106. 0:17:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: working with Katherine and Elizabeth and others, and we do recognize the importance of urban agriculture, and I think Joanna has been working with our team to
  107. 0:17:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: on those communications, so I don't know if there's anything you want to add to…
  108. 0:17:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Yes, just in general detail, I would say hi, it's Joanna Bloom, I'm Deputy Director of Utilities on the Policy and Planning side, and I'm supporting the Rate Study project. So we did do individual reach-outs to our urban customers, just because we know that their uses
  109. 0:17:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Vary from just kind of standard use, and even among the urban ag group.
  110. 0:17:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: the use among that group can vary a fair amount. And so, largely what we're looking for is to make sure that we can accommodate their need in a normal year, knowing that drought is also important, but that's kind of outside the scope of this
  111. 0:18:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: topic to a degree, but we are looking carefully at each of those accounts to make sure that we don't really have any wild swings one way or the other. And so, really, thank you for your time coming here, for those folks that fall into that category, and we're happy to meet with you and kind of look at what some of the rate changes
  112. 0:18:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: may or may not show up as differences for you. I do think that the team will talk about, our shifting ET factors, and you should pay particular attention to that to see if it meets your needs. And then we can also just meet with you to,
  113. 0:18:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Discuss any particular impacts, but an early indicator doesn't show any major monetary impact, so…
  114. 0:18:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So far, I feel like we're on track.
  115. 0:18:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I'm Joel Smith, member of the WRAB, and yeah, first thanks to all of you who offered comments tonight, and to the very constructive letters we got, including Joe on that. I did want to comment on,
  116. 0:19:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: on Peter's letter, because I was usually trying to prep for the meeting the week before with a lot going on last week, so I was reading this afternoon, and then, maybe by serendipity, I checked my email and my water utility
  117. 0:19:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: statement just happened to arrive about 3 or 4 this afternoon, so I… I looked at it, and I said, and you just get the opening. It says, okay, go in. And fortunately, right, I saved my password in the system, otherwise I'd be hunting around for it. And then you gotta go in, then you gotta go, I think, through 2 clicks to actually get to the water usage.
  118. 0:19:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: to see what… how… what my monthly usage was compared to the budget.
  119. 0:19:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And so it does take a little bit of work, because I do remember those old paper bills, and it was nice. It was… it was a very clear graphic, and you could really see it very nicely. So I… I want to echo what… what Peter said. I don't know if there's some way, maybe in the… in the email itself, I realize we don't want to go back to paper.
  120. 0:20:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: But maybe in the email itself, if there could be either a direct link to usage, or maybe it just popped right in there, something that would make it… because
  121. 0:20:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: this really… it's a… you know, it's a financial incentive tool, but it also is communication, so it's critical that people see what their water usage is, and see it in as timely a manner as possible. I mean, one of the problems you have is there's just a lag.
  122. 0:20:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: You know, between when the recording is made and when to get the bill. Not much we can do about that, but at least make sure that that information is accessible. So, particularly, you know, for those people who are exceeding their budgets, that should be a really… should be almost like a flashing red light in front of them.
  123. 0:20:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And the harder we make it for them to see them, I think the less effective the whole rate structure effort, program can be.
  124. 0:20:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: That for sure was one of the trade-offs of moving to pay for this.
  125. 0:21:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: other important reasons that we needed to do that, and I can assure you, we did not plan that, to send you your bill. It's all automated.
  126. 0:21:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And thank you for that feedback, and we can definitely… we're always up for continually improving both our communication and just kind of our data provision.
  127. 0:21:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: That being said, for those customers who don't know, you can set up a threshold through the portal at whatever rate you want to. So, it'll send you a notification if you do exceed a certain usage amount, so that can align with your budget, that can be slightly lower than your budget, depending upon what your needs are, so that's one option. And then I do know, I totally agree with continual
  128. 0:21:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: education, and I know that our conservation team tries to do that a lot, but I also know that we have a hardworking group of folks that answer the phone every day, and they are going one-on-one education, walking people through the portal, and telling them how they can access the information, so that's available to anybody who wants a little bit of help.
  129. 0:22:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And if you really prefer the paper, I agree, at full sale, going back to paper, there's downsides to that, but folks still can opt in for the paper bill if you prefer, so the team can help you with that as well. And the last thing I'll say is that our most recent numbers do show that despite about 70% of our customers being on auto-pay, so there's really no reason to look at the bill unless
  130. 0:22:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: They have an issue, or whatever.
  131. 0:22:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: There's about 20,000 that have checked their portal account out of 30,000 in 2026, so we do show that two-thirds of our customers are using the portal in one way or the other, so we can absolutely improve, but I do, I do think we have some evidence that folks are interacting with the information.
  132. 0:22:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Well, that's encouraging to hear. Yeah, totally. We weren't sure either, but…
  133. 0:22:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Yeah, we'll for sure take that feedback, though, and look at what's possible.
  134. 0:23:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: There are some constraints in the software itself of what we can program, and so that's, thank you.
  135. 0:23:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: But, if you want, I can go to introducing the site. Yeah, please, and it sounds like we're all proud for it. Agenda number 4. Yeah, for sure, and I will say, you know, this is a topic, we did it in 2008, I think we started one in 2016, and it got approved in 2018.
  136. 0:23:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And here it is, 2025 and 26, and we're doing it again, so these only come along.
  137. 0:23:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Every so often, and it's probably one of the most important things that,
  138. 0:23:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: the board weighs in on. So, in terms of where we've been, and in this particular study and where we're going, we met with the board on this topic in 2025, had several touchpoints with the board in 2026, in January, April, and July.
  139. 0:23:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: The first phase, as you might recall, we are really focused on the water budget analysis.
  140. 0:24:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And then the second, phase was our cost of service analysis, so now
  141. 0:24:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: We're kind of combining all of that and putting it all together and seeing how that models and kind of shakes out when you put it all together.
  142. 0:24:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And in terms of what's coming, the last steps that we'll be looking at and having an information item with the board will occur in January.
  143. 0:24:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: When we talk about plant investment fees, a lot of cities call them TAP fees, what it costs to buy into our
  144. 0:24:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: system, and then we'll be coming to the board, looking for a recommendation in February. And we'll be talking to Council after that, and that's all on a track to allow us to work on a big lift around implementation and programming everything into our
  145. 0:24:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: our software in advance of hopefully going live January of 2028.
  146. 0:25:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: It's too early to talk about 2020, but I just did it.
  147. 0:25:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So tonight, we'll be talking about the cost of service study and potential rate proposals or a rate scenario that goes with it. I did want to mention that in this particular rate study, we are really focused on the water utility.
  148. 0:25:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: In the one we did in 2018, we did some work on wastewater and storm and flood, but this one's a deeper dive on the water utilities side of it.
  149. 0:25:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I did want to mention to the board that you will hear in the discussion tonight a rate scenario.
  150. 0:25:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Or a rate proposal for several years.
  151. 0:25:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Based on what we'd showed to the board in our, Six-year financials, customer budget process.
  152. 0:25:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: But I want to emphasize that that's really just a scenario. It was the most logical one to work with in the modeling, because it's been formalized and it's there.
  153. 0:26:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: That does not in any way block the board into… you're not… you don't have proven rates for the next 5 years. We won't… we won't hold you to that.
  154. 0:26:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: We'll still go through each year's budget process. So, that was kind of a…
  155. 0:26:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: a number of different items on context and tee-ups, and we're pleased to have Dave, Yanke and Carrie Anderson with us from NuGen, our consultants, that'll be leading a lot of the presentation tonight, and I think before going to them.
  156. 0:26:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I will kick it over to Steph Klingemann, who is our Principal Financial Analyst, to provide
  157. 0:26:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: a little bit more, in terms of introductory comments. Yeah, so I'll probably say a few similar items here, but, good evening, I'm Steph Klingemann, the Utilities Budget Analyst, City of Boulder. I've been working really closely with Dave and Carrie here, of Nugen on the utility rate study with support from, our other budget analyst, Adrian Walker.
  158. 0:27:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And so, really, the purpose of tonight, as Joe mentioned, is to really go through the water cost of service results and the proposed rate scenarios for the water utility. When we come back to the WRAB, we'll have, you know, later on next year, we'll have the other utilities in the mix, but as
  159. 0:27:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Joe mentioned already, we're really looking at making some fundamental rate structure changes to the water utility, so today's discussion is really focused there.
  160. 0:27:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And as Joe already mentioned, you know, this work did begin last year with the water budget analysis, so really, when we started the analysis, we wanted to see how water budgets were performing.
  161. 0:27:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: whether they were set correctly, and whether they set, you know, the right conservation signal to our customers. So we gathered input from customers through a variety of ways. We went to a What's Up Boulder community event. We also set out a community questionnaire. We've come for this board in the past. We also hosted some large water user workshops, and
  162. 0:28:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: We've also connected with our community connectors and residents, so we've really tried to be thoughtful with how we
  163. 0:28:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: presented this study and how we've also gathered feedback. So through that outreach and some of that internal analysis, we have found that water budgets are working really well for our single family.
  164. 0:28:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: and metered irrigation customers. And as a result of that, we plan on retaining the existing water budget rate structure with some targeted adjustments there. So we'll talk about this, I think, a little bit more in the presentation, but looking at moving the single-family indoor budget from
  165. 0:28:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: 6K gals down to 5K gals to actually better match actual indoor usage. We're looking at tweaking the monthly outdoor water allocations using recent data, and then for the single-family residential customers, also looking at
  166. 0:29:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: resetting outdoor budgets based on lot size rather than your goal here. You can get into…
  167. 0:29:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: some of that a little bit more later. For our commercial multifamily customers, you know, we found that water budgets aren't working quite as well, they're not sending the same conservation pricing signal, so we're proposing a simpler rate structure based on meter size there.
  168. 0:29:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: As Joe mentioned, you know, this is a work in progress, so what we're proposing today is not final. We're still refining these scenarios with your input to make sure that the changes are fair and manageable for our customers. And as Joe already mentioned, the plans to retain the current rate structure
  169. 0:29:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: through 2027, so any approved changes wouldn't take place until January of 2028.
  170. 0:29:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So with that, I'll turn it over to Carrie and Dave to walk us through these instances.
  171. 0:30:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And share my screen.
  172. 0:30:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Hi, my name's Terry Anderson, I'm a manager with NuGen, and here with Davion B. We're going to be talking about our cost of service and rate design study. Like, Steph and Joe mentioned, we're doing that for, water, wastewater, and stormwater, but today we're going to be focusing on water.
  173. 0:30:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So here I have the agenda that we're gonna be talking through today.
  174. 0:30:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Throughout this presentation, if at any point you have any comments or questions from the board or staff, feel free to bring them up while they're fresh on your mind, and we can talk through those. But I'm going to start with the study progress of where we've been since we,
  175. 0:31:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: We're here back in April, and we'll talk through the revenue requirement and cost of service, the process of putting that together, and then the proposed rate structure changes, as a result of that, along with the proposed rates for each of the customer classes. And then we'll talk through, some of our next steps.
  176. 0:31:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So, like I mentioned, we were last year in April of this year, and we talked through the study scope, and some of those class and service principles. So the overall goal of the study is to determine the revenue needed to cover costs, and model those alternate rate structures, that we're going to be talking about later on in this presentation.
  177. 0:31:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: With the ultimate goal of balancing conservation, and to alleviate some of that administrative burden, and then add to predictability of the bills for customers.
  178. 0:31:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: We, since, that April meeting, have worked through the 20-year financial forecast, so looking at fiscal year 2026 through 2045, for that revenue requirement, incorporating capital funding, and reserves. Using that, we used the fiscal year 2031, that year as a basis for the water cost service, and allocating those costs to the different customer classes.
  179. 0:32:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And use that to inform those rate structure alternatives, along with, the water budget policy recommendations provided by SAP, and then those stakeholder meetings that step in.
  180. 0:32:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So you might recognize this from our April meeting. This is the cost of service methodology. When we were here in April, we were working through those first three steps, so putting together the test year, allocating out those costs, and since then, we have conducted the cost of service analysis, which I'm going to be walking through in the next few slides.
  181. 0:33:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So, to put together the revenue requirement, we started off with the fiscal year 2026, budget as a basis for that test year, and then looking at a number of different, items, like the funding plan, the capital, the capital funding plan, and then target, financial target, so…
  182. 0:33:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: based on conversations with staff, we were looking at approximately $164 million in capital spending over that 5-year period from fiscal year 2027 through 2031. So this is what we used as,
  183. 0:33:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: This is what we incorporated into that revenue requirement, and I'll just mention here that this is something that staff plans on reviewing further, looking at the timing, and the program needs to talk to the board about it in the 2028 budgeting cycle, so there may be changes to, some of these values.
  184. 0:33:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: But as a basis for that revenue requirement, about $164 million in capital spending. As a part of that, we incorporated a bond issue in fiscal year 2028 of $47.1 million, so that resulted in about $3.7 million a year in debt service, and that starts in fiscal year 2029. And we'll see that a little bit more in our next slide.
  185. 0:34:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: To lay that out across the 5-year period, we looked at a number of different financial metrics that we looked at maintaining, so those being 180 days cash on hand target with, no fewer than 90 days in any given year, 1.75 times minimum debt service coverage in each year, and then 25% operating reserve as a share of annual operating expenses.
  186. 0:34:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So these essentially represent those boundary conditions for the cost of service and guided how we forecast through those expenses. Can you just explain what the debt service coverage formula is? So that's looking at the revenue, divided by the annual debt service, to see what can be,
  187. 0:34:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: spent on debt each year, essentially. Okay, yeah, thank you.
  188. 0:35:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So based on all of that, we put together our revenue requirement forecast. So again, using that fiscal year 2026 at a budget as a basis, we, forecasted expenses, for certain items, like debt service, that's based on contractual terms.
  189. 0:35:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: All of the operating and maintenance slide items, we applied inflation to somewhere between 4% and 6% on each of those.
  190. 0:35:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: to create this forecast. The capital funding, that's the main source of the volatility that you'll see in here. So…
  191. 0:35:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: seeing in fiscal year 28, when that bond issue's coming online, the lowest point of the capital spending. Overall, across the forecast period, it's an average of $23 million in annual cash funding.
  192. 0:35:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So for that reason, we use fiscal year 2031 as a basis of the cost of service analysis that you'll see in the next few slides. That incorporates that $3.7 million in annual debt service coverage from that bond issue we mentioned, and then the average of the capital spending each year.
  193. 0:36:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So, based on all of that, and looking at the fiscal year 2031,
  194. 0:36:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: as a basis for that cost of service analysis, we projected using, current billing units and rates to, see what the revenue would be.
  195. 0:36:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: From that, we got approximately a $14.8 million shortfall, and that…
  196. 0:36:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: When incorporating the, rate increase that's already been approved for fiscal year 2027 of 5%, resulted in about a 7.5% increase needed each year from fiscal year 28 through 2031.
  197. 0:36:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Again, here I'll mention this is based on current capital planning that might be adjusted based on, conversations in the future. This is just one proposed scenario to make up that revenue shortfall. There's a number of different ways that you can meet this. This is just
  198. 0:37:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: The basis that we used, to look at the different rate structure alternatives.
  199. 0:37:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Any questions about? You're gonna get to the inflation assumptions.
  200. 0:37:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Do you want to hear more about those assumptions?
  201. 0:37:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So they range from about 4% to 6%. We looked at a number of different indices, so we looked at the municipal cost index, the construction cost index, capital costs were inflated using 4% each year.
  202. 0:37:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And then I can give you some more detail on some of those numbers. Are those based on long-term
  203. 0:37:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Yeah, you know, it's a really good solution. Excuse me.
  204. 0:37:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: let's talk about this for a second, and make a note, if you want, we can send a listing of the inflation factors, we'll send them to STEP, and you can provide them, right? Yeah, what we saw. Okay, so one of the things in the last 4 or 5 years with inflation.
  205. 0:38:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And you have to be careful in looking at historical versus going forward. There's been real volatility on chemicals, and so it's been huge increases, but if you use a historical, then that can skew, because
  206. 0:38:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: hoping it'll continue that way. So, we have a number of those that are based on, say, a 4% historical for general costs, then we'll look at historical… we looked at a longer period of time.
  207. 0:38:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: on chemicals, I think we went back, like, 10 years, or what have you, as I recall. And then, looking at electricity, also looking at, construction costs, that's the big one that we just…
  208. 0:38:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Are seeing across the board,
  209. 0:38:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: significant costs, you know, in steel costs, concrete, you name it. And, that's one of the big drivers.
  210. 0:39:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Unaccountable costs.
  211. 0:39:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Okay.
  212. 0:39:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: But I also noticed in the table, there was… it was after about 20… sometime in the early 2030s, there was a significant drop. That's… Is that… Right. You know, we…
  213. 0:39:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: You know, we're all watching inflation, or where it is right now, you know.
  214. 0:39:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I believe, but, you know, I don't have a crystal ball.
  215. 0:39:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: We believe these things will smooth out. We've got a number of external factors going on in the world that are skewing some of these things that
  216. 0:39:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I hope are not going on in the world a year or two from now, and those will help bring some of those factors down, so we do…
  217. 0:39:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: want to look at what we believe to be breeds.
  218. 0:39:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Okay.
  219. 0:39:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I'll just quickly add, I mean, this is a, say, 20-year forecast, so this is a pretty long, planning period we're looking at. If we were to use those higher inflation factors over that 20-year forecast, that would really
  220. 0:40:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: compound those costs over time. So we were really intentional with these first 5 years, looking at, you know, five-year historical averages, but then wanting to drop some of those inflation factors down a bit, just so that we could cost control a little bit. You'll still see, I think we have salaries and benefits, and, you know, construction costs still at a slightly higher percentage, but then you see the other inflation factors dropping down to, like.
  221. 0:40:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: multiple 2 or 3%.
  222. 0:40:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I mean, it seems prudie to, you know, prepare for not necessarily the worst case, but a bad, reasonable bad case scenario, so that seems prudie, but I assume that
  223. 0:40:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: should we be fortunate and actual prices don't go up, these will be reflected in the CIP leads that we'll be seeing in the future, right? Yeah, that's correct. Yeah, okay. And the 2027 through 2031 is really the most important period of fairly conservative escalation.
  224. 0:41:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: As soon.
  225. 0:41:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Okay, well, thanks for the explanation, please.
  226. 0:41:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So here we get into some of those proposed rates. So, as a basis for those rate structure alternatives that we're going to be looking at, we set
  227. 0:41:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: what we're…
  228. 0:41:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: calling the status quo scenario, so looking at what the rate increases would need to be if no structure changes were to occur. So those are the rate increases that you see across the top there. So the 5% that's already being… been approved for fiscal year 2027, and then the 7.5% increases each year for fiscal year 2028 through 2031.
  229. 0:41:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So these are the, monthly service charges for inside city customers, and these are applied to all customer classes. And these…
  230. 0:41:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: are the monthly service charges that collect a fixed amount of revenue, so essentially representing revenue that the utility can count on and is not subject to that volatility for, for things like consumption.
  231. 0:42:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And these are going to be maintained through the rate structure alternatives that we're going to be recommending, so all customer classes would have these monthly service charges, and then the, alternate structures that we're going to be talking through.
  232. 0:42:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Yeah, and one of the things that's worth noting here is when we design rates, there's a balance between the fixed charge and the variable charge, and so you try to find that sweet spot there. Okay, so yes, you have that fixed charge going, you know, proposed going up at, say, 7.5% here.
  233. 0:42:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: One of the challenges, and we're dealing with this for a lot of our clients, in the last few years with the inflationary costs we just talked about.
  234. 0:42:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: we are seeing the fixed charges going up in this range. We have a lot of clients that the fixed charges for a 5 eighths inch or a 3 quarter inch meter are harder than what those are. You've got to balance this, because when we talk about all those other costs.
  235. 0:43:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: this is your only fixed portion, and then that other portion, you know, that's going to be varied. And now that you've got weather affecting your revenue stream, as it is, I think we're coming in with the fixed charges that are only around 30-35% of your total revenues.
  236. 0:43:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And… which is a lot… it's about where you… we typically see 30, 35, 40% in that range.
  237. 0:43:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So you try to find that balance between fixed and variable revenue recovery, and I think where you've got this here is reasonable from what we see in the industry.
  238. 0:44:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So then we get into some of those proposed rate structure changes that I was mentioning. This represents, a bulk of what we're going to be talking about through this study, and
  239. 0:44:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I'm gonna talk through the three bolded ones that I have here, and then we're gonna get into more detail on the rest of them in the next few slides.
  240. 0:44:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So first, we have for single-family residential, their indoor budget, the change proposed there. Currently, there's a 6,000 gallons per month allocation to each customer, and then the proposed is 5,000 gallons per month.
  241. 0:44:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: For commercial customers, there's a number of different ways that their budgets are calculated, average winter consumption, historical monthly usage. We're looking at moving to a meter-size-based inclining block rate structure.
  242. 0:44:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And multifamily would also follow that recommendation, with some large customers paying a single rate. And then, finally, for the number of tiers for each of these proposed scenarios, recommending going from 5 tiers to 4 tiers,
  243. 0:45:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And, that's a consolidation of Tiers 3, where they currently exist, for single-family and meteor irrigation, but we'll get into that more on the next slide.
  244. 0:45:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Okay, you'll keep talking, I'll put in more detail. Yeah, but any questions on any of those so far? Well, go ahead.
  245. 0:45:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So first, we have that 5 tier to four tier change. So this is illustrating what it would look like for single-family and metered irrigation.
  246. 0:45:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So for tiers 1 and 2, that's for those staying within their budgets, and the rates proposed for those are slightly lower than what it would be for under the status quo scenario.
  247. 0:45:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Tier 3, that's a combination of what was previously Tier 3 and Tier 4, so that 101 to 200%. That rate for… would be slightly higher than what it is currently for Tier 3, so more of a,
  248. 0:46:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: when they immediately go over their budget, more of that conservation, pricing signal, and then slightly lower than what it currently is for, Tier 4, or yes, for what's currently Tier 4. And then new Tier 4, would be maintaining that highest rate, for those going above 200% of their budget.
  249. 0:46:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So, just… I mean, I like the idea of simple.
  250. 0:46:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: fewer, tiers. But I just wanted, just to ask the question, you proposed combining Tier 3 and 4, as opposed to, what about instead combining 4 and 5, just to ask the question.
  251. 0:46:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: That…
  252. 0:46:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Ultimately, with our proposed rate scenarios, we are looking at remaining revenue neutral, so in order to maintain that revenue neutrality, if we were to reduce the rate for those going over 200% of their budget,
  253. 0:46:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: it would…
  254. 0:46:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: it would adjust… it would send less of that pricing signal for conservation, yeah. It's more effective, yeah, to commit to four a second. Okay. And I think one thing that's important… yeah.
  255. 0:47:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: We spent a lot of time… let me just emphasize, we spent a lot of time looking at the consumption levels in those different blocks, because it kind of goes back to, again, getting that sweet spot to find that, and so that was important, that there were a lot of different analyses looked at there, and then on the rates, playing with
  256. 0:47:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: those, because…
  257. 0:47:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: you also want to take care of those first two tiers, and, you know, with those folks, and so you still have to keep it revenue neutral, so there's…
  258. 0:47:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: there was a lot of playing with it to see where you can get it balanced. No, and I like reducing 1 and 2, I think that is good, especially one. Yeah.
  259. 0:48:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Okay, okay, that's it, that's interesting. Can I ask if the… did you look in that same analysis if you…
  260. 0:48:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: thought about moving the line between Tier 1 and Tier 2, like, up or down? Like, did it go… did you change the split to 0 to 50 for Tier 1, and then 50 to 100, or something different? Just out of curiosity.
  261. 0:48:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: We did not look at that in particular. I think the goal was to maintain tiers 1 and 2 so that those that were staying within their budget. You'll see on the next couple slides that we reduced those rates, to…
  262. 0:48:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: encourage staying within your budget, but for the split between those two, no, we didn't look at that, specifically. And one of the things…
  263. 0:48:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: When it comes to rate design, there… there are countless, literally countless ways. One of the reasons we didn't do that is because you want to keep
  264. 0:48:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: That 100%. That's right. That's what you gotta hit, and we have to be careful in how we move things. If we move too many pieces, if you start moving too many pieces, variables, you start losing the connection of why are we doing this change, and so…
  265. 0:49:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: It gets to be a judgment of, okay, let's try to keep it simple here, so we can follow that 100% on the budget.
  266. 0:49:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Absolutely, yeah, I get the 100% of budget, for sure. I… just for background, city staff, do you know why that number is at 60?
  267. 0:49:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I don't know if it's that important or worth spending much time on, I'm just trying to tell. Yeah. Okay, thank you. Do you know what share of single-family users are… fall into 3, then 4, and then 5?
  268. 0:49:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: That's true, that's true, this is gonna hit.
  269. 0:49:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: For how many… not how many, who? Doesn't that bar chart… that bar chart will get there. If you can hang on, I can hold that question, and if we do not answer it, you can say, Dave, you did not answer my question, I'm sure it was. I know you're consolidating tiers here, but was there any consideration to setting up a tier for
  270. 0:50:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: like, super savers, or… conserving.
  271. 0:50:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Stellar water conservers.
  272. 0:50:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Like, below Tier 1? Yeah.
  273. 0:50:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So it's gonna get more complicated then, and again, the messaging. Tier 1 is always… that's…
  274. 0:50:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: that's your smallest one. If you're trying to save, we're going to encourage that. I get the Super Saver, but now we've got to reallocate those dollars across those other
  275. 0:50:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Blogs, and it just… again.
  276. 0:50:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: we can model things until the cows come home, and… In the context of, like, affordability, you wonder if there is some, you know, like.
  277. 0:50:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: fixed income.
  278. 0:51:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: any water user sort of category. We do have those decreases. I mean, the tiers 1 and 2, and let's go to… we'll get to the bar charts a little later. I think… I think we're addressing that, and…
  279. 0:51:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I think we're addressing.
  280. 0:51:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I think, Amy, to your point, though, if we are looking at, like, a really low, rate for Tier 1, we then would have to make up those
  281. 0:51:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: those increases elsewhere. And so, by limiting it here to those four tiers, I think we'll show the bar chart and how things kind of end up working out. I think we have a really good mix of, rewarding those low water users who are staying in Tier 1 with a slightly reduced rate, and then
  282. 0:51:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Yeah, I… I think… I think, I think with the new rate structure, we're striking a good balance by still working with the water budget rate structures and making sure that we're not
  283. 0:52:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: over-penalizing anyone in, like, Tier 2. I think we really wanted to make sure that Tier 1 and Tier 2 was representative of, you know, low water users and also users who were staying within their budget, so…
  284. 0:52:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Sorry, back to Katherine's question, the 60% is set.
  285. 0:52:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: When they were originally… water budgets were originally set up based on the amount of indoor use.
  286. 0:52:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So that is… so if you just are indoor, followed 60%. Oh, that's okay.
  287. 0:52:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Sorry, so the assumption was if you just have indoor water use, like, you have an apartment, you don't have a lawn, or outdoor plants generally fall into that tier level under suspension.
  288. 0:52:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So Tier 2 is really getting at outdoor water use.
  289. 0:52:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Jen.
  290. 0:52:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Interesting.
  291. 0:52:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Someone, for example, on, like, a water lock-wise lawn.
  292. 0:52:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I'll be with him.
  293. 0:52:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: fall within Tier 2, not 3, almost 3, yeah. Okay. I think it's variable. I mean, ideally, that's how it would work out, but…
  294. 0:53:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Yeah, it's kind of like a lot of factors.
  295. 0:53:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: It's… Okay.
  296. 0:53:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So then we get into the proposed rates for single-family. So…
  297. 0:53:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: like I mentioned, we're looking at moving from 6,000 gallons to that 5,000 gallons, to encourage conservation, better reflect actual current water use by those single-family residential customers.
  298. 0:53:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: The current budgets are above what typical of those typical customers use, so they're less likely to,
  299. 0:53:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: use above their budgets, and those conservation signals aren't being sent, as effectively, so reducing that budget. Then also looking at updating the outdoor budget. So currently it's based on irrigable area. That's something that is harder to maintain. It's something that can change over time due to something like landscaping. So moving that to lot size that's more consistent for customers.
  300. 0:54:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Because of that, we reduced, it's currently a tiered application rate, for outdoor budgets, moving that to $8,000, or…
  301. 0:54:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: 8 gallons per square foot, for that application rate.
  302. 0:54:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: That's many gallons per…
  303. 0:54:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I'm sorry, just per month… per what time period? 8 gallons per square foot of lot size, and so then… so that is spread out across the year based on those 18 factors. And then we'll… I think we will look at that on a later slide. What's the current… anybody have a date on the current rate structure?
  304. 0:54:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: It's… so it's based on irritable area. I can get that for you, Joel, but it goes… But I'm particularly between 2 and 3.
  305. 0:54:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: the jump, how much it goes up from block 2 to block… Oh, for the rate structure? Yeah, the current… how much the water rates jump. So the block differential on that, so if you're using Tier 2 as a basis… Tier 2. Tier 1 is .75, Tier, 3 is…
  306. 0:55:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: 2 times, or, I'm sorry. Let me double check that. I know that the net, the new block differential we're looking at is 2.5 times, and then, 5 times per block. Well, that sends a clear signal.
  307. 0:55:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: In the packet use next? I can't get it to pull up on my computer, but I didn't say that the average
  308. 0:55:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: indoor use was 3.5 for the winter usage for those customers, yeah, for winter use.
  309. 0:55:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Okay, and so winter use is kind of like a proxy for indoor use, right? So, yeah, so we're still… we're still above the indoor use. I think something that's important to point out here is that,
  310. 0:56:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Single-family residents don't get an outdoor budget allocation in the winter months.
  311. 0:56:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So to the degree that there is some watering that needs to happen, you know, over the winter, this gives customers a little bit of an extra cushion to do that. We wouldn't want to take that all the way down to $3,500. We'd still kind of want a little bit of a buffer for that reason. Would that be still too stringent?
  312. 0:56:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: We thought about doing 4 as well, but we just felt like the step down from 6 to 5 was sort of an obvious step down we could do without penalizing customers maybe too much, and especially kind of coming off of this really dry year, where we have had a lot of folks needing to winter water, we just felt like the 6 to 5 was a better approach.
  313. 0:56:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So these are the proposed rates that we put together based on that revenue-neutral scenario. So…
  314. 0:56:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: compared to that, the 2028 rates that we're showing here are slightly lower than what would be under that… just that 5% and that 7.5%, increase. So,
  315. 0:57:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: for those customers that are using within their budget, giving them a little bit of that grace, and then the pricing signals as you move into Block 3 above.
  316. 0:57:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So here we have that bar graph that Dave was talking about, showing the bill impacts for those single-family residents. So the majority of customers see some reduction in their annual bill, so…
  317. 0:57:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: those staying within their budgets and those slightly lower rates. And again, this is as compared to those status quo, rates, so fiscal year 28 status quo versus these proposed structure changes.
  318. 0:57:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So this is to minimize that impact on those low water users and those staying within their budgets. And then those seeing some increase in their bill are those,
  319. 0:57:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: using above their budgets, so the increase in Tier 3 rates, for those exceeding their budgets, just to encourage conservation, for those individuals.
  320. 0:58:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So, it's about… I'm just trying to do that. So, it's about 21% who exceed
  321. 0:58:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: It'll go above tier, okay. Well, that's pretty good, so… The vast majority.
  322. 0:58:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: We'll benefit from this, will have less lower costs.
  323. 0:58:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I really don't get hit hard. Okay, well, that's interesting.
  324. 0:58:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And going back to the public feedback we heard.
  325. 0:58:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Because it's actually by design to send a better price signal to make them more effective. I'll just ask this, since we're just exploring.
  326. 0:58:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Given… so just the way I read that chart, so that first blue line, that would be Tier 3, and then next would be Tier 4.
  327. 0:58:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: No, not necessarily. It depends where they, like, who you're talking about. Oh, okay. No, that's not… I'm just misreading this, okay.
  328. 0:58:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: This is just by share. Those are customer bills percentages broken out.
  329. 0:59:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So how… I'm just curious, I mean, if you had…
  330. 0:59:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: If you didn't combine two, ask that question, I know it'd throw things in tism, but if you combine 4 and 5 plus 3, I'm just wondering how that might split out in terms of
  331. 0:59:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: The people that are exceeding.
  332. 0:59:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Just curious how am I square in terms of percentages. You know, we ran… no, I'll get over the tips of my skis here, because, you were doing this.
  333. 0:59:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: You were running numerous other scenarios where… this is not the first bar chart we've been looking at. Okay. There were some others, and, you know, they moved in the general area. I mean… We didn't look at a chart where we were combining Tier 4 and 5. I think the idea with… if we were to combine those, it would be giving more of a
  334. 0:59:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Bring to those that are going well above their budget, versus…
  335. 0:59:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Yeah, that's the one that really sends the strongest down for the real, the real outliers. Yeah. Okay.
  336. 1:00:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Whatever share that is.
  337. 1:00:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Which makes sense. Okay.
  338. 1:00:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And it's still not that big, so…
  339. 1:00:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Okay, I want to make sure I understand. So the 15% on that first blue bar, that's the percentage of people that fall on that.
  340. 1:00:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: That's okay, and then they are… they're only facing, you know, a 0% to 10% increase.
  341. 1:00:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And almost 40% would face a 0% to 5% decrease. Right, right. Now, I'm just curious, I mean, it'd be okay in my book, especially in a small percentage, these are probably people who use a lot of water.
  342. 1:00:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: even sent a stronger signal, but, you know, I don't think 0-10% is gonna…
  343. 1:00:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Probably, I suspect, that may hardly notice it.
  344. 1:00:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So I don't have… I have other clients that are going up more than 10% right now, so… Yeah, yeah, they'll notice. No, no, but it's not. It's, you know, it'd be okay in my vote to send a stronger conservation sign.
  345. 1:01:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: This isn't exactly where you're headed, Joel, but we did get a question online that I can't answer in the Zoom, so I want to answer it out loud, but should a drought situation occur, we do have the ability to lower the budget amount. So, like, right now, the indoor allocation would be 5. We can lower that in a drought scenario to increase the price signal, so if we were really wanting to do that, there are ways to do it.
  346. 1:01:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Right.
  347. 1:01:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: It wouldn't be in a normal race. Peter, comment on that, although I just… I didn't really… I actually agreed with just sending a clear signal saying 2 days away, rather than doing it to the price. I think this is faster, it's cleaner.
  348. 1:01:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: easier understood. I think a die-type person.
  349. 1:01:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Yeah, the evolution of that, since it was first adopted, and how we applied our equity principles, I think it's more of a hybrid approach. It's not that we're not aware of the
  350. 1:02:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: the initial intent.
  351. 1:02:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: To have a strong price signal, but relying solely on that to manage our water reduction needs.
  352. 1:02:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Hasn't really played out.
  353. 1:02:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: enough to not have a separate drought plan, too. Yeah.
  354. 1:02:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Venue.
  355. 1:02:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I was just gonna say, I realize some of the commenters may have a different perspective on that, but that's…
  356. 1:02:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: kind of dealing with it day in and day out. That's how we've evolved.
  357. 1:02:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Yep.
  358. 1:02:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Sorry.
  359. 1:02:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I'm just thinking about, you know, the number of households, the number of single-family residences that fall in Tiers 1 and 2, versus… because the water budget is volume, right? Volume of water that's budgeted.
  360. 1:02:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: But the number of actual customers that fall, there could be one customer that's using a huge percent of the budget, right?
  361. 1:02:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Am I picking you out of this friend? So,
  362. 1:03:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Do you have a sense of the numbers of customers that have traditionally fallen in the 1 and 2 tier?
  363. 1:03:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Like, is that, you know, 20,000 accounts, or is that…
  364. 1:03:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: 10 accounts… 10,000 counts? Like, where does… what's the… what is the number like?
  365. 1:03:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Yeah, we do have that data, Amy. I don't know it off the top of my head, but I can… I can definitely follow up with you after this. I would say that generally the majority of customers outside of the summer months are falling with the Tier 1 and 2.
  366. 1:03:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And then you see a little bit more of those customers creep into Tiers 3 and 4. It's pretty rare that you would see a single-family resident hit that Tier 5,
  367. 1:03:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: not account for, like, leaks or something like that, but I would say I don't want to… I don't want to put a percentage… And it is seasonal as well, yeah. Right, right. But, we really don't have a lot of customers who fall outside of that second tier.
  368. 1:03:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: During, like, a non… a non-summer month, so…
  369. 1:04:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I think a big takeaway from this graph, is that, you know, we are seeing a lot more customers shift to an… shift into a lower bill, and so most of those decreases are small and go to the customers that already have that smaller bill, and so the increases,
  370. 1:04:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: fall on fewer, but those higher-use customers with the larger bills. So, kind of looking at it, it's like, wow, so many customers are going to see a decrease, but those decreases are likely, like, relatively small and much. Small decrease. Everything's going up, so it's nice. Something. Yeah. Well, I mean, I guess, like, as long as the people that are the most
  371. 1:04:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: using the most water are actually paying their bills. I hope so.
  372. 1:04:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Well, the other thing is, because of the drought, I suspect, and I know I, for one, so I'm here to pull out the sun.
  373. 1:04:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: grass, and I'm hearing from the landscaper, they're… they're busy.
  374. 1:05:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Because after the prop, because, yeah, did a lot of damage to humans.
  375. 1:05:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Hopefully, water municipalities should probably drop something.
  376. 1:05:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Sure.
  377. 1:05:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Kim did share…
  378. 1:05:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: the indoor-outdoor percentage is shifting because of the more efficient indoor use, and I imagine we'll see the same thing change.
  379. 1:05:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: look at an example of that. We put together a model of an average bill, so it takes into account those changes to the budget on both the indoor and the outdoor side. So reflecting a lower budget in tiers,
  380. 1:05:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: 1 and 2, and then also those lower rates that we mentioned. So here we'll see, it's about a $5 monthly decrease, but about 7,
  381. 1:05:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: A 7.8% decrease in the bill.
  382. 1:05:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: From status quo to the proposed.
  383. 1:06:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And so this was based on, 7, thousand gallon monthly consumption, that 12.7,
  384. 1:06:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: 1,000 gallon, yes, 12.7 thousand gallon, current budget, the reduction to about 10,000, 10.6 thousand gallons under proposed, due to those indoor and outdoor adjustments that we mentioned.
  385. 1:06:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So next we get into metered irrigation. So these are customers that only have an outdoor budget, no indoor budget. For all customers, there's some adjustment to the, ET factors, evapotranspiration factors.
  386. 1:06:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: But for metered irrigation, they did have a 1% allocation in those winter months. The adjustment here is moving that to 3% to cover that limited winter watering. I think, like Steph mentioned, the single-family residential, their budget already accounted for some of that, since metered irrigation doesn't have an indoor budget. This is to allow winter watering that they might have. So how much
  387. 1:07:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Watering, you know, once a month, but additional… once a week. How much additional watering might that…
  388. 1:07:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: allow for typical usage? I'm not sure. It depends on their…
  389. 1:07:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: their irrigable area, so it varies for each customer. They have an application rate, currently of 15, gallons per square foot. We adjusted that to 14 gallons per square foot, since now they're getting more of a budget allocation, but it would vary by customer.
  390. 1:07:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Since, I guess, my plea to City Council when I applied was climate change, so this is…
  391. 1:07:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And boy, we're seeing it this year. Look at this, I mean, these temperatures this week alone are a good, I think, 10 or more degrees above
  392. 1:07:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And besides that, Prusa.
  393. 1:07:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So, yeah, I think this whole… They're in.
  394. 1:07:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: October… October through March watering is probably… probably see some water.
  395. 1:08:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: not major, but some increases, just with, you know, let's hope we can start getting some decent moisture, too. Probably a new reality, as are…
  396. 1:08:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: extremes, like what's happening in southwest Colorado. I saw on the national news, the weather predictions, deep freeze next week in the Upper Midwest, and it's just…
  397. 1:08:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Yes.
  398. 1:08:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Yeah, yeah, that holds, more extremes. Yeah. Okay, but this is moving in the right direction.
  399. 1:08:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So then we have the proposed rates, for those customers. Similar to single-family, they're also seeing a slight decrease, in that fiscal year 2028 rate, as compared to status quo.
  400. 1:08:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Overall, they had, less of a change due to that increase in budget that they were receiving.
  401. 1:09:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And then we have the bill impacts for those customers, so approximately 61.1% of those customers experience a 5% change or less, so that's on either side of the dotted line, either a 5% increase or a 5% decrease.
  402. 1:09:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Approximately 51% of meter irrigation customers would see a lower bill. And then…
  403. 1:09:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: 1 in 25 customers would see an increase above 20%. So this would be due to those customers that are entering Tier 3 more quickly, and
  404. 1:09:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Continues to send that pricing signals, encouraging them to stay within their budget.
  405. 1:09:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And the meter, just remind me of these are the CII and the multifamily.
  406. 1:09:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: These are different, actually. These are metered irrigation, so it's, it's metered irrigation. Okay, right.
  407. 1:09:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So, so often, a commercial customer will have a metered irrigation if they have
  408. 1:09:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: an area, like, a separate meter. So, I think it's kind of easy to conceptualize our commercial customer class, pure commercial customer class as, like businesses on Pearl Street, but CU is an example of a commercial customer, an industrial customer that has separate metered irrigation accounts, and so these specifically are just talking about those metered irrigation,
  409. 1:10:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Yeah, the CU lawns look pretty green.
  410. 1:10:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I don't want to have the search.
  411. 1:10:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: They might be on the top end of this jack. So we did coordinate with them on drought messaging, and in their defense, I know they use a lot of irrigation ditch water, non-potable water, for their…
  412. 1:10:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: For their irrigation, so…
  413. 1:10:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: There's that. We did hear from a few community members about urban agriculture. Is that top… are they included in this category, or are they in CIO? They actually vary, so it's a really good question, and so…
  414. 1:11:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: as Joanna mentioned early on, we found that some of the urban ag customers, they have different needs, and some of that actually relates back to the customer type. So, some of these customers, are commercial.
  415. 1:11:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: customers, some of them have a legacy commercial account with a meter… with a… with an irrigation component. Some of them are strictly metered irrigation accounts, some of them are single-family residential accounts, so they really do kind of…
  416. 1:11:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: they're captured throughout. Do you know where they fall on the…
  417. 1:11:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: spectrum of the bill changes? We're starting to look at that more closely, so not… I don't want to call out specific customers, but we did look at a few, and it was interesting. One customer in particular had
  418. 1:11:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: commercial… had two different commercial accounts, and the way that the commercial rates that Carrie will show, it kind of ended up adding up zero to zero in terms of the change during that year. One of the customers we looked at had a slightly lower bill, but again, we're trying to make sure that we are fully capturing all those customers and looking at them on an individual basis.
  419. 1:12:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Okay. And one of…
  420. 1:12:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: the community members was talking about winter water rates and budgets, specifically. I guess, can you talk about that in the Urban Ag accounts, too? Like.
  421. 1:12:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Will that change? Is that something…
  422. 1:12:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Yeah, how are you thinking about that, specifically?
  423. 1:12:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So, in the single-family residential, so again, we do have some customers who fall in that single-family residential. We feel like
  424. 1:12:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: we have enough of a buffer within our indoor water budget to account for some winter watering, and we can look at that more closely with the specific customer. For customers who are on a metered irrigation account, they are getting the benefit of an expanded budget into the winter, so hopefully
  425. 1:12:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Those customers with metered urination account would see, the benefit of just, like, maintaining within their budget.
  426. 1:13:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: for customers, for urban ag customers who are on the inclining, meter block rate structure, which Carrie will get into more on the commercial side, there is no budget component, but we did try to set the rates,
  427. 1:13:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: in a way to where there's not massive block differentials, between, like, Block 1 and 4, to kind of help transition us into this new grade structure, and to also kind of take into consideration things that… like that, where people may need a little bit of water in the winter months. So, again, it's just…
  428. 1:13:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: It's kind of in different places, but we're hoping that these changes can help account for, some of the winter watering that would occur across all of these account types.
  429. 1:13:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Yeah, we need… we like Christmas treats. Thank you.
  430. 1:13:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So then we get into, commercial and multifamily proposed rates.
  431. 1:14:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So the proposal here is to move away from those water budgets and start using, meter-size-based inclining block rates. So to make those bills more predictable for customers and to help to alleviate some of that administrative burden that comes from the, large number of different, customer classes.
  432. 1:14:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: While still accounting for those differences in their water use. And we do that through, different block rates that we're going to look at on the next slide.
  433. 1:14:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Something else you'll see here are smaller steps in between those blocks, or reducing those block differentials. So they have a slightly higher, block 1 rate, and then, smaller steps in between each of those blocks.
  434. 1:14:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: That's something, that could be changed in the future, widening the space between those different hub blocks, but moving to this, since there's going to be such, like, a…
  435. 1:14:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: A change in the rate structure.
  436. 1:14:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And then… for some… This question, though, I think in the report was very good, but a statement was made that the
  437. 1:15:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: and it was playing on both of these, that there's not much sense… that the price doesn't induce much conservation. But I'm wondering, is there a difference between CII and multifamily? Because my sense is that businesses tend to be pretty…
  438. 1:15:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Cost-conscious, and caught increased costs, and anything.
  439. 1:15:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Let me drive them, try to use less of whatever input that is.
  440. 1:15:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So we are keeping the same rates for each customer class, but we're going to be looking at different block caps for them, so there'll be some slight changes, differences in how these rates are applied.
  441. 1:15:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Let me go ahead and show those. So for CII, this is, these are the block caps that we looked at. So, we put these together using the, percentiles of their current consumption, so that's where you'll see the differences between those two customer classes.
  442. 1:15:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So… am I getting kind of into what? No, but I'm just curious, maybe based on your experience, do industrial customers respond to a price… So… So, it's gonna depend on your community, and so, you use two different terms.
  443. 1:16:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: commercial and industrial. I was gonna say commercial, I mean… Yeah, and so if you're commercial, you know, it depends if they have any irrigation included in that one meter, and if they don't… if they don't… if you're a Wendy's.
  444. 1:16:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Restaurant, you're just gonna be just making your stuff and doing what you're able to.
  445. 1:16:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And then industrial, well, it depends what their product is, and what is your pricing for those folks.
  446. 1:16:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And I may just add real quick, and we can get more into this later, and we didn't wait to carry, but when we did the community engagement, particularly with the large water user groups that included both CII and multifamily,
  447. 1:16:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Many times, just administratively, the person paying the bill is not the person that is making monitoring decisions, nor is the person that's running the irrigation, right? So, there's a huge disconnect in between the financials and the actual operations, and so academically, as an exercise, it totally makes sense, and it breaks down practically.
  448. 1:17:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So I think that's a major barrier. We also heard that all…
  449. 1:17:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: both multifamily and CIA really valued predictability, so much so that they were willing to pay a little bit more so that they could budget a predictable bill. So we're trying to honor a lot of that in what we're proposing. Yeah, it just makes a lot more sense to me, rather than trying to set it based on each individual CIA is based on their business, because I thought that
  450. 1:17:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: maybe you raised some concerns, was it rewarded bad behavior? You know, we're not doing good. This, this just makes a lot more sense to me.
  451. 1:17:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Sure. And it takes care of businesses that change over. If you have a retail store that changes to a restaurant, they really… that restaurant really gets hit in the initial months until the, account type or the water budget catches up. So, this is more adaptable to the business needs as well.
  452. 1:18:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So, I'm a retail clothing store, and now I'm a restaurant. Am I going to change my meter slots, or… No, no, you just… your budget, right? So, currently, it's set based on either historic
  453. 1:18:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: monthly usage, or average winter consumption, or another method. But if you switch, it's… those methods only update once a year, and so you go with it, you know, the restaurant is going to have a huge increase initially. We can reset to the customer class average, but a lot of times that's the lower than what a restaurant would use. And so there's a lag in when the budget catches up, and so there's a several month
  454. 1:18:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: period where the bills are higher until that water budget adjusts. And the team tries to work with businesses and do things, but it's really,
  455. 1:18:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Again, it's one of those ideas that sounds really good on paper, but in practice, it ends up kind of unintentionally penalizing folks.
  456. 1:19:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Because there's… we don't have an adaptable mechanism that is universal to all of the businesses.
  457. 1:19:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And the team can correct me if I'm wrong here, but my impression is that we've been doing this work, and we've been talking to our consultants.
  458. 1:19:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Other cities that have water budgets.
  459. 1:19:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Don't try to have the level of complexity that we do with our commercial customers, and it just hasn't…
  460. 1:19:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: They tend to follow what is being proposed here. Yeah, makes sense. Just for practicality and…
  461. 1:19:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Keep it simple. Keep it simple, and…
  462. 1:19:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: It was a good concept in theory, but it just hasn't worked out as intended in practice.
  463. 1:19:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And, for those types of customers, trying to understand how to set up their accounts and what their options are.
  464. 1:20:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I just think there's a lot of confusion, and… Right. Well, I also think, frankly, if you're a large water user, whatever, you know, babe, you gotta pay more. You know, it just makes more sense to, you know…
  465. 1:20:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And I'll say, at the end of the day, if it's not affordable for them to be…
  466. 1:20:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: upward in Boulder, I mean, but, you know, they're using a lot of the resources, so it's, you know.
  467. 1:20:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Like, to have businesses survive, but if they're a huge water user.
  468. 1:20:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: you know, I know they're… the company's gonna ban data centers, so we don't deal with that issue, but they oughta pay a lot.
  469. 1:20:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And they do. I mean, currently, if you look at the amount of volume that our large water users are using, like, they're contributing the most revenues to the system. Yes, they should. Yes, they should. And I think one thing that I…
  470. 1:20:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: just wanted to reiterate and highlight here is that there… that in this rate structure, the CII rate structure.
  471. 1:21:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: there is a component of it where we're looking at our largest water users who might be on looped accounts, or really large meters, where setting these blocks doesn't really make sense. We are looking at a flat rate structure for those customers.
  472. 1:21:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: But that… that flat rate structure is based on, sort of, like, the percent of revenue that they are contributing to today, so we're not penalizing, but then we're also not cutting them a break. We're sort of maintaining the status quo. Okay, that's good. We're still… we're still looking at the, you know, the guardrails around that and the qualifying factors, but, just wanted to
  473. 1:21:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Put that out there, because that is a big change from what we currently have.
  474. 1:21:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So for those blocks, for these, customer classes, we looked at the, 50th, 75th, and 90th percentiles, as a basis for each of those blocks. So, for example, if we take these 1-inch meters, current consumption for those customers,
  475. 1:22:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: about 50% are using 7,000 gallons or less. So then for Block 2, that being 18,000, block 3, 50,000, and then Block 4 would capture any consumption that, goes over,
  476. 1:22:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: That 50,000 gallons, specifically for 1 inch meter, and so that's how we laid it out for all of these meter sizes.
  477. 1:22:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So here we have the billing sets for commercial customers. So, the median change would be about, a 4% reduction. The miners got pushed onto the other line, but that is a 4% reduction.
  478. 1:22:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: About 53.9% stay within 10% of their status quo bill. And then, like Steph mentioned, those outliers are under review, so those are mostly those larger meter sizes.
  479. 1:22:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: That might be on that, that, flat rate structure.
  480. 1:22:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: just to clarify, you may have said this already, or said it last time, you're familiar, but there's, like, 10 of those outliers? Like, there's not… there's not very many. There's not very many, but again, I think in looking at those parameters, we may need to expand that subset a little bit. So like Carrie mentioned.
  481. 1:23:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: You can probably see there's a 2%
  482. 1:23:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: 2% of accounts are getting a greater than 30% increase, so that's an example of accounts that are still kind of currently maintained within this new rate structure that don't qualify for this flat rate, and so is it fair to push some of those customers
  483. 1:23:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: into that 30% range, or should we consider looking at them on that flat rate structure? We're still looking at that a little bit more closely. And then, where it becomes
  484. 1:23:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: a little bit more complicated, and we'll get into the multifamily impacts, but on the multifamily
  485. 1:23:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: impacts and kind of, like, how do we… how do we expand that flat rate, or do we or don't we? As you know, we've got, manufactured housing communities that we want to be sensitive to, and so we're still kind of investigating that a little bit further.
  486. 1:24:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So, in this chart, do you know how many total customers this is?
  487. 1:24:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And the commercial, I think it's around 1,000? It's $5,000, okay.
  488. 1:24:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And one thing to keep in mind, too, you're moving to this new structure, and so, as Joe mentioned, we've got a forecast where we're
  489. 1:24:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Showing going out. But one of the things
  490. 1:24:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: want to track, see how this settles out, you know, as far as the consumption here. One of the things we're providing them is a model, so looking at how the commercial is moving, how their behavior… then you can adjust things as needed going forward. So.
  491. 1:24:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: That's good, yeah. Get it in place one year, they're gonna have the model.
  492. 1:24:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Just kind of look at it and see if you want to tweak it.
  493. 1:24:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I can guarantee you're not going to get it right 100% year one, because there's too much moving. And Joel, I misspoke, it's actually closer to 2,000 commercial customers. It's about 1,000 metered irrigation customers, so…
  494. 1:25:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Oh, I see, okay. So 2,000… so it's about 40 or so, roughly, to miss 2%. Yeah, okay. So at least small enough, you can…
  495. 1:25:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Work with the community to work with them, figure out what's…
  496. 1:25:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: reasonable, and also sends the right. Yep.
  497. 1:25:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So, we'll put the structure in place, but then the numbers and the levels and so forth can shift… you can shift those fairly easily, you imagine?
  498. 1:25:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I would say once we set a rate structure and have it approved through Council, that would need to hold in place for a year. But I think we're trying to… before we implement any sort of new rate structure, right, we would just want to make sure that we're solid and
  499. 1:25:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: and comfortable with the rate increases and do outreach for some of the customers that might see a much larger increase. Well, we wouldn't anticipate, like.
  500. 1:26:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I mean, obviously, you wouldn't anticipate a full grade study to come back and, like, make adjustments to the block sizes, right? Like, the caps and whatnot. If we notice after a year that
  501. 1:26:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: There's a… there are some weird things happening, we can ship.
  502. 1:26:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: We'll come back to WRAB, we'll talk about it. Yeah, exactly. That's the… And similarly, when… or maybe slightly different, just, Joanna mentioned that if there's drought going forward, there is the possibility, and Peter wrote this up in this
  503. 1:26:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: his memo to us, that you could use the block… the… you could use the budgets to help really push. And that, again, would go through some sort of
  504. 1:26:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: review or counsel approve more, or is that just something you could implement separately?
  505. 1:26:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: we could operationally make that change for a fixed period of time. It would then reset back to the whatever we set it at, assuming we go to 5.
  506. 1:27:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: 1,000 acre fee, we would reset it back to them, or she could temporarily rebower it. And I'm sure we wouldn't do that in a vacuum. We would come… there's no, like, there's no… that's an operational decision that doesn't need to go through some sort of approval correct. Right, right. It's… the drought plan is approved under city manager rule.
  507. 1:27:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: But when that kind of thing happens.
  508. 1:27:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: we… we let the board, we let Council know what we're thinking. That's great. Appreciate that. For that kind of thing, there's generally support when we're in that situation.
  509. 1:27:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And you all kind of see that…
  510. 1:27:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: like, ability to make those changes to the budget as one tool out of many that the utilities can use in response to drought. Where does that fall, like, on the scale of the other tools? Like, what other tools would you rather do first before you could… you alluded to this earlier, but…
  511. 1:28:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Well, I mean, I think you heard some of it, from the… Urban agricultural community that
  512. 1:28:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: The… pulling it down and, and, like.
  513. 1:28:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: having people pay higher bills, especially in a moment when the economy is… people are paying higher prices everywhere. We thought about that early this year, and just thought.
  514. 1:28:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: It's kind of situational, too, like, not that tool. Not right now.
  515. 1:28:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: But… I would say… This year's drought situation was striking, but we were in a decent supply situation.
  516. 1:28:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: If… if the… In a much more severe drought, we may not have
  517. 1:28:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: options, and it may force our hand to be more aggressive with those types of things. If we could not get those many storms.
  518. 1:29:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: It would have been very different, yes.
  519. 1:29:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So next, we get more into multifamily. So just as a refresher on commercial, for that 1 inch meter, we were looking at the firm block being around, 7,000 gallons for Block 1. Here, you can see for a 1 inch meter, it's at 10,000 gallons. So for multifamily overall,
  520. 1:29:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: their Block 1 and some of the Block 2 is a little bit higher than we saw in commercial. Some of this is due to those customers being on master meters and seeing more consumption in the lower tiers.
  521. 1:29:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Multifamily usage is also a bit steadier, so they have a higher average month, but fewer really high months. So we adjusted their blocks to reflect some of that. So they're using that same percentile approach as commercial, so that, 50th, 75th, and 90th percentiles.
  522. 1:29:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So, what does this… how does this… how does this break out on a per…
  523. 1:30:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: unit, you know, residential unit basis. I'm just wondering, a large… does a very large apartment complex
  524. 1:30:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: you know, I don't… what number that would be. Are they somehow paying more per…
  525. 1:30:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Yeah, per unit, per residential unit.
  526. 1:30:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: than a much smaller complex, or does that… I don't think the per unit rate should really shift a whole lot, but you're right. I mean, we have… we have, multifamily that could be a duplex or a triplex. We have, you know, apartments that could be 200 units, correct? So…
  527. 1:30:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I mean, if you're… if on average the rates are increasing, let's say, a 7% rate, you are going to be able to spread that
  528. 1:30:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: percent… that unit cost over more… over more units for a larger complex than you would a smaller unit. But we, you know, really did look to see how
  529. 1:30:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: these multi-tier blocks should be set, and how they should be different from the commercial blocks. And so we really tried to capture, those percentile usage using the block rate structure, and then also, we're also not setting those rates
  530. 1:31:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Between blocks, so, so high to where, you know.
  531. 1:31:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: a larger multifamily, unit would get hit with a much larger rate. So I think, Joel, it's a good question, but I don't think on a per-unit basis we're really… we should really see,
  532. 1:31:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: huge, huge increases for those… those large units versus the smaller ones. But I'm even curious just even what… what they're paying.
  533. 1:31:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Right? A duplex versus a… Oh, I see, I see. Oh, I see. Per…
  534. 1:31:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: you know, per family unit. What are they paying? We do have that data. I think I've provided some of that information maybe during, like, the budget process. Again, I don't have that memorized or off the top of my head, but I can certainly follow up. I appreciate that, yeah.
  535. 1:31:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And just a little caveat with that, I mean, we send the bill to the property manager or owner, or whatever, how they disseminate it, we don't have control over.
  536. 1:32:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I just think in terms of, you know, how that affects someone's rent, or however they've, you know, the property owner decides to have it paid for, but…
  537. 1:32:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I don't… you know, if somebody just happens to live in a large apartment building.
  538. 1:32:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: They shouldn't necessarily penalize versus someone who's in a duplex. That's the answer, or vice versa, you know, either way, it seems…
  539. 1:32:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Want some exclusive.
  540. 1:32:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Now, reasonable similarity.
  541. 1:32:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So that's… yeah, so if you provide that information, I make sure to see that. Yeah, and I'll reiterate what Joanna said, or just now, which is, yeah, we can see what the total cost of the bill is, but we don't know once the…
  542. 1:32:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: property owner passes that bill on to the customer, what they actually are paying, and how that gets absorbed in the… Yeah, I wouldn't sweat that. I'm just curious how difficult those terms are. Now, I see this differently than the CII.
  543. 1:32:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: You know, which you would have if you have an industry that's a big water server, well, that's different. They should pay a lot. Does the next slide show us what the impact is?
  544. 1:33:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Yeah, yeah,
  545. 1:33:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Yes. So, the majority of consumption for this class is, billed at that block one rate, so since it's slightly higher than under the status quo scenario, that's why you see a little bit more of that shifted to the right side of that dotted line. Approximately 50% of, accounts stay within 5% of the status quo comparison.
  546. 1:33:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So that brings us to next steps for our process. So I guess before I get into that, any questions or comments on any of those customer classes or the proposed rates?
  547. 1:33:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So for next steps, following this meeting, we plan on taking, your feedback, and then, through the additional, customer engagement, adjusting our analysis, to shape those final proposals.
  548. 1:34:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Steph, like Steph mentioned, the plan investment fee analysis that's going to be talked about in the January meeting.
  549. 1:34:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And then we're going to continue with the wastewater and stormwater cost associated services. And then all of that will be incorporated into our final report presentations.
  550. 1:34:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And then further on the next steps, the next few meetings, the January 25th WRAB meeting, followed by a February 11th City Council meeting, and then a February 27th.
  551. 1:34:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Next.
  552. 1:34:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And then for more information, here are some links for that, and then for, our contact information,
  553. 1:34:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: We have that available if there's any further questions.
  554. 1:35:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Thank you, guys. Thanks. Yeah, a lot of overlapping ideas and numbers and considerations, so thank you for…
  555. 1:35:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: There were so many layers. It was honestly daunting to try and determine, like, how to…
  556. 1:35:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Yeah, I mean, I guess, just thinking about the multifamily, I know that one of the takeaways from the cost of service was that if you really, like.
  557. 1:35:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: made it.
  558. 1:35:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: more equitable occurring according to cost of service, you would slow the rate increases for ag and multifamily, or sorry, commercial and multifamily. The increases for residential.
  559. 1:35:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: The metered irrigation would be higher. But then, when we look at, like, the cost impacts
  560. 1:35:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: chart that you just had up suggests that multifamily, with the status quo.
  561. 1:36:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: A lot of them are going to experience a slightly higher cost, but…
  562. 1:36:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: It's not really apples to apples, right? It's sort of a…
  563. 1:36:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Yeah. Time impact, timing, rates versus status quo, rate increases versus status quo, yeah.
  564. 1:36:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Yeah, I think, Amy, that's a really good point. I think for sure, once we land, the new rate structures we're looking at implementing will then
  565. 1:36:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: kind of follow up with the next analysis to try and right-size that cost of service a little bit better. But for now, we felt like a system-wide,
  566. 1:36:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: rate increase across all customer classes was just going to be easier to track and to kind of see really what those changes would do, for our different customer classes. So, it's a good point, and we'll definitely be, like, watching it quickly.
  567. 1:36:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: affordability impacts… impacts to customer classes also impacts to revenue, and collection, and what it means, so… And conservation. And conservation! Yes. It's a puzzle. It is a puzzle, and we're trying to…
  568. 1:37:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Find the right balance of all the things.
  569. 1:37:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And then, PIP, and you're gonna have to figure out how to make the developers pay for all. Well, I don't know what I want.
  570. 1:37:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: We're still trying to separately deal with this issue for, you know, low-income people. Yes, yes. And this is all against the backdrop
  571. 1:37:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So, there was a…
  572. 1:37:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: few folks, there was a watch and a Poke story about 6 months ago, where about just utility rates through the well aware of this, are just going up much faster than inflation, just nationwide, right? Yes. But, yeah, this is a struggle. Yeah, it really is.
  573. 1:38:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Thanks.
  574. 1:38:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Yeah, thank you so much. Nice work.
  575. 1:38:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Any other comments from anyone, or…
  576. 1:38:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I'm impressed with how many numbers we can… Carrie's in it, she bought it. We minimized the number of numbers we brought here. No, we didn't. Excellent presentation. We used 17.5% fewer numbers.
  577. 1:38:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Port was good, too. Yeah, very helpful.
  578. 1:38:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Okay,
  579. 1:38:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Katie, any questions from you? I think Katie's still online. She was online for a while, I did see her drop, at some point.
  580. 1:38:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Alright, well, I guess we'll move on to the next item, which is, matters from the board.
  581. 1:38:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Anybody? I just wanted to make an announcement that in January, I will be moving out of Boulder, so I will be leaving, the board, and so that will be my last meeting.
  582. 1:39:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: But thank you all so much, I've really enjoyed my time here, and I've learned a lot, and I look forward to doing more local government work in the future, so…
  583. 1:39:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I will be here in January, and I'm… I would love to help any way I can with, transitioning out of my role, filling my seat for the remainder of my trip.
  584. 1:39:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Thank you.
  585. 1:39:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: We've really appreciated you and your participation.
  586. 1:39:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Okay? Matters should stop.
  587. 1:39:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Well, just to segue on that, Katherine, we've appreciated your service and all the board members' willingness to volunteer and understand sometimes that it happens, that people move, and
  588. 1:39:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Life happens, and so… Appreciated your… your service, through the January meeting, and we'll…
  589. 1:39:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Wish you luck on what comes next.
  590. 1:40:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: In terms of matters from staff, really don't have a lot tonight. I think from month to month, I've been doing a really brief update on the water supply situation.
  591. 1:40:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And, it's kind of the water year, outdoor watering year is kind of winding down. People are shutting down their irrigation systems, and probably really should be soon, or risk freezing issues.
  592. 1:40:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Just looking at some of the numbers that Kim shared with me in graphic for the past few months, demand has been tracking below the 5-year average. I think it's been a little bit wetter.
  593. 1:40:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: We got more rain in this…
  594. 1:40:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: it is a little strange that we're this deep into November, and
  595. 1:40:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Still exercising outside with not having gloves on, and…
  596. 1:40:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: That kind of thing, but…
  597. 1:40:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Overall, I think, doing okay, and the drought management approach this year has… has…
  598. 1:41:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: We met the goals that we did it to, and we didn't have to make major operational change… changes for…
  599. 1:41:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Whiplash with our community members taking one approach or another, so we appreciate everyone's response to that.
  600. 1:41:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So that's what I have from Matters, and if you'd like, I can switch to the upcoming agenda. This will be our last board meeting for 2026.
  601. 1:41:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And then coming up in January, just the way things are working out, we really do try to balance agendas, but we have 3 fairly information items that night. Always like to do our utilities year-end review.
  602. 1:41:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And, it's kind of like our annual report. And having that report out to WRAB makes us accountable to making sure we do it.
  603. 1:42:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: And then, a really important topic is our integrated water supply plan, and so having an initial discussion with the board on that in a kickoff. Because it's a kickoff, maybe not as much depth as when we really get down to the heart of it in later
  604. 1:42:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Months and years. And then, as you just heard, we'll be talking about the utilities rate study and plant investment.
  605. 1:42:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So that, that's how it's shaping up for January. It may be that when we map out the time allotted.
  606. 1:42:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: I think we've established a really good culture with the board in finding the time, and have… generally having board meetings finished by 8, but we may have to…
  607. 1:42:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: might need to be a little bit longer. Thank you for the advance notice. But we also push on ourselves to keep things tight, so I'm not giving up on any of the call.
  608. 1:43:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: So we're not committing to not ask the question. Well, they're important topics, and I thought tonight was a great presentation and a great discussion lead for the board, so we don't want to…
  609. 1:43:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: shortcut.
  610. 1:43:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: There have been years in the past where board meetings went till 10 p.m. or midnight. I don't know that we want to return to that.
  611. 1:43:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: That's what I have for the upcoming schedule. All right. Thank you, Joe. Thanks. Okay, if there are no other matters from the board, can we get a motion to adjourn?
  612. 1:43:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Don't move. Second? Okay.
  613. 1:43:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: All in favor of adjourning, please raise your hand and say yes. Aye. Aye.
  614. 1:43:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Okay, seeing and hearing none opposed, we're adjourning the meeting at 7.45 p.m.
  615. 1:43:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Thank you.
  616. 1:44:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker WRAB Host: Music.