Transcript: 10-28-26 Housing Advisory Board Meeting
October 28, 2026
Each time links to the meeting video at that moment. Speaker names appear only where the source gives them; otherwise the speaker is shown as Unknown speaker. Open the meeting video (opens in a new tab).
- 0:00:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Maybe count.
- 0:00:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Hello!
- 0:00:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Tiffany, at some point, I think Eli is gonna be Zooming. Okay.
- 0:00:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I'll keep an eye out for them.
- 0:00:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Alrighty.
- 0:00:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Hello, everyone. I'm Karin Hoskam, the chair of the Housing Advisory Board. Welcome to our monthly meeting. Today is…
- 0:00:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: October 28th.
- 0:00:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah, 28.
- 0:00:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We'll start with a roll call. Lauren Schevets?
- 0:00:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Fear.
- 0:00:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Brendan Selby? Here. Chip Pennessy? Here. David Garbed? Here. Philip Ogren? Here. Shira is not here in person, is she online? Okay. And our planning board liaison, Max Lord. Yeah, here.
- 0:00:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Also, we have two guests tonight, one joining us right now, Dan McCauley. McCauley, thank you. And then, Eli Irkin will be, zooming in in a little while.
- 0:01:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: All right, so, reviewing the agenda, we'll, approve the minutes. We'll have time for some public participation, if there is anyone.
- 0:01:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Then the matters from the board tonight are Habitat for Humanity Affordable Ownership Model, and then the City of Boulder Permanently Affordable Homeownership Program.
- 0:01:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We'll take a look and do some brainstorming for the work plan, and then, look at a letter to Council regarding San Lazaro, Park.
- 0:01:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Any matters from the staff, final thoughts, and then we will adjourn by 9. Hopefully everybody got, the minutes from September. Was there any comments or corrections to be made?
- 0:01:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Nope.
- 0:01:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Alright, well then, I'll make the motion to approve them.
- 0:02:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Second. Fantastic, all in favor?
- 0:02:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Aye. None opposed? So the motion is approved.
- 0:02:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Public participation. Tiffany, do we have anybody?
- 0:02:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Tonight?
- 0:02:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: There's a member of the public, but no hands are currently…
- 0:02:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So, if you would like to speak, raise your hand so Tiffany can… Let you talk.
- 0:02:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Alright.
- 0:02:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So then we'll just get right to it, then. Matters from the board. So, Dan McCauley, Habitat for Humanity Affordable Homeownership Model. You are the Executive Director of Flatirons Habitat for… That is correct. I'm Executive Director and CEO for Flatirons Habitat for Humanity. We serve
- 0:02:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: the parts of Boulder County that are served by the Boulder Valley School District, and all of the city and county of Bloomfield. So we have a little bit of the Adams School District. A little bit about Habitat,
- 0:03:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So, Habitat is a affiliated nonprofit model, which means we have a corporate office. They don't like it when I call it that, but that's essentially what it is, our international office, in Atlanta, and then we are an affiliate of that larger organization.
- 0:03:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Big Habitat is celebrating its 50th anniversary this year, having been founded on Koinonia Farm in 1976. The work of Habitat started
- 0:03:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: 25 years prior to that founding.
- 0:03:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: As Poinanilla Farm was established as a place where Blacks and whites, men and women worked together, were paid the same wages, you know, completely radical model for
- 0:04:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Southern Georgia in 1940.
- 0:04:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: That work carries forward as we do our work now. Flatirons Habitat for Humanity started organizing in about 1990.
- 0:04:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We were officially chartered in 1993, and have built, in that time, roughly 140 homes.
- 0:04:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We are…
- 0:04:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I think it's safe to say we are the only housing organization doing home ownership for families earning at or below 80% of AMR.
- 0:04:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Which, in markets like the one I came from, in Brookings, South Dakota, that wasn't all that difficult. In markets like Boulder and Greenfield, it presents significant challenges.
- 0:05:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: To qualify for a Habitat mortgage.
- 0:05:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: A family must qualify on three criteria.
- 0:05:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: They must meet our income qualifications, which means they have to be between 30% and 80% of the AMI.
- 0:05:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I, as a practical matter, we serve families at 60 and AMI and above, because the discounts get so deep.
- 0:05:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: That it becomes very, very difficult to cash flow. A housing unit that cost me $400,000 to build and sell it at $150, it's just simply… the numbers are very, very hard to make work.
- 0:05:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So they have to qualify, on that criteria. They have to qualify on a criteria called need for housing, which means their current housing needs to be too small. Children of different genders sharing the same bedroom, parents and children sharing the same bedroom.
- 0:06:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Children separated by significant age, sharing the same bedroom. Unsafe.
- 0:06:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: mold, security issues, windows that don't open or close, etc. Or too expensive.
- 0:06:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: That is typically where most of… we don't have to go into those other criteria because our families are going to qualify on the too expensive metric, which is, are they paying more than 30% of their gross monthly income for their housing costs?
- 0:06:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: The third criteria is that they need to agree to… they want… need to be able to partner with Habitat, which means they need to be able to do their sweat equity, they need to be willing to…
- 0:06:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: join the Habitat family and program, as part of their mortgage process. Flatirons Habitat does not originate any of our own mortgages at this point. We have not been doing that for some time.
- 0:07:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Which means my home ownership team works with the family, does all of the vetting, makes sure that they qualify on all of those program criterias, and then we hand that file off to a willing,
- 0:07:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: for-profit banking partner, or the IDF, or some other program that we might be able to connect them with, so that they do pay a mortgage.
- 0:07:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Connect them with partners that are giving them a point or two below market.
- 0:07:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We're working very, very hard to find
- 0:07:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: More generous terms for our families, but even if… but we factor that home payment, that mortgage piece of the mortgage, into the calculation, and so they are not paying more than 30% of their gross monthly income, on their housing costs.
- 0:08:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: When I started at Flatirons Habitat in May of 2024, we had roughly 1,500 families on a list. It's not a waiting list, it's just we have only the names and their email addresses.
- 0:08:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: They're waiting to begin the program. We don't know how many of those 1,500 families will qualify.
- 0:08:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: But they are there. As we open a new development, we can say we have this housing product at this address at roughly this price point. Is that something you are interested in? And then the 500 or so families that respond to that email will go through a pre-qualification exercise.
- 0:08:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Are you a good candidate for this?
- 0:08:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: If they have any kind of debt, or a cell phone bill, or anything, their debt-to-income ratio, it's really easy to get too high, so we work with them.
- 0:08:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: For another round, and then they go through… those that make it through that pre-qualification exercise, then go into a formal mortgage process.
- 0:09:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Sign a partnership agreement, begin to do their sweat equity, and then work toward buying their home.
- 0:09:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We see roughly 10 families for every qualified mortgage.
- 0:09:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We try very, very hard to never say no.
- 0:09:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You said 10 families for every qualified market. Did you mean 10 qualified families? No, we see 10 families who are willing to buy
- 0:09:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: 5150 Cherry, 9 of them will not qualify for a mortgage, and then we'll get to a qualified mortgage.
- 0:09:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We have not yet had the problem where we have…
- 0:09:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: 10 qualified families for 5 houses.
- 0:09:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: But we are… the board is now working its way through
- 0:09:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: A process where we will have a distinguished priority list.
- 0:10:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: To help us sort through the eventuality when we get to
- 0:10:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: we have 10 homes, we have 100 families that qualify, what do we do with that to help us get… but currently, we don't have that, and we're not faced with that problem. How do down payments work?
- 0:10:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We often don't require a down payment. So… and there are… so…
- 0:10:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We are in an unusual situation in that we are currently partnered with the City of Boulder in the redevelopment of the Ponderosa Stabilization Project. That is an entirely different model than the one that I just
- 0:10:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Described to you.
- 0:10:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: That model is handled largely by the City of Boulder's Affordable Housing Program, and
- 0:11:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Costing, down payments, what the family gets paid for their… their trailer, how all of that works is outside of what my home ownership team
- 0:11:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: works with the families and helps them through that process, but it is outside of a typical Habitat program.
- 0:11:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: This oversimplifies the relationship, but largely what has happened is the city has hired Flatirons Habitat to be their general contractor for that project. That's, again, that's an oversimplification, but it describes it pretty well with Ponderosa.
- 0:11:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I would imagine that we will be in partnership with the city
- 0:11:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: In other development projects, where we will have…
- 0:11:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: not typical family selection, family screening processes in place. Anytime that I…
- 0:11:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: go to over 80% of AMI, I need to get permission from Habitat International.
- 0:12:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: To do that.
- 0:12:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So for our project on Violet Avenue, we've done 7 homes at 60% of AMI. The next 12 will be a combination between 80 and 100.
- 0:12:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I have to get permission for that. If we go into a project where the city wants to sell to 120,
- 0:12:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I'll need to get permission for that. It's just part of what I have to do. They've never ever said no. Not sure what it's going to take to get them to say no, not willing to press that apple.
- 0:12:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So, as I mentioned, I started in this role in May of 2024. Prior to coming to Boulder, I served as Executive Director for Brookings, South Dakota, which is a small market affiliate, and it was well
- 0:12:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: funded.
- 0:13:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: For the last two and a half years. Perfect.
- 0:13:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: the last two years, or the last two and a half, my work here has been stabilizing Flatiron's Habitat for Asian path. I don't think it's going to be shocking to anybody in the room, but the affiliate was in deep organizational and financial crisis when I came.
- 0:13:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We have worked our way through that, largely, and are on moderately strong financial footing.
- 0:13:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And organizationally, we are a much different organization. There's almost nothing about Flatirons habitat that is the same as it was when I started two and a half years ago.
- 0:13:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: What was the cause of the organizational crisis?
- 0:13:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Multi-pronged, some off-mission, bad business deals. My predecessor bought a 10,350 square foot home in Broomfield and was operating that as a
- 0:14:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: 55 and older, income-qualified co-housing.
- 0:14:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Which is not even tangential to our mission, and it didn't cash flow. And then it took us a really long time to sell that property. That was a big piece of it.
- 0:14:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: there were some other organizational things, I couldn't find any
- 0:14:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: strategy that had been applied to fundraising.
- 0:14:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And so we had to… we had to correct some things. I had way too small of a team, and they were doing the wrong things. So we've been able to fix through… fix through all of that, largely by doing what I call Nonprofit 101. Just go back to the basics, you pay attention to your mission.
- 0:15:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You identify donors, you ask them for money, you follow up, you give them touch points, you kind of do the work, and then a big part of that stabilization was making good on the promises that the organization had made to outside partners.
- 0:15:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: like, staffing up and building the Boulder Mod facility.
- 0:15:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Our budget in 24 was $1.2 million. Our budget this year is $12 million.
- 0:15:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I think we will settle in at 20 or 25 million once we are fully…
- 0:15:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Right-sized for, for, what we're gonna be doing.
- 0:15:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: How many staff members do you have? Like, full-time? 16 right now.
- 0:15:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: when I started, we had one construction person. I now have…
- 0:15:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I have 8 in the factory alone.
- 0:15:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So…
- 0:16:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Plus, we have a finance team, plus we have an operations team, you know, homeowner services, all those kinds of critical functions.
- 0:16:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: With the Bouldermont factory, I think you are well aware of what's going on there. I'm not going to go into great detail, but what that will mean is that we will have 40 to 50 homes under warranty at any time. We warranty all of our products for one full year from closing, and given that we're going to have that… we hope that there won't be many warranty issues with the homes, but there are going to be some, so we're looking very seriously.
- 0:16:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We're launching a repairs program.
- 0:16:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: For families in that same income qualification, where we might go out and do the kind of repair that, if it is not made, the family will have to leave their home.
- 0:16:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: My thinking is that there's no less expensive, or there's no more affordable home than the house the family already owns. So if we can repair a front porch, if we can put grab bars in the bathroom, if we can widen an entry door to accommodate a wheelchair.
- 0:17:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: That's really good invested money.
- 0:17:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: But we haven't done any of the market analysis, I don't know who's already in doing that.
- 0:17:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I don't know what kind of need there is, but we are going to explore that in the coming, coming months.
- 0:17:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: The Boller mod has been critical.
- 0:17:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: to bringing us from financial instability, organizational instability, to where we are now. We have had to, in very short order, develop enormous
- 0:17:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: capabilities that we did not have two years ago. But in doing that, it's like we have this big lit
- 0:17:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Flashing billboard about what we are capable of doing, and that is drawing attention, both, media, donors, and volunteers.
- 0:18:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: almost a year ago now, the Boller County Community Foundation of Boulder County invested $3 million of their, Marshall Fire, recovery money with us. We will be doing a development in Louisville as quickly as I can get that land through entitlement.
- 0:18:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So we'll be doing, in partnership with Thistle Community Housing, almost 40 homes.
- 0:18:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: In Louisville.
- 0:18:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: behind that, from the factory? They'll…
- 0:18:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: All but the market rate homes will come out of the factory, yeah.
- 0:18:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So, like, all but 8 of them will come out of the factory. And we're working on different designs to make that neighborhood, you know, something that nobody wants to live in the third yellow one on the left, right? We want some architectural interest and that kind of stuff. Behind thistle.
- 0:19:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We have… we're currently in negotiation on an LOI with Roeberry Development out of Denver on a 38-home development that will go into the baseline development on the north end of Broomfield.
- 0:19:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We're very excited about where that project is going. And then we've got some other stuff. The city owns some land on Belmont that we think we will be in partnership with. We've got to finish
- 0:19:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Violet Avenue, we're going to be in and out of Ponderosa, I think, probably for the next decade, as that is proving far more complicated than anybody imagined, and we imagined a great deal of complexity there. So, you know.
- 0:19:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: there's a sewer line that nobody knew about. Where did that come from? Well, let's deal with it, right? And then… and the other thing that,
- 0:20:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Last fiscal year, we had almost 19,000 volunteer hours donated to us, and that is a cash gift equivalent to $680.
- 0:20:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So as I said, Boller Mod is that big, shiny billboard, drawing attention to us.
- 0:20:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: What I spent most of the day working on today is we've received funding from a private foundation to develop a decision-making model framework for other Habitat affiliates considering a Boller Mott factory, because we get visited
- 0:20:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: probably once a month from another affiliate, looking at trying to do this somewhere else in the United States.
- 0:20:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It's a real fast kind of walk through what we're doing. Are there questions I can answer?
- 0:20:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Good question, when I was in college, I…
- 0:20:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: worked on building a house with Habitat in New Orleans, and that was, like, you know, brick and mortar foundation, normal house, and there was, like, a Habitat employee who supervised, like, 100 volunteers. My question for you is.
- 0:21:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: How much of that are you doing compared to, like, the mod factory model, and do you think the Mod Factory model is more cost-efficient, a better route for Habitat to go in the future? Sure. So, we are all in on Boulder Mod as our construction
- 0:21:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: process. We are going to come across families
- 0:21:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: That cannot live in what we're building in the factory.
- 0:21:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And in that case, so we have a family that's intergenerational and they need a first floor bedroom and bathroom for ground, or they have mobility issues and they're not going to be able to live in a house with stairs. We will simply hire a general contractor to say, build this house here.
- 0:21:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And then just turn it over to them, then we'll handle the homeowner side of it, and sell it, and work through. But we're… we are all in on Boller Mod, so that will be our delivery mechanism.
- 0:22:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: For housing in this community.
- 0:22:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: How that works with volunteers and homeowners, they simply do that in the factory. The challenge we're coming across now is volunteers really like to build with the homeowner.
- 0:22:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And we're…
- 0:22:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: building them… they move through the factory so quickly that it's hard to make that happen in an intentional way. Because if it's taking you 9 months to build a house on site, well, you can simply schedule your family there on certain days, and volunteers can come build with them. But when it's only taking 15 weeks.
- 0:22:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It's really hard to make those connections, so we're working on figuring that out.
- 0:22:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Now, it's a challenge that we've just recently come across. But we're still a Habitat affiliate, so families still do sweat equity. We still build with volunteers. The consultant the city hired to help stand up Boller Nod told me in one of our early meetings that I was going to need 50 full-time staff.
- 0:23:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I have 8.
- 0:23:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And we're building them faster than we have places to put them. And you think it's a much more efficient way to put out housing for… Yes, so the first two that went through, we knew we were going to be slow and expensive, because we had to stop at every station and…
- 0:23:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Figure stuff out, but those cost us a little over half a million dollars apiece.
- 0:23:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We're now down to, minus affiliate overhead, about $380,000 a unit. And coming from South Dakota.
- 0:23:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I could build a mansion for $380,000. I was really freaked out by that number.
- 0:23:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: But then I learned that our friends who are building affordable rental are spending twice that on a two-bedroom apartment.
- 0:23:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And we're building a 3-bedroom house.
- 0:23:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So, I feel better about the number. I simply have just…
- 0:24:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: call that the Boller bonus, because I have to pay more for staff than they do in Walmart. I just have to.
- 0:24:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: The, the 380 number is for the cost for the next unit.
- 0:24:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It's… it's not a… it's not a averaging over the… No, it's… it's… so we… we wrote a… we wrote a grant for the, four houses on South Boulder Road. That's the number that came directly out of the grant.
- 0:24:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So that's… that's what our current cost is. Is it through the real estate, or is that just the cost to build it? No, we got the land for free, although it's gonna cost me a million dollars to develop it, because nobody gives me the land.
- 0:24:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: That means they can develop a business. If they can't, they give it to Habitat. But you're saying it's $380 to build… So that's everything connected to the house. That's not just inside the factory, that's foundations and site work and that kind of stuff, too.
- 0:25:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: foundations.
- 0:25:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Utilities, etc.
- 0:25:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And we hope that number will go down, but it probably won't go down by much.
- 0:25:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You know, I've been to the factory, I haven't been to any of these installed units. Maybe that's a good field trip idea in the future. We're gonna set, again, we hope.
- 0:25:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Depending on how long it takes for some asbestos remediation to happen, we hope we're going to set again at the end of January. We'll be sure to invite this group. It's kind of fun. It's like 5 minutes of excitement, followed by 20 minutes of standing around waiting for the next one to come. But, and then we've got one
- 0:25:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: on-site that is not yet sold, we could, probably make arrangements to get you into a
- 0:25:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Finished unit, provided it's… Not been sold today, you know, before we can get you in there.
- 0:25:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So you said a few things that defied my own expectations.
- 0:26:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: One is, the last thing I thought I heard you say is you have more units. You're building them faster than you can deploy them. Yes.
- 0:26:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I just assume that there's way more demand than there is. Oh, yeah, absolutely. So, it's not… it's not a home buyer demand issue. It is a… two and a half years ago, we bought… we thought the first three years of production were all going to go into Ponderosa. Oh, yeah.
- 0:26:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And so I didn't I didn't… wasn't standing on my construction director's neck to get land ready.
- 0:26:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah. Honduras is moving more slowly than we thought it was, so now we're backing up, and I don't have another place to put them right now. In 6 months… You've got stuff that's ready to come. Yeah, in 6 months, I've got room for 120 houses.
- 0:26:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: But right now, I don't.
- 0:26:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I don't know, so 120 houses is three and a half, four years of…
- 0:27:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: of, production. I'd like my board to have 8 years of land in bank.
- 0:27:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Because it takes…
- 0:27:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: 5 or 6 to get it from bare ground to being able to put in a foundation. So we're not quite there yet.
- 0:27:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: But we're working on it. What's the max yearly output you expect? The consultants tell us 25, we think 30. And, if we can be really, really good neighbors.
- 0:27:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And the neighbor stops sitting on their porch with binoculars and calling me every time we do something that we're not supposed to. And we can push maybe a longer work day.
- 0:27:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You know, maybe we can build 12 hours a day instead of 8, then we can maybe get that up to 50.
- 0:27:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah. And so when you say 50, that's…
- 0:27:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: generally too… too much. That's 50 families a year served. When I talk about production, I talk about it in full houses, or families. Yes, but right now, each duplex is for, for lack of a better word, boxes. Yeah.
- 0:28:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Two units. Right. So each house is… each family is two boxes, first floor and second floor.
- 0:28:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I'm a lawyer, I worked on a foreclosure once where Habitat wasn't here. Habitat was lean holder, they were foreclosing. I've been through that, it's horrible.
- 0:28:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: you said that you guys use private banks? What's, like, what's the reason for that? Can you just talk about that a little bit? Sure, because I,
- 0:28:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: The federal oversight and regulation for originating your own mortgages is onerous.
- 0:28:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And, to fund our own mortgages. So if we're…
- 0:28:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: building for $400, selling for $250,000. I've already got to come up with a $150,000 subsidy, and then to fund that $250,000 mortgage for 30 years is just really bad business, right? Because particularly if we're not charging interest on them, they just sit on our… I mean, it's just… it's…
- 0:29:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: it's a very poor use of our money, and it's money that I currently don't have. So that's why we've gone to third-party… third-party direct lending. Some exciting things that are happening. Habitat Metro Denver is working to create a mortgage fund
- 0:29:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: that they would then loan direct lend to other habitats, at 2 or 3 points below… below market, and then they'll sell them to CHAFA or other buyers and recoup their funds. So, some things are happening.
- 0:29:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: But right now, I'm going to whomever, can… can meet our demand. Like, we were at Alpine for a while, because they've got a good program. Not sure where we're going to be next.
- 0:29:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I could also see why maybe Habitat doesn't want to be, like, the bank foreclosing on someone when, you know, recognition is to help. I mean, I get it why lenders have to foreclose sometimes, but…
- 0:30:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It was… it was… it was… I did it in South Dakota, it was 25 years, it was the first foreclosure, and leading the board through that was horrible. And then sitting across the table, the attorney's table, with the buyer that you had worked
- 0:30:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah. To get into a house in the first place. It was… it was emotionally, it was horrible.
- 0:30:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I'm… I'm…
- 0:30:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: new to the board and don't know the background with Ponderosa, is there… what is the… The Ponderosa Stabilization Program is, the rehabilitation and redevelopment of a distressed mobile home park that is in North Boulder.
- 0:30:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: it, very quickly, it grew up in the 40s and 50s as a place for Midwesterners to park their campers for the summer. It was way outside the city at that point. The city grew up to it. It,
- 0:31:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: transitioned from, you know, an Airstream for 3 months to a permanently placed mobile home.
- 0:31:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: They were added onto and built with little oversight, so we're not really sure
- 0:31:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: like, you know, 2 months ago, we came across a sewer line that nobody knew was there. So, but it was heavily impacted by the flood.
- 0:31:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: The city bought the property, annexed the property, brought it in, spent $6 million-ish or so on, you know, things that did not exist, like roads and sewer systems, and put that in, and then a commitment has been made to the current residents.
- 0:31:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: That you will not be displaced.
- 0:31:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: by new construction. So, some of the complication that we're navigating is…
- 0:32:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: okay, we need this family to either move to a different trailer or agree to buy one of these houses, so we can demo their trailer and build this out. So that's why we're going to probably go in fits and starts. We'll do, you know, another
- 0:32:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: 8 or 10 months of work there now, and then we'll probably sit for 2 years.
- 0:32:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Until there's enough open space to go back in and redevelop another block.
- 0:32:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: How did Habitat get selected as the… to do this? So, there are very few nonprofit developers in town that do, affordable home owner… ownership.
- 0:32:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And the genius of… Boulder Mod, and the City, and Habitat, and the School District Partnership.
- 0:32:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: lives in one human being who used… who was among the founders of the Habitat Affiliate, used to teach the… the building trades program at the high school, and currently runs the city's Affordable Home Ownership Program.
- 0:33:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Kurt Fernhopper.
- 0:33:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Did I say that right? Beautiful. Yeah. The detail of the city owning Ponderosa is unique to all mobile home parks in the area. Very few cities would own a mobile park. Yeah.
- 0:33:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It was… gives… gives a bit more… But it's no longer a mobile home park. Well, it's… it's part… we've got 6… we've sold 4, we've got 6 sitting there. We'll set 4 more this winter. It's transitioning.
- 0:33:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: But it is still very much a distressed mobile home park. Because these are not mobile homes. No. These are… What we are… what we are building are… Just west of Broadway. …super energy efficient.
- 0:33:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Permanently… permanent foundation, 1,150 square foot, three-bedroom, one and a half bath, two-story, Duplexes.
- 0:34:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And then the people who buy it, they own the building and the land underneath it. They own… it's like, in Ponderosa, it's like they're buying a condo.
- 0:34:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So the condo or homeowners association takes care of everything behind the drywall.
- 0:34:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I'll move through.
- 0:34:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: which is real property. In Colorado, mobile homes are basically recognized vehicles. So, you…
- 0:34:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Often will own it, or you could lease it, but it's a vehicle, and if you stop paying your rent, the landlord can… the mobile home park can evict you, and tell you to move your mobile home.
- 0:34:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Right. Which is very different from here, where I guess if someone stops paying their HOA dues, they get foreclosed on by the HOA, and if they stop paying their mortgage, they get foreclosed on by the bank. Exactly.
- 0:34:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Exactly.
- 0:34:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Other questions?
- 0:35:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Start off by saying that you've built 140 units in your entire history? Yes.
- 0:35:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So that's…
- 0:35:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Not very many… Yeah, it's a very slow output, per year, but I assume that number's just…
- 0:35:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So,
- 0:35:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Prior to 2023, our historical average was 3 houses a year. In the 3 years prior to my arrival.
- 0:35:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We hadn't sold a house.
- 0:35:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Our construction timelines have slipped to…
- 0:35:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: 36 months per unit. Was that impacted post-COVID, or… There's a lot that goes into that. This is a public meeting, I'd prefer not to go into much detail there.
- 0:35:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Happy to talk about it privately. But Boulder Mod will then take us from… so last year, we did 12. This year, we have 19.
- 0:35:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Next year will probably be 20 or 25, depending on funding and land availability, and then we'll settle in at 30-ish a year.
- 0:36:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And then that's sort of…
- 0:36:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: where our glide plane will be until and if we can expand production capacity, hours, etc. So where… so…
- 0:36:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: There's not a lot of land available, so is there the… potential…
- 0:36:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: for there to not be any more land in Flatirons, habitats.
- 0:36:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So there's… Review, and then what? Well, so… Is that possible? I'm sure, yeah, it's possible. Room is about build-out. But then if you talk to landowners, it's like, well, no, I got 50 acres sitting over here that I don't know what to do with.
- 0:37:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I… I don't… I don't imagine a scenario in which we won't have
- 0:37:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: places to build. My current land acquisition strategy is to come alongside major developers like Realberry, and say, let me solve your inclusionary zoning. You just give me the land, I'll build the houses, you get the credit, I take all the risk, and we're done.
- 0:37:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Do you think this Ponderosa project has made the cost of living more expensive for residents in Ponderosa? No. No? Because what they're doing, so, I was talking with a recent home buyer
- 0:37:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And we're standing on his front porch, and
- 0:37:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I said, you know, how's your house? Is everything going alright? Is there anything that we need to fix? No, no, Dan, everything's great. I said, what's, you know, what's the biggest change you've noticed? He goes, Dan, I have to go now, I have to come out onto the front porch to know what the weather is like.
- 0:38:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Well, I mean, the reason… He's a trading and energy bill?
- 0:38:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: for a mortgage. The reason I ask that question is it's been my experience working with people who are being evicted from their mobile homes, that most mobile homes in Boulder are essentially… I want to say this caveat, because it's a lot of money to certain people, but
- 0:38:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: to your average, like, market analyst, they're essentially worthless, because they're all so old. This is, like, a 50-year-old mobile home that's in horrible condition, and you can't even move it, or else it'll fall apart. So, like, people will often sell them to each other for, like, under $10,000 in cash.
- 0:38:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And really, it's sort of like the unit itself
- 0:38:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I mean, it's not a great place to live, but it's essentially, like, nothing. And then the land underneath it, paying that rent is really their big cost. And it's…
- 0:38:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: from just what I've seen, it's, like, the cheapest way of living in Boulder. It probably doesn't meet this… and not all mobile homes are, like, some are new and nice. Right. But what I'm talking about, it's super cheap, and some people have, like, 6 people living in it. It doesn't meet what most of us would probably recognize as, like, a minimum
- 0:39:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: standard of life, and it kind of seeps through habitability laws, because they own this house, and the landlord's not on the hook for the quality of the house, only for the lot space. In Ponderosa, the city is charging a below-market lot rent.
- 0:39:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I think I'm saying that correctly. And they're trading a $600 or $800 a month energy bill?
- 0:39:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: For a comparable-sized mortgage, and they're getting a super energy-efficient house that is
- 0:39:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: you know, we're going to reduce the num… the unit count in Ponderosa, but we're more than doubling this livable spread. I mean, I've encountered mobile homeowners who couple stoves, which is not safe, but but I guess the point I'm making is, like, I have encountered a lot of people who have a very low housing bill for a very…
- 0:40:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: below what should be quality of life. And my concern, I just… I'm curious, as we provide people with a much better quality of life, is that also just sort of pricing them out? So,
- 0:40:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I don't know the details of what people are buying their houses for, but I have heard numbers below $200,000.
- 0:40:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: In Ponderosa.
- 0:40:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: For some families, we… so we… Habitat had, like I said earlier, we had to get permission anytime we go above 80, to work in Pine de Rosa, we had to get permission, because we're serving families below 30. Sure. So, and again, the whole pricing structure is set that that payment
- 0:40:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Will be no more than 30% of their gross monthly income.
- 0:41:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And there are some folks in there that have very low incomes.
- 0:41:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I hear your concern,
- 0:41:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And the other… the other thing about Ponderosa is nobody is being displaced. Nobody is being…
- 0:41:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Okay, you gotta be out next week, because we're running the bulldozer through your lot.
- 0:41:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: If they don't want to buy, and they don't want to move, that is fine.
- 0:41:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: They can continue to live in their 1950s camper that they've built onto three times, for as long as they are alive.
- 0:41:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: As long as they pay the rent. As long as they, yeah, as long as they pay their lot fees, right? They're fine.
- 0:41:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: What do you see as the biggest risk to your mission over the next, like, 5 years?
- 0:41:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We're growing very, very fast, and I need to do that at a pace that is sustainable.
- 0:42:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I mentioned prior to my arrival, we hadn't done a lot of strategic fundraising, and so we don't have a developed, individual major gifts program, and so we are building that out. But that is a 3 to 5 to 7 year process before
- 0:42:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: that really is functioning in a way that… that it works and is sustainable. So we rely pretty heavily on, partnership agreements with the City of Boulder and other large, grants. We get a
- 0:42:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: fair chunk of money from the state of Colorado.
- 0:42:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: If our… If we don't start to see some economic stability, and start to see some…
- 0:42:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: A return to federal government leadership in the space of housing.
- 0:42:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And, I mean, Habitat just got two of the largest awards ever out of HUD.
- 0:43:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: But we're… also got kicked out of a grant from the Department of Energy.
- 0:43:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So, if we don't start to see some stabilization of that.
- 0:43:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Funding could become a serious risk for us, because if I lose $5 million from this funding source, I don't have another donor I can go to right now that can fill that gap.
- 0:43:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And so that's where I see, that's where I have anxiety as we move forward. Right now.
- 0:43:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: if it were… if… if not for the City of Boulder and the agreements that we have with Ponderosa.
- 0:43:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I wouldn't have money to operate and do this work.
- 0:43:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So that's a big risk for us, as we're working to build out these other things.
- 0:44:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: But it's always funding. I mean…
- 0:44:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Does… does Flatirons Habitat receive any funding from
- 0:44:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: national? Is there, like, an… Sure. Yeah, so, yes. So, for example, I just said that HUD… we got our largest HUD award ever. That went to
- 0:44:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: national, and I'll apply as a subaward under that, so it's an easier process. We also have a shared fundraising model where we revenue share money
- 0:44:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Habitat U.S. makes in Boulder County. We share in that revenue. So I've got major gift fundraisers doing large proposals to donors that I don't…
- 0:44:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: have to steward or do any work for, and I get, you know, 70% of the money. So we… we have those arrangements, and then there are other funding opportunities. There's gift in kind, there's… there's all kinds of other stuff that comes to us directly and indirectly from
- 0:45:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Habitat, International Habitat U.S.
- 0:45:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: But generally, they make federal money a lot easier to access, because I don't have to write a grant directly to the federal government. I just have to write a subaward grant to them. I was curious to be reminded why you came today. Like, who invited you, and what was the stated purpose, and as a follow-on, what do you need from us? So, I…
- 0:45:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: was told that you all wanted to know more about what we were doing, and how we were doing it, so that's why I'm here. I'm not exactly sure what you all do, and that's okay, but, because my answer would likely be the same.
- 0:45:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I need an army of advocates. I need people telling the story of why affordable home ownership, not just affordable housing, affordable home ownership is important, what the economic benefits of that are, what the community development benefits are, to justify
- 0:46:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: The millions of dollars of public investment that it's going to take to solve this crisis.
- 0:46:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And so I just need you telling those stories. And, you know, if you all want to come and volunteer at the Bowling Mountain, I'm not going to say that.
- 0:46:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah, I was just gonna say, if you haven't been over there yet to volunteer on a Saturday, or whenever you have time… Tuesday through Saturday. We can make it work. It's a lot of fun, and you give wonderful speeches, by the way, and you extracted a little money out of me this year, so… Thank you. Thank you so much. I mean, seriously, from the heart, thank you so much.
- 0:46:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And I hope everyone else comes and tells their friends. I have one last question. I know the city's, like, affordable home ownership program, equity is capped, and the people who can buy it have to go through a vetting process. Is that the same way? So, our program comports with the city's.
- 0:47:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Okay. So when one of our homeowners in 20 years decides to sell their house, it will be sold to the city's homeownership. That eligible person, the increase in value is basically matching inflation. And so that's… and now that…
- 0:47:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: every community… every community that I do business with in Boulder County has outsourced their affordable home ownership program to the city. It's the same process for me everywhere, except for the city of Brookfield.
- 0:47:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So I have much less complication.
- 0:47:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So you're saying, like, the unique benefits of affordable home ownership, which made me think that that's in contrast to renting? So what we know, exact same family, exact same family demographics, renter and homeowner, okay?
- 0:47:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Homeowner, they see the doctor less often.
- 0:47:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: They, do better, their kids do better in school on…
- 0:48:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Math and reading, and other things like leadership and character.
- 0:48:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: They use social safety net programs less. Now, this is compared to the exact same family that's in an affordable rental.
- 0:48:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So, those are the community benefits.
- 0:48:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: of…
- 0:48:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: living in affordable home ownership. And then, of course, the family has greater wealth building, they get promoted at work more often, they have higher educational attainment. All of that, all of that kind of
- 0:48:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: In the family benefit, but there's… there is real demonstrative community benefit.
- 0:48:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: to have families in homes they own versus the same family in affordable rental. Because of stability, or perceived stability? I know the numbers, I don't know the why. I just know that Habitat for Humanity International has done an enormous body of research.
- 0:48:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And those are the numbers that have come out in lovely evidence briefs that I'll be happy to share with you. I just wonder, I know that there are some people out there who…
- 0:49:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: even if it's an affordable program, they're just not going to be in a position to own. They're not… Right. Certain things going on in their life, keeping up with maintenance, they need to rent. Right, absolutely. They don't have that, and…
- 0:49:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I wonder, like, in terms of the hard economic numbers, when people go to sell, like, how long do people usually stay in these homes?
- 0:49:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I don't have good data on that,
- 0:49:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: when I was in South Dakota, we, you know.
- 0:49:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: About a third of our homeowners sold within 10 years.
- 0:49:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: But I don't have good data on that here.
- 0:49:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I just think, and I agree with you, I think if someone owns an asset, it's harder to sell, it's harder to get out, you know, you can terminate your lease, usually. People are going to stay put longer, and when people stay put in the same place longer, they're going to be better contributors to the community than someone who passes through for
- 0:50:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: one-year lease. Right. And I think that's probably the value. I just wonder…
- 0:50:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You know, when people go to sell, like, how much…
- 0:50:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: equity, like, the… what's the… just the financial, the pure financial upside? So, the… the…
- 0:50:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: without going in, because I don't know the formulas in the math, but gen… the concept is designed around, if you buy a house today, and you're at 60% of AMI,
- 0:50:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: 20 years from now, when you go to sell that home, it will be affordable to a family at 60% of AMI.
- 0:50:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So the family gets some appreciation every year. They get credit for major improvements that they do. Actually, probably Eli could probably take you through the actual math.
- 0:50:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: But they never get market appreciation.
- 0:50:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: nobody wins the lottery, and I won't buy anything. And I guess by paying their mortgage, they're getting some of that back. I mean, they're obviously paying interest and all the bills and stuff, but there's probably some return if they… Yeah, and they're not… so the home appraises for a million dollars.
- 0:51:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: they buy it for $250. Right. Right? So they're paying a mortgage on $250, and then, yeah, so the only time… the only time that that…
- 0:51:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: doesn't come into play is if there's a foreclosure, and then the bank can sell it at market rate at the end of that process. It's the only way we can get a bank to partner.
- 0:51:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Interesting. So the bank can basically get these properties from… Only in a foreclosure situation.
- 0:51:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: to recoup the amount of the loan. Yeah. But if it's…
- 0:51:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: if it's a $250,000 loan and they have a little bit of attorney fees on there, it shouldn't be a million dollar balance. It's the only way that we can get… that we can partner with banks to do this. I'd like to… is there… Is there a lot of… because that seems like a way a bank can make a huge profit off of… Well, Habitat homeowners are really, really well prepared to buy their homes. We have a very, very low foreclosure rate. Yeah.
- 0:52:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I could just see a situation where a bank, in theory, could lend a house for $250,
- 0:52:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: resident stops making a mortgage payment, bank sells it for a million. On the free market, makes a $750,000 profit off of a taxpayer-funded enterprise. That sounds deeply…
- 0:52:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: chime in and hear, hey, how's it going? I'm Eli, Eric, and they, them.
- 0:52:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Right.
- 0:52:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: We actually have, protections in the legal document to prevent that from happening, so that's not a concern for the program.
- 0:52:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: What I may have been talking about is when we have sold our mortgage portfolio to a bank, we had to give the bank that protection.
- 0:52:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I'd be careful about that. Well, yeah, but that's why… that's why I'm really, really excited that there are habitat entities that are building out a direct lending program, because then we're… I mean, generally speaking, the bank should only recoup
- 0:53:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: whatever, the balance of the load, but… Alright, I'm gonna move on. You dig into that. You should dig in.
- 0:53:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Thank you all very much for your time. No one else has questions for Dan.
- 0:53:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Emails. Lauren, did you have any questions?
- 0:53:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: I'm really interested in…
- 0:53:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Sorry, excuse me, the cost aspect of it. So you mentioned, on average, Boulder Mod, the construction costs, the hard costs, are $380,000 per unit. When you take into consideration soft costs, other things like that, what's your total all-in, total development cost per unit?
- 0:53:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So right now, our affiliate overhead is calculated at about $50,000 a unit, and that will go down as we build more units per year, because our fixed costs will get spread out over more units.
- 0:54:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Okay, so $50,000 is all you've got, you don't have any sort of design or engineering fees at all?
- 0:54:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It's all… it's sort of calculated all in there. Remember, the building and the equipment is all paid for, I don't have a mortgage on that.
- 0:54:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Right.
- 0:54:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I don't have to pay a lease on that.
- 0:54:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: And then, of that $380,000 plus, or so $430,000 total development cost per unit.
- 0:54:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: How much of that is subsidized by the city? Do you have an average cost per unit that you receive from the city?
- 0:54:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So right now, the relationship we have with the city is with Ponderosa.
- 0:54:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And again, they've basically hired us to be their general contractor, so they are paying the hard costs on each of those units, and then they are recoup… they are… they are collecting whatever revenue is made at home sale.
- 0:55:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Got it. Okay, thank you.
- 0:55:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Questions?
- 0:55:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Is there anything you think the city should do differently?
- 0:55:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I think this is a great city to do affordable housing in.
- 0:55:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It has one of the most gen… from my perspective, one of the most generous inclusionary zoning policies. It's got great public policy. It's got a
- 0:55:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: A city housing staff that
- 0:55:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: knows it's crap and does really well. I wish planning were easier to deal with. Planning and permitting? Sorry. Well, there you go, I mean, that sounds like… My staff complaint about something is something about permits, but… but I don't know the details of that.
- 0:55:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I'm normally one of the easier ones. Yeah, probably. But I mean, and your hands are tied, too. I mean, there's… I mean, it just… things just take time. And… and I'm generally standing on my… right now, I'm standing on my sap stack to get land through entire…
- 0:56:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: This is a grievance we hear from every single person who comes before this board, and we're talking to Habitat's non-profit guy here. We hear it from the for-profit developers. This is something the City of Boulder needs to take very seriously. And for what it's worth, I think that
- 0:56:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: within the political climate right now, the Council and the planning board are pretty unified.
- 0:56:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Towards.
- 0:56:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: cleaning things up and making it easier for everybody, and I don't see that changing with this election either, so I think that… Generally, this is a… I mean.
- 0:56:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: nothing is going to be as easy as I had it when I was in Brookings, South Dakota, when I could print on an 11x17 a floor plan out of Chief Architect, and take it down to the planning department and say, yep, go ahead.
- 0:56:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I mean, nothing's gonna be that easy. But as far as doing the work of affordable housing in a high-cost market, I'm glad I'm involved.
- 0:56:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I'm glad I'm not in Vail and Aspen and places like that.
- 0:57:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We should all be glad we're in Boulder in some nice place.
- 0:57:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Anything else from anybody?
- 0:57:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Thank you so much for your time. You're very, very welcome. We'll be in touch, come in to…
- 0:57:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Is it one of the boxes, or… Absolutely. Absolutely. Volunteering. We will make that happen. All of those things. Not November 17th.
- 0:57:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Okay. Yeah, we… I think the planning board's been…
- 0:57:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: A couple of our members have been… I'm a general contractor, so it's really hard for me to convince myself to swing a hammer on a Saturday, but come winter, I'll probably have a little bit more bandwidth for it. I understand. And, you know, it's funny, general contractors who are used to building on site, they have a hard time orienting themselves to the factory. I'm super interested in it. Yeah, we build everything inside out and backwards. Yeah, yeah, I've heard a lot of
- 0:57:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: very interesting things about it, and I look forward to visiting. And then, of course, the students are awesome, so it's always fun to work with them. I've taken a lot of your time, thank you so much. Thank you. Thank you for coming. My pleasure.
- 0:58:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: As I told Holly wanting and talking about Habitat is the favorite… my favorite thing. Thank you. Alright, thank you so much, thank you. Eli, I hope I didn't tell too many lies.
- 0:58:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: I didn't catch any, so you're all good. Good to see you, Dan.
- 0:58:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: The nature of your question. What? He had a question about the rental versus ownership, and… Oh, I just, like, wanted to, like, know what he thought, because it was… he really felt that there was…
- 0:58:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: That was, like, a large part of…
- 0:58:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: the mission was, like, the ownership part, so it's like… I think he explained it as well enough, but I think that there's a… Let's see what Eli has to say, so let's go to our next person, if that's okay with everybody. So, Eli Irkin.
- 0:58:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I don't know what your, what your, you know, title is, but Housing and Human Services with the City of Boulder, and the, talking about the City's permanently affordable
- 0:59:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: home ownership program.
- 0:59:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Thanks for coming!
- 0:59:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Yeah, there we go, am I off mute?
- 0:59:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Here we go, yep, we can hear ya.
- 0:59:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Awesome, and then I'm gonna share my screen.
- 0:59:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Let me know if you could see that.
- 0:59:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yes.
- 0:59:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Awesome. Thank you so much for the intro. So, Eli Irkin, I use they, them pronouns. What is my title? Homeownership?
- 0:59:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Senior Program Manager, I think is my official title. I've been with the city a long time, 12 or 13 years with, 10 or 11 of those in housing,
- 0:59:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: 8…
- 0:59:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: of those in the homeownership program. So, love this program, and love what it does, and happy to be here with you tonight to share more about it. I know we've… we did this last year, so it's very similar, so just a refresher on what the programs are that we have.
- 1:00:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: And happy to answer any questions.
- 1:00:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: So…
- 1:00:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: There we go. I like to start with a couple… some statistics, and you can see here on my slides that,
- 1:00:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: The left side is in English, the right side is same exact thing in Spanish.
- 1:00:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: And so we have…
- 1:00:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: In the program, currently 836 homes as of the end of 2025, so not including any new units that we've brought into the program in 2026.
- 1:00:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: We'll update this at the beginning of the year, of course. And…
- 1:00:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Of those homes, 36 sold in 2025, so it was a bit of a slower year of sales. We tend to have between 30 and 60 homes sell each year, some being homes that are already in the program that are just naturally turning over, and some new construction.
- 1:01:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: At the end of 2025, we had 132 certified applicants waiting for homes in the program. So it's more, less supply than demand, usually a pretty competitive program, but I'll talk more at the end about what it's looking like right now.
- 1:01:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: The price ranges of the homes, vary, and so we've got some in very low price ranges. They're usually… they… they…
- 1:01:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: match the income limit. So we go all the way from low incomes, so I think 60% of the area median income, all the way up to now 150% of the area median income, serving middle incomes.
- 1:01:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: And so we have fewer homes at those high, high prices and high income limits, and… but more, kind of, spread across the other, kind of, chunks of…
- 1:01:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Price range here.
- 1:02:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: And…
- 1:02:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: if you want to check out this QR code, you probably are very familiar with the Affordable Housing Dashboard, but I like to share this with folks when, when
- 1:02:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Teaching them about the program.
- 1:02:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Anybody want to snap a pic of that QR code? No pressure! Okay, great. All right, so today I'll talk about the three programs we offer. The Permanently Affordable Homes program, the Solutions Grant.
- 1:02:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: and the Shared Appreciation Loan Program, aka our House to Home Ownership, or H2O, loan program.
- 1:02:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Our Permanently affordable homes program, this is what y'all are most familiar with. This is our affordable purchase program. We offer homes available for sale at below market rate prices. We don't exactly keep statistics of this, but it tends to be at least half of market value.
- 1:02:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: And the homes are all scattered all throughout the city. With a small number of homes now available in Boulder County, they are… they are fully available. We've had two homes in Lafayette, expanding our program, with a regional approach with, communities who have, opted in for that.
- 1:03:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: When homes are available, they're listed on our website. We don't consider them for sale until they're on our website, but they could also be listed on Zillow, on the MLS, and these homes must be sold to buyers who meet the income limits, asset limits, and meet some other program requirements.
- 1:03:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: And the homes remain permanently affordable forever.
- 1:03:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Our Solutions Grant Program. This is a down payment assistance grant that can be used to purchase one of the permanently affordable homes, and they can also be used to purchase a
- 1:03:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Thistle Land Lease Home located within Boulder City limits. Fun fact.
- 1:03:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: This down payment assistance grant, covers up to 5% of the home's purchase price, for folks who don't have enough of their own funds to meet the minimum down payment and closing costs.
- 1:04:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Funds are limited, so it's first come, first-served throughout the year, but we get fresh funds the next year.
- 1:04:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: The amount is determined after going under contract, and those final loan details are available, because it varies. It's like, how much cash do you have on hand?
- 1:04:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: You get to keep 3 months of reserves, but you must put in everything up to 3 months of reserves, and then what are the actual closing costs? And that'll depend on the price of the home, and each home can be different.
- 1:04:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: And grant commitments aren't made until 2 weeks before closing. That's mostly for a buying audience.
- 1:04:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Okay, but the grants are, they reduce the future resale price of the home, so that investment made to, in that down payment assistance is recaptured, essentially, in a future lower resale price.
- 1:05:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Here's an example, if you're a numbers guy like me, or a numbers person like me. Let's take this example of a $200,000 home.
- 1:05:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: 5% is the minimum required down payment, that's $10,000, plus $6,000 in closing costs. So that's, $16,000 total that's due.
- 1:05:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: The buyer has $6,500 of their own funds available, so that leaves 9… a gap of $9,500. This is below the maximum 5% for that grant, and so that grant is
- 1:05:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: made at that $9,500, then the starting resale price is $200,000 minus the $9,500 grant for a future starting resale price of $190,500.
- 1:05:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Next is our, and last, our Shared Appreciation Loan Program. So this is a down payment assistance loan that can be used to purchase a market rate home within Boulder City limits.
- 1:06:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: It's a deferred loan for up to $100,000. No repayments are made during that… a 30-year period, but at the end, there's a balloon payment due. So if at 30 years, or if you sell the home sooner, that's when the loan becomes due.
- 1:06:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: The home remains market rate, so that can be sold… resold at market rate in the future.
- 1:06:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Here's an example.
- 1:06:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: So the… what is owed back? The original loan amount plus a percentage of appreciation. So for this example, they're purchasing a $500,000 home, they're getting a $100,000 loan.
- 1:06:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: That is 20% of the home's purchase price. So then, at the end of, let's call it 30 years, that home went up from $500,000 to now being worth $700,000.
- 1:07:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: So it increased by $200,000 in value.
- 1:07:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: So what's owed back is the original $100,000 loan amount, plus 20% of that gain in value, a shared portion of that gain in value. So 20% of that $200,000 is $40,000, so what's owed back is $140,000.
- 1:07:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: If the home value were to go down, then just still the original loan amount is due back. There's not a discount given for depreciation.
- 1:07:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And is the city the lender in this situation, or is that outsourced to someone?
- 1:07:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: We… we partner with Impact Development Fund. They administer these loans for us, but we supply the funding.
- 1:07:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Pardon?
- 1:07:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Gotcha, but if…
- 1:07:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You know, if there was, like, some sort of collection issue, they would deal with it, not the city.
- 1:07:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Okay.
- 1:07:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: So to qualify for the programs, folks have to be under the income limits. So these vary from year to year. They're based on HUD numbers. The…
- 1:08:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: First column here, it's based on household size, so however many people will live in the home that someone plans to purchase is how many people are in the household.
- 1:08:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: This is that maximum for 150% AMI, but all of the homes in the program are at varying income limits, so each specific home can be a different income limit.
- 1:08:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: And that will be listed on the city's webpage when that's listed for sale, but they go from… I think we have a couple homes below 60% AMI, which is, an interesting thing. And then,
- 1:08:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: you know, there's… they… most homes tend to be around, or just below… around 80% AMI.
- 1:08:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: We've got a smaller number of homes available.
- 1:08:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: up to between 80 and 100, between 100 and 120, and then now just a very few opportunities at 150% AMI.
- 1:09:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: a lot of the homes are available under… are under this amount, this… that… the same as the Solutions Grant, which is…
- 1:09:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: roughly… 80-ish percent. I'm happy to get into more detail if y'all are interested in that.
- 1:09:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: But you can see, like, these are higher than you might expect. I get that a lot.
- 1:09:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: When I'm talking with the community.
- 1:09:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: In the…
- 1:09:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Go ahead.
- 1:09:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Images blocking a shared… It's not your fault, Eli.
- 1:09:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: behind Eli? Shared Appreciation. Shared appreciation. How popular has that program… Shared Appreciation on H2O. How popular has that program been?
- 1:09:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: It's not utilized very often, to be honest. We tend to get about, between 0 and 3 loans per year, for that program.
- 1:10:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: you know.
- 1:10:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: a couple years ago, a handful, maybe 5 years ago, we increased the loan maximum from $50,000 to $100,000, and we have seen more utilization with that $100,000 actually going further, to purchase a market rate home in Boulder.
- 1:10:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Yeah, I think we're seeing a slowdown everywhere right now, so we haven't had much utilization this year, but the last few years have been 3 loans each year.
- 1:10:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: No.
- 1:10:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Compared to our 50 or 60 who buy on our permanently affordable program each year, it seems lower.
- 1:10:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Okay, I'll keep going.
- 1:10:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Next is… there we go. Asset limits. So, similarly, if someone can't have a ton of money to be able to qualify for the program, kind of in the bank, if you will, so we consider asset limits are, up to 150% of the area median income. Someone can have that amount in assets and qualify for the program. For most homes, we do have a handful of homes
- 1:11:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: That are, funded with,
- 1:11:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: You know, state funding has different requirements, so there's a handful of homes that have, you know, different asset limits there.
- 1:11:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Generally, someone will qualify for a solutions grant if they have less than $15,000 in assets.
- 1:11:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: At the time of purchase.
- 1:11:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: We also… I won't get into it here, but we exempt some retirement assets, depending on age, we exempt the down payment, and there are some
- 1:11:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Other exemptions that happen with income, mwah.
- 1:11:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: There.
- 1:11:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: So, when someone buys a permanently affordable home, they sign a legal agreement that keeps the home affordable forever. I won't get into everything, but I will, talk about the covenant limits, the future resale price.
- 1:12:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: outlines what the capital improvement credits are that are allowed, that y'all were talking about earlier at the end of, of Dan's presentation.
- 1:12:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: They must own or occupy the home, so they have to live in the home, but the covenant does allow some renting, so one year out of every 7-year period, an affordable owner can rent their home, unless there were, other funding sources involved that don't allow that.
- 1:12:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: It also restricts who the home can be sold to in the future, how the home is marketed when it's sold, and it limits refinancing to protect that home from foreclosure.
- 1:12:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: I'm happy to provide a full copy of that covenant if you love a 12-page legal document, or happy to talk you through what that is, if anyone's ever interested.
- 1:12:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: And we… you know, we're talking about how the, like, what is the appreciation that they earn? So this is how we calculate the future resale price.
- 1:13:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: We start with the original purchase price. We subtract the solutions grant, if they received that grant directly from the city.
- 1:13:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: And then we add annual appreciation. So we add between 1% and 3.5% appreciation every year, and the amount depends on some area economic indicators. So every year, we look at the change in the area median income.
- 1:13:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: And the change in the consumer price index, and whichever is lower is the appreciation that each household receives for that year, between that 1% minimum and the 3.5% cap.
- 1:13:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Then we add the approved capital improvement
- 1:13:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: And capital updates, and I'll talk a little bit about that next. We add a $650 flat amount for some of the seller's closing costs.
- 1:13:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: And then we add some agent commissions compensations. If there is excessive damage, or there's deferred maintenance, the seller is responsible for fixing those deferred maintenance items before closing, or they can offer a credit to the buyer.
- 1:14:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: That's how we determine the maximum resale price.
- 1:14:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: And so, you were talking earlier about, you know.
- 1:14:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: how much wealth are they really gaining? It's this, small amount of appreciation, the capital improvements, and then the equity they are, you know, paying down on their mortgage does increase their equity.
- 1:14:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We know, like, do we have quantifiable numbers for your average seller? How much money they're walking away with after all is said and done?
- 1:14:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Not off the top of my head, no.
- 1:14:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: It's between, you know, the 1% and 3.5% average is about 2% each year for the last… I looked it up recently, so, like, last 10 years, it's been about 2% on average, across the board.
- 1:15:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Yeah, it's… it's all in that calculation, so we don't… we don't necessarily pull numbers for that specifically.
- 1:15:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Capital improvements, I'll keep going. Capital… I'll take questions at the end.
- 1:15:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Capital improvement credits, so some things that are allowed for credit are energy improve… energy efficiency improvements, so adding solar,
- 1:15:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Attic insulation, that sort of thing can add, value to the home. Increasing habitable space, so doing a basement finish or doing an addition can increase the home value.
- 1:15:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Adding AC, ceiling fans, or mini-splits can increase the value. Replacing flooring that's over 10 years old with a more durable, flooring material is eligible for credit.
- 1:15:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Replacing a furnace or water heater that's over 10 years old with a new furnace or water heater that meets certain energy efficiency specifications.
- 1:16:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Adding a radon gas mitigation system, remodels of kitchens or bathrooms that are over 20 years old. These are some examples of the capital improvements that are allowed. But it's not an exhaustive list.
- 1:16:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: So to qualify, someone needs to apply for the program. They need to be pre-approved for a mortgage with a total debt-to-income ratio at or under 42%.
- 1:16:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: And then apply to the program, complete an orientation, some education requirements, and then complete the full application, which, it's a beast. There's a lot of paperwork. I wish I could get it to be lower paperwork, but…
- 1:16:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Then, to get into… get a specific home, we have a fair selection process, where homes are listed for a 30-day required marketing period.
- 1:16:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: During that time, buyers can't offer… make offers or submit contracts. Instead, they submit to the city their interest in the specific home. We call that our selection process entry form. We verify that they're eligible for that home, and then we do a random drawing between everyone who's eligible and has entered.
- 1:17:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: That's what I just said, I'll keep going. So then, at the end of that 30 days, we hold that fair selection process. Buyers, need… the winning buyer needs to submit an offer within 24 hours.
- 1:17:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: They… offers can be rejected if not received within that 24 hours, or if they do a low offer less than the maximum resale price, that can be rejected. Or if they have a contingency to sell another home.
- 1:17:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Their offer can be rejected. But otherwise, full price offer without a contingency to sell within 24 hours, essentially must be accepted by the seller.
- 1:17:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: If a home does not have a buyer after that 30-day marketing period, then the homes become immediately available. Then any certified and eligible buyer can go under contract at any time. It then becomes first-come, first serve.
- 1:18:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: And we… we have had a slowdown in the market. We tend to mimic the open market, which is also slow right now, for sales. And we have several… in my tenure at the city and in this program, we rarely have an immediately available home. Right now, we have
- 1:18:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: 8, I believe, including, a Ponderosa home that we've listed for sale, and many others that… that are… it's… it's very interesting to me. I don't know… I mean, high interest rates, the whole… we could
- 1:18:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: I could…
- 1:18:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: speculate all day long, but I won't. But we do have some availability, so it's kind of, in a sense, an easier time than ever for someone to buy a home in the program, because we have so much availability. I think the tricky part is getting a loan these days.
- 1:19:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: So if someone is interested in one of those immediately available homes, and they're not already certified in the program.
- 1:19:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: They can, ask for a fast track application, which can skip the waitlist, and we can bump them up to the top of the list for processing applications, if they're interested in a specific home that's available.
- 1:19:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Once someone gets into the program, they get a preliminary certification letter, and that's good for a year. If they don't buy a home within a year, they can recertify at no cost, and continue in the program.
- 1:19:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: So the program in usual times, can take, sometimes as little as 3 or 4 months.
- 1:19:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: From starting an application to buying a home, to closing on a home. And sometimes it's 1 to 2 years, so it really depends. The average is about 9 months to, a year and a half.
- 1:20:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: And it depends on someone's needs in a home, that specific home coming up for sale, what preference tier they're in, if it's a desirable home going through that selection process, and then luck.
- 1:20:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Oops, there we go. That's… The bulk of my presentation here.
- 1:20:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: And happy to take questions.
- 1:20:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I would just like to get a financial understanding of…
- 1:20:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You know, affordable homeownership compared to affordable rentals.
- 1:20:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: How much is the public spending per resident per year between the two? And then what is the financial benefit for the residents in…
- 1:20:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Affordable homeownership compared to rentals.
- 1:21:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Yeah, that's a good question. I don't have statistics or information available on that at the moment.
- 1:21:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: I'm sure there are some studies out there, but yeah, that's not something I have off the top of my head or, available.
- 1:21:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: That's my sidewalk.
- 1:21:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Like, ugh.
- 1:21:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: That's cool.
- 1:21:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Totally.
- 1:21:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: The left. Do we know the total cost of the program?
- 1:21:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: So, alms…
- 1:21:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Homes come into the program in a variety of different ways. So, homes that are built through an inclusionary housing requirement, and if a developer chooses to build, on-site or off-site home ownership, units.
- 1:21:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Then they will come into the program at, you know, no additional cost. Cost to the develop… is essentially on the developer.
- 1:21:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: We also fund affordable home ownership development, so as you were hearing from Dan, we fund, homeownership developments through the, Housing Investments, team. I don't have specific, like, how much is the budget for the homeownership program off the top of my head.
- 1:22:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: just the thought I have, like, there's a lot of transactional costs associated with it, and that a renter doesn't always incur, and that's why I'm, like, curious. When you're dealing with a smaller amount of money, smaller amount of equity.
- 1:22:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: the transactional costs are still large and appreciate, often in conjunction with, like, the private markets, so… are those transactional costs potentially cutting into any financial benefit? I don't know, that's just something I'm curious about. My gut tells me that, like.
- 1:22:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: affordable rentals, subsidized rentals are probably… we're able to build more of them for less money, for more people to live in. That's my gut, but we don't really have the data.
- 1:23:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Go ahead and jump in, Lauren.
- 1:23:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Hi, Eli. I have a quick question on when…
- 1:23:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: A home has accepted offers, and you receive, say, 20 offers on…
- 1:23:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: a property or interested parties. How do you rank
- 1:23:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Who gets to be the winning buyer?
- 1:23:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Sure… Let me… I'm gonna…
- 1:23:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: De-share, prep a slide, and then reshare, because I have a slide for that, but I didn't know that y'all would be interested in it. Okay, give me one sec…
- 1:23:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You're having ChatGPT generated slide.
- 1:24:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Can I ask a follow-up question while we wait for the slide? So, is your…
- 1:24:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: answering.
- 1:24:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Is your question about, like, the total cost?
- 1:24:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: to the city for a home ownership unit versus a rental unit? Is that the transactional cost you're talking about? I mean, that's part of it. I think it's more, like, in terms of people serve, so… Like, how the people… Yeah, honestly, you could spend half a million to build a house, but once you spend that half a million, it's gonna serve people for…
- 1:24:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: a long time. I don't know, it's just like, what's the budget, and how many people have we served each year under this program? Does that make sense? Like, what is the public subsidizing, and how many people is it helping? It's interesting, because I think we can…
- 1:24:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: probably, like, that number of what, like, per unit subsidy would be easy to find, how to translate that over
- 1:24:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: families served over time, and the cost per fam… like, not family, households, whatever. Right. I mean, the per unit subsidy, I imagine the average affordable home has more people living in it than the average rental unit.
- 1:25:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I would just assume that. Like, it seems like there's a bypasses.
- 1:25:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I don't know, but that…
- 1:25:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: No, I think that's a misconception. I don't think there's data for that.
- 1:25:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: That's clear.
- 1:25:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah, I mean, most… you have a lot of single people or couples in rentals, and I mean, you can have.
- 1:25:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Same in our program.
- 1:25:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah. Well, I don't know, I… yeah, do we have data on how many, like, the average
- 1:25:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: household size? Probably. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:25:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I mean, we want to get… just, like, how many people are we helping with… in which… what's the most cost-effective way to help the most people? That's interesting. The ownership model versus the rental model? Right, that's what I kind of want to understand. Does that make sense? Yeah, yeah, yeah. And I mean, to Eli's point, I'm just, like, giving…
- 1:25:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: hypotheticals here, like, we would want to adjust it, you know, obviously it costs more to build a house that has 6 people than it does a smaller one for 2, so we don't… you know, we'd want to account for that, right? Like, in understanding how many people are being helped.
- 1:26:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Great. I'm gonna jump to Lauren's question. So.
- 1:26:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: When we have a home where there's a lot of interest, we… they don't put in offers, like I was saying, they put in their, interest form, essentially. So our selection process entry form. In our select… then… so we…
- 1:26:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: You know, gather those over the 30 days that the home is listed for sale, and then at the end of the 30 days, we take everyone who has entered and is eligible, and we sort by these preference tiers.
- 1:26:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: So, we give preference to households that work in Boulder, that work in Boulder over a year, and who are continuously certified in the program for over a year.
- 1:26:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: So, Tier 1 is… has worked in Boulder over a year, and who is in the program continuously certified for over a year.
- 1:27:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Tier 2 is they work in Boulder over a year, but they're in the program under a year.
- 1:27:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: And so on and so forth.
- 1:27:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Is there any, preference points given if someone has
- 1:27:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: not made an offer. What did you say? Expressed interest? Filled out the interest form? If they've done… if they've…
- 1:27:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Been in the city more than a year, and been continuously certified more than a year, but also have
- 1:27:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: attempted to purchase a permanently affordable home multiple times. Does that do anything?
- 1:27:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Nope. No, no matter how many other homes you've entered for, it's not considered in that fair selection process. It's just everyone who's entered, and then just sorted by these tiers.
- 1:27:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And then is it ran… like, if there's 3 Tier 1 people, is it then just random?
- 1:28:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Yes.
- 1:28:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Exactly.
- 1:28:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: That's helpful. Thanks, Eli.
- 1:28:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Cool.
- 1:28:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Excellent.
- 1:28:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: A random question. I went to a city council meeting once that opened with, Fear Brocket,
- 1:28:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: recognizing a citizen who had dated their house to the affordable housing program, and I can't remember
- 1:28:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Now that I think… now that I say that out loud, I can't remember if there was anything about it being a for-sale home or not. I suppose it could just go into the rental
- 1:28:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Cool.
- 1:28:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: No, that will be, into the home ownership program.
- 1:28:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: That is…
- 1:28:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: But that was the first time I had heard about it. I'm just kind of curious if that happens more than once per year, or how many houses have been acquired through that program, and does anybody even know about it?
- 1:28:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Yeah, so that's our Housing Legacy program, little known. And to date, to my knowledge, we've had two homes donated to the program, at the… and they will be donated, they're bequeathed to the program upon the owner's passing.
- 1:29:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: So we don't have those homes yet, but we will in the future. And, yeah.
- 1:29:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: It's very exciting. Am I… Holly, am I missing any?
- 1:29:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Do you remember? Nope.
- 1:29:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: That's right, it's, like, two to three, and we would… we would love to figure out how to expand this program, and have talked to various organizations of brainstorming ways to expand it, and get more people to know about it, have more obvious advantages to participate in it, but…
- 1:29:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: it's a challenge, so… Yeah. It's an interesting encouragement. I just think of those, like, NPR ads, where they're like, when you die, donate your…
- 1:30:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It's like, donate your house to the government, you die. That doesn't sound good. I know, you gotta come up with a better way to sell it, but that kind of is what it is. Huh.
- 1:30:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Thank you so much.
- 1:30:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah, but it is, it is something, it's a program that we… we are, like, in the hopper about ways… trying to figure out ways to improve it.
- 1:30:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Because it's…
- 1:30:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I mean, in this community, it seems like it would be a good… There's wealthy people, but not a lot of people just donate a whole house. That's a… that's a big ask. There'd be any kind of tax benefit to their… the remainder of their estate? Or some kind of…
- 1:30:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: reverse mortgage benefit process thing that you could… To their extent. I don't know. Usually the other beneficiaries are… they want the money. Dad giving away. Yeah, dad donated all our… all his money to the government, we get nothing. Not to… to the people. To the people.
- 1:31:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Eli, can you go back to… it was, like, the first or second slide or something like that, where you were talking about there's, like, 836 homes in the program?
- 1:31:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Fairly.
- 1:31:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So… What's the goal for this next year? And… That kind of thing.
- 1:31:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Sure, okay, so we're back to here.
- 1:31:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: So, like I was saying, we bring homes into the program in a variety of ways. There's, new construction through inclusionary housing, and there's funded or not funded, inclusionary housing.
- 1:31:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: units that come to the program. We also have a program where we, buy a handful of,
- 1:32:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Existing homes, usually condos or townhomes, and bring them at market rate, and then bring them into the program.
- 1:32:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: We now have, and there will be a press release soon, but we received some state funding from, the Division of Local Affairs, DOLA, to assist in the subsidy for that scattered site acquisition.
- 1:32:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: I don't know the exact number off the top of my head, but I'm hoping between new construction, like Dan was saying, 19 units next year, that would… that will be awesome. So 19 plus…
- 1:32:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: 12 to 15, hopefully, with the scattered site acquisition. And so, what is that? 30?
- 1:32:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: 30 or so? 35?
- 1:32:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: And then whatever new construction, I'm not privy to the entire development pipeline, so there should be some more.
- 1:33:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I'm thinking we have this affordable housing data dashboard, and the idea… you look over time about how many units have been added into the program since, like.
- 1:33:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: the year 2000, I think.
- 1:33:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And, most of them are rentals, and so the idea of us adding, like, 30 ownership units per year is a pretty substantial addition to the home ownership portfolio. Yeah.
- 1:33:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So, it doesn't feel like these…
- 1:33:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Huge numbers, but it is substantial.
- 1:33:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: What… Eli am curious what,
- 1:33:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Dan said something, maybe you guys can help me remember. He said something about
- 1:33:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Habitat for Humanity had some research showing, home ownership being
- 1:34:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Affordable home ownership. Affordable. Affordable home ownership, though, that was the emphasis, right?
- 1:34:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Tangible community benefits versus… Right, affordable renting. Yeah, and I'm just curious if you… have a… Comment.
- 1:34:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: About chat.
- 1:34:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: I don't have a specific comment. I think that is super compelling, and I love that data. I don't have it off the top of my head or prepared, I'm so sorry. I, but I find that
- 1:34:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: The need for our program just, there's always…
- 1:34:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: You, more of a need than we have available, so, seems to be helping.
- 1:34:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I had a question about HOA fees in a condo scenario, whether it's new construction, inclusionary housing, or if you acquire a condo. I mean, what prevents the HOA fees from going way up and making a home unaffordable? How do you have
- 1:35:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Control over that. If you're… your unit is part of an HOA.
- 1:35:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Great question. We actually have no control over any HOAs.
- 1:35:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: So all… so there are some costs of home ownership that the city cannot, control for, including HOAs. So HOAs are entirely governed by the owners within that community. The city is not an owner of the home, and so we don't have a vote,
- 1:35:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: And HOAs are governed by the state, and so the city actually has no ability to regulate HOAs from that standpoint either. So there are also other costs of home ownership that are essentially at market rate as well. So HOAs are one of them.
- 1:35:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Insurance costs. We can't control insurance costs. Someone should insure their affordable home for a full replacement value, because that permanent affordability is permanent, even in a total loss situation.
- 1:36:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: So if a home is… does have a catastrophic event, and it's a complete loss, what is rebuilt is still deed-restricted.
- 1:36:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: So,
- 1:36:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: full replacement costs should be insured. So it's similar to that. We cannot control for all things. I wish we could. We've done some research into how we can, if we can do anything about HOAs, and unfortunately, at this moment in time, we don't have a silver bullet for it.
- 1:36:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: When we're searching for homes that we purchase in that scattered site acquisition program, we are assess… accounting for, is that HOA
- 1:36:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: relatively affordable, and the… the resale price formula, that calculates what the affordable price can be does account for a market rate HOA and an average HOA, for… for the region.
- 1:37:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Do the covenants require the homeowner to purchase full replacement cost value insurance?
- 1:37:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Yes, essentially, the legal documents do. It's in the deed of trust, not the covenant, but yes.
- 1:37:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: There was another thought I had about HOAs. Oh, we had… we did, several years ago, start a grant program for HOA special assessments, because that was a concern we heard from the community, and it's one thing we can do, and so we have a limited amount of money each year that we can assist homeowners facing a special assessment, so affordable owners facing a special assessment
- 1:37:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: They can receive a grant to cover the special assessment cost.
- 1:37:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: It acts just like that solutions grant program, where it reduces the future resale value by the grant amount. So that gets invested into deeper affordability into the home, going forward.
- 1:38:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Eli, one thought… I hear you on the HOA piece and how it's regulated by state law. I was thinking… you were saying we're thinking of ways we can help on the HOA side, and one thing I've seen in my career is often, like, small HOAs just kind of struggle with
- 1:38:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: how to run the property, or, you know, those sort of things. I'm wondering maybe if the city could provide a resource just on, like, training HOA presidents, stuff like that, connecting them with, you know, a property manager who's done it for 20 years, and providing education.
- 1:38:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: There's all of that through the state, so the state already has those resources, that they provide.
- 1:38:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: How many city staff members administer this program.
- 1:38:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: I, supervise a team of 5, so 5 plus me is 6, and…
- 1:39:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: I'm trying to think, yeah, 6 people.
- 1:39:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Does that include the acquisition, or just the… kind of accounts.
- 1:39:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: It does. So that includes… I do most of the acquisitions, so think about buying 15 homes a year. Anyway…
- 1:39:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: I do the acquisitions!
- 1:39:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: And I have a staff member who manages the rehabs of those homes, so each home we purchase is in varying condition and needs, you know, a level of rehab before it can be put to market in the affordable program.
- 1:39:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: And so that's…
- 1:39:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: one full-time employee, for rehab, and then I do the acquisitions. We have two, analysts and one,
- 1:40:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: administrative coordinator. And then we also have a new staff member who's starting a rehab and,
- 1:40:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Rehab and Replacement Program.
- 1:40:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: So that's… Not out yet, but soon there will be a…
- 1:40:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Rehabilitation programs, so low-interest loans for, minor home repairs.
- 1:40:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I just thought of something that I'm kind of curious how… how you've thought about this. Seems like one of the main… one of the… it's almost kind of a counterpoint to the HOA issue, which is,
- 1:40:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: A lot of people, as they go through their professional lives or their careers, their earnings go up.
- 1:40:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: as they gain more experience. And if you're, you know, if you're young and you start off in an affordable rental, or you're young and you start off in affordable ownership.
- 1:40:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You could find yourself graduating out of the affordable rental.
- 1:41:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Whereas if you got in on the affordable ownership.
- 1:41:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: you may have more resources to pay higher HOAs and repairs and insurance and all these things, and you don't… you don't find yourself, like, oh, shoot, I'm earning too much money now, I have to, like, ratchet back so that I don't…
- 1:41:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You know, earned my way out of affordable housing.
- 1:41:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I'm kind of curious, like, how many…
- 1:41:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Well, I guess there's no way to know this, but… so I'll just leave it at that, and just ask you to reflect on if that's something that is a thread that you guys talk about, or you can't ratchet away of affordable home ownership. That's right, that's my point, yeah. A rental, sure, that can happen.
- 1:41:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Yeah, so our program qualifies people at the time of purchase.
- 1:41:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: And so we no longer check income or assets after… after that purchase happens. So someone can purchase an affordable home, you know, own and live in it forever, for… for their lifetime. We… it's different from affordable rental, where they're… they have to re-qualify
- 1:42:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Every year or so, every couple years sometimes. And… so there's…
- 1:42:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: not that fear of, I'm gonna lose my home if I earn more money. And then I think what you're getting at is, do we know the rates in which people graduate from the home ownership program? And we don't. We don't have data on that. We do ask a survey when someone is selling their home. You know, would they do it again? Are they satisfied? It's more,
- 1:42:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: quant… no, qualitative data than quantitative. And…
- 1:42:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Most, you know, vast majority of people are happy that they purchased an affordable home. Many people are moving on… moving on to,
- 1:42:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: different areas, or, or moving to market rate housing.
- 1:43:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Phillip, I think your point is, like, with affordable rentals, people benefit from a government subsidy as long as they need it.
- 1:43:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And then if they don't need it anymore, they're not eligible for it. Whereas, like, in theory with affordable home ownership, they benefit… the subsidy benefits them for the life of the ownership, in theory.
- 1:43:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And they only need to qualify at the time of purchase. They could win a million dollars the next year in the lottery and still continue to benefit from it. So, I mean, it's just, like, in terms of how we allocate our resources and eligibility for
- 1:43:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: subsidies and things, I think that does… that is a factor to consider.
- 1:43:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I'm not saying it's problematic or that it's a red flag or anything, I'm just kind of pointing it out, and
- 1:43:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I assume that there's a fair number of people who…
- 1:43:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: buy into the home ownership affordability, and their income never dramatically improves, and it's, you know, it's the kind of constant struggle to
- 1:44:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: To make it all work and meet your monthly budget.
- 1:44:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I also assume there's a certain percentage of folks who sort of, like.
- 1:44:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: do really well, and they're living in Boller, and they're prospering, and it becomes a really nice benefit that they got into early.
- 1:44:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And I'm not saying that they've worked the system in some nefarious way, I'm just saying it's… No, but in especially a place like Boulder, someone, maybe they qualify, then they go to graduate school, and then they're making a big salary afterwards, you know, in a matter of a few years.
- 1:44:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And they're still…
- 1:44:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: And they still may not be able to purchase market rate housing in Boulder, even if their economic situation has, changed.
- 1:44:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: There's plenty of us. I think probably everyone experiences that to a certain degree here. We did a survey of affordable homeowners in 2025. We have some data around some of these questions, not, like.
- 1:45:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: super easy to tease out right now, but… Yeah, it's more like just what is the macro effect of various housing programs, and how does it serve people? You know, that's…
- 1:45:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: That's kind of… what I'm curious about.
- 1:45:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It's not necessarily, like, waste or abuse, it's more just, like, what is…
- 1:45:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: What is the most cost-effective way to serve the most people, and what are the impacts of the various programs, and understanding that.
- 1:45:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Because when we budget, we do make a decision. What are we going to invest our money in? And, you know, it would be… it would be helpful to just have a better understanding of that. As these programs mature, a lot of this is, like, a very kind of new pilot-type program. We're still learning from it.
- 1:45:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: When did this program start? When did the permanently affordable homeownership start?
- 1:45:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Late 90s.
- 1:46:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Do you know…
- 1:46:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: 30 years.
- 1:46:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: like, we've had, like, affordable rentals, that's been a thing for a long time in America, but before Boller started this affordable home ownership program, was there much precedent?
- 1:46:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Holly, do you want to take that one?
- 1:46:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I don't.
- 1:46:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: No.
- 1:46:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You don't know.
- 1:46:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: I don't know either. I think there was some precedent for land lease models of affordable ownership, but I don't know the timing on that.
- 1:46:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah, it's a good question. I don't know the… The history behind it, yeah. Yeah, it's like, we know how our program evolved, but in comparison with other… My gut tells me Boller did pilot something, because we tend to do that here, but that's why it has.
- 1:46:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Cool.
- 1:46:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: I bet y'all are sick of looking at this slide.
- 1:47:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: So I'll take it down.
- 1:47:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Anyone else have questions for Eli?
- 1:47:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Lauren, did you have other questions?
- 1:47:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: No, I'm good, thanks.
- 1:47:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It was a very informative presentation, thank you. Thank you, Eli. So, I would imagine somebody maybe has the question in their head again, so what…
- 1:47:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: what can we, as the Housing Advisory Board.
- 1:47:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Do for you and your programs?
- 1:47:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Thank you for that question. You know, I don't know. I feel like I'm very appreciative of everything y'all do. I'm happy to take any questions you have at any time. You can email, you know, homeownership at boulderColorado.gov, and that'll get to me.
- 1:47:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Yeah, do you wanna…
- 1:47:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Start a research, a, research think tank for, flushing out and funding all of these,
- 1:48:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: You know, pieces of data that would be so helpful in the work y'all do.
- 1:48:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Y'all can donate your house, the house…
- 1:48:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I need to build them before in the house before I should donate it to the government.
- 1:48:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Alright, well, thank you so much for joining us tonight, I really appreciate it.
- 1:48:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Absolutely, so happy to be here, thank you for having me.
- 1:48:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Hey, I think, so, I might have on there. Thanks again.
- 1:48:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Eli Urken, COB: Thank you, take care.
- 1:48:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Alright, next up on our agenda is, work plan.
- 1:49:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: To, for the… Remember, we combined November-December meetings to November 17th?
- 1:49:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Question mark? Yeah? 18. 18.
- 1:49:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And at that meeting, Kurt will come in and, talk about house… housing and human services, affordable housing, kind of in general, I hope?
- 1:49:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah, he's gonna be talking to us. He's gonna give you guys an update about the budget. There's a request about talking about the numbers. Right? That's what the… 18? 18.
- 1:49:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So that's one that we cared for. According to my calendar. Good job.
- 1:49:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: All right, so that… I think that's what Tiffany's doing, actually. Then in January, we have Jill Grano coming to talk about the history of housing in Colorado, Boulder.
- 1:50:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Boulder.
- 1:50:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Specifically. Can you attach her master's thesis slash book to the, the packet? Oh my gosh, have you seen it? No, but I'd like to. Me neither.
- 1:50:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: She's super excited to come in and talk. I mean, she just loves talking about housing in Boller, so that'll be pretty great. I'll ask her, yeah.
- 1:50:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So… That's what we have.
- 1:50:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: kind of laid out for right now. Is there anything in particular?
- 1:50:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Anybody wanted to have something else?
- 1:50:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: To take a look at.
- 1:50:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I know I said it before, but it's a good idea, is…
- 1:50:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And I don't know, like, how we would conduct this meeting, but I think we should talk about Sundance after Sundance, and…
- 1:50:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I don't know how we talk about it, other than just have a conversation.
- 1:51:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Seems like that…
- 1:51:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: probably would need to be months out. Yeah, I think that would be, like, March, April, May, you know, not February, necessarily. Okay.
- 1:51:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So we would need some data, right? Right. Yeah, or some… Yeah, it's gonna take a little bit of time. I think in the interim, we should all kind of, in our, like, personal lives, try to pay attention to what we're hearing and seeing.
- 1:51:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Okay.
- 1:51:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: He's… the city did make some, like, housing rules about temporary rentals for Sundance, right? There's a special license, a festival license. Yeah. That, people can get.
- 1:51:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: one of the, so we are, like, making policy about, you know, Sundance, so I think that would just be…
- 1:51:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: One thing I think that's particularly, unique about the festival licensing stuff is with the…
- 1:52:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: permanently affordable homes, there is a restriction about doing any type of short-term rentals, but, folks that live in permanently affordable
- 1:52:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: ownership.
- 1:52:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Just ownership?
- 1:52:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: No, there's some move to also the rentals. We'll be able to sell rent, which they normally are not able to do, but I think that that's…
- 1:52:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: in a large part being pushed for by certain people within the city, but I think still, in some ways, falls to the discretion of, like, the HP and whatnot. Okay, so ownership, that… that is…
- 1:52:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: that's settled, they will be able to apply for, the festival license. So, that is… I wouldn't be surprised if, like, any sort of federal
- 1:52:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: public rental, the standard lease, I wouldn't be shocked if it prohibited subletting.
- 1:52:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Like, that just seems like something you would find in a lease for permanently affordable rental unit.
- 1:53:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: it's something you find in the lease for almost every rental unit in Colorado, so… There is, like, some push.
- 1:53:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: even… Like, towards the state legislator to working on that.
- 1:53:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Specifically because of events like this.
- 1:53:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah, but that's, like, more a state… Yeah, I mean, if you're gonna abrogate a lease, you need a state law to do that. Yeah.
- 1:53:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: What else?
- 1:53:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Anything else in particular?
- 1:53:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I'd be interested in learning more about, like, market rate housing construction, since we have a lot of focus on affordable, but…
- 1:53:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Since it's a Housing Advisory Board, like.
- 1:53:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: most people are in the mark, in the open market, so I think learning more about trends there, or what, like.
- 1:53:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: how construction works in Boulder versus other places would be interesting.
- 1:53:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I feel like we've talked to developers over my years on this board, and a common theme, and we heard it tonight, was that, like, what can we do? And it's like, try to streamline the city's permitting approval process to make it cheaper to build.
- 1:54:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: For… we've heard that from even the BHP people, we've heard it from Habitat, and… That definitely seems like a problem, for sure. Yeah, I mean, that's what we're hearing. I guess the next step for us as a board is, like, do we want to really dive into that and start making more concrete, you know.
- 1:54:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: I think… I think the idea was that we would wait until the new council got settled, see their direction on Title IX,
- 1:54:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Dive in, based on… Feedback from staff.
- 1:54:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I like the suggestion. I think it makes a lot of sense. There's always,
- 1:54:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You know, another theme that keeps coming up is, like, the only thing that pencils out is super high-end luxury condos, and
- 1:55:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: just understanding What knobs are available to make the market conditions
- 1:55:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You know, have some wind in our sails for building the kinds of things that we'd like to have built.
- 1:55:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And… and are there levers that we could invent, or levers that we could, get bigger… bigger turning radius on somehow?
- 1:55:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: to make a healthier market is just kind of something I'm very interested in.
- 1:55:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yep.
- 1:55:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I think to Lauren's point, though, that, I mean, there are two builders here, right? That a lot of the… a lot of what you're talking about
- 1:55:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: comes back to Title IX. Like, the difference between building in Boulder versus building, like, where I'm building right now, an unincorporated Larimer. Most of the differences all come back to our municipal code.
- 1:55:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Okay. Beyond that, I'm sure either of us can talk to you about… Yeah. Well, then, I hear Lauren's point. Let's see what then the Council looks like in January.
- 1:56:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And if there is a movement among Council to reform our…
- 1:56:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: code, then… and it has to do with housing, we should have a more substantive discussion about weighing in on that. Maybe it has to be market rate housing.
- 1:56:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: putting aside Title IX issues, so not focusing on that, but, like, other trends or other…
- 1:56:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: factors in Boller.
- 1:56:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: as an example, TVAP2, there's some projects coming up with that, and
- 1:56:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Something I saw recently was… was going to be all rental, and no condos, and
- 1:56:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: the reason that was given was still that even though the construction defects law was changed, they still felt like it didn't make sense. So then I said, well, okay, do you have…
- 1:57:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: a laundry list of the things you would need changed so that you'd be willing to build condos. He's like, no, we're not in the business of building condos. I was like, okay, well,
- 1:57:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I don't, I don't know, it just, it feels like there's,
- 1:57:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: There's inability to build market rate
- 1:57:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: stuff, other than the high-end stuff. Like, the cheap new market rate housing is those tracks that they build out at DIA. Like, it's a really good value for the house you get.
- 1:57:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: In Adams County, and every developer I've spoken with is, like, the reason why that's… and I say cheap, they're able to… they build it at such large scale, on so much land, that, like, the per unit cost is so much lower. And every developer I talk to in Boller says, like.
- 1:57:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: that type of development's just not available here. You don't have 100-acre fields of land that you can just build, you know, cookie-cutter houses on for cheap.
- 1:57:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: They're about, like, townhouses, though.
- 1:58:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah, and it's more profitable to build a townhouse that's gonna sell for $1.5 million, which they can do here. And a lot of times, yeah. We could even just get piers at them and talk it through if you want, like, a lot of times, even, whether it's a custom home builder.
- 1:58:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: or a developer, they're gonna… they just have to try to maximize their profits, so a luxury unit is always gonna go for more. Like, in Boulder, a lot of times, student units have the highest ROI.
- 1:58:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You can't get around that, because students are always going to be circulating through, and it's hard to compel a developer to do something where they'll make less money. Yeah, and I guess I will put it this way, I don't really have, like, a normative stance on, like, what should be built. I'm more just, like, curious to know more about, like, what the…
- 1:58:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: like, the economics and the conditions are. Like, I don't… like, I'm not opposed to building townhouses. It sounds like it could, like… yeah. So, it's less of, like, coming to it with a certain viewpoint and more of, like, it'd be good to just explore that topic.
- 1:59:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Like, bringing in developers of multi… of market rate…
- 1:59:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: housing, to chat about what's going on from their perspective in Boulder?
- 1:59:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah.
- 1:59:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Okay.
- 1:59:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah, we've had that, and every time I've talked to, like, when we had that meeting at the Chamber of Commerce, I thought it was really helpful and educational. I learned a lot, so I definitely think that's…
- 1:59:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: something we all could benefit from. Talking to lenders can be very helpful, too. Like, I meet,
- 1:59:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: with the banks, occasionally, just to go through it. And a lot of times, I think that they're underrepresented, and, like, I think of the city, the builder, and the bank as all having equal parts of what's able to be built, because there's a lot of stuff
- 1:59:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: like, the city may not care about parking minimums, the banks do, because a bank doesn't feel that, you know, it doesn't matter what we say for HAB, if a bank is like, we're not going to let you build 150 units with only 75 parking spots.
- 2:00:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: which has come up recently before us at Planning Board. If the bank won't approve the loan, it doesn't matter what we want as a city. So sometimes talking to the lenders, because to Chip's earlier point, lenders can't…
- 2:00:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Give money that they don't think they're gonna get back.
- 2:00:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: they've got their own agenda that they… they're kind of able… They're gonna do a market analysis regardless of… They understand the market really well. I think lenders is a great, great idea. Yeah, the president of the Bank of Colorado for the Front Range once told me that he cares about three things. Primary form of repayment, secondary form of repayment, and tertiary form of repayment.
- 2:00:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: He's like, everything else means nothing to me.
- 2:00:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I don't… it's his job. Yeah, he's like, I gotta get paid back, otherwise I can't give out loans.
- 2:00:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And then another piece, I think, and this would probably be the end of next year, maybe even 28, wow, I can't believe I said that, but there is a ballot initiative for vacancy tax, and if it passes.
- 2:01:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It's sort of… these vacancy taxes, they exist a handful of places, but it's like a pilot thing. If it passes, the city… we should be monitoring, like, how… how is this working? It's a very novel idea.
- 2:01:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: In a novel-type pilot program, and that's something…
- 2:01:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I think are… we should be staying on top of. And staff will be…
- 2:01:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: if it passes, staff will be tasked with enforcing it, and listening to staff, what… how is this going? You know, like, how is it being enforced? What are the reactions? Things like that. That's something I think that would be very important if it passes.
- 2:01:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: A follow-on to that is, real estate transfer tax,
- 2:01:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It's probably a little early to start talking about it, but… because it would require an amendment to the state constitution. But there's actually some movement in the city to
- 2:02:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Start making that percolate up a little bit.
- 2:02:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: But I don't… I don't think it's productive to talk about it just yet, but…
- 2:02:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Something to put in there.
- 2:02:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Distant future.
- 2:02:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah, but I think if this passes, it's, like, it's very… Well, this one, yeah, that one's a much more… one of those things where, like…
- 2:02:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: we do something new, and we'll see if it… if it's good or bad, and I think we should just try to understand that.
- 2:02:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Anything else?
- 2:02:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Excited for the budget conversation. I actually am. Well, as I've said in the past, like, I think it's fully within our right to weigh in on that, and I think it's helpful to understand from Kurt and HHS, like.
- 2:03:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: How are you guys doing, and where… what are the priorities, and…
- 2:03:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: That is an area where we could weigh in on Council.
- 2:03:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And I think it would also be helpful, in addition to just understanding, like, the budget issues from Curt, like, how is the… what is the budget process every year, and where could HAB best comment on that in the future when it comes to housing?
- 2:03:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Okay, anything else as far as work plan goes?
- 2:03:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Great.
- 2:03:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: List.
- 2:03:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: All right, next up is talking about the letter to Council regarding San Lazaro. Did everybody have a chance to…
- 2:03:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Review the letter, draft, thoughts, comments… Could you provide some background on what… what… how this percolated, what's going on? So, we're standing under a bridge.
- 2:04:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It's pouring rain. Phillip is measuring how quickly… I think 17th Street crossing Boller Creek, that bridge.
- 2:04:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: No, seriously, though, we were on the, affordable housing, bike tour, and we got stuck under the bridge for, I don't know, 15 minutes, something like that, waiting for the deluge to lighten up, and we just got talking, and one of the things that came up was
- 2:04:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It was, big local news about the San Lozaro, community, and…
- 2:04:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: just the fact… is everybody up to date on what's happening with San Lazaro? No. Okay, so San Lazaro, do you know where San Lazaro is? I do, it's on Belmont, you know, that's okay. But, yeah, and I…
- 2:05:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah.
- 2:05:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I think I maybe even refused myself from part of that conversation anywho. But yeah, yeah, I did read it, and best of luck.
- 2:05:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So it is technically not city limits, which is a part of the challenge.
- 2:05:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It's got some… infrastructure issues.
- 2:05:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: But the… the big challenge that they're facing right now is that the owner of the property is selling it.
- 2:05:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Apparently, there's been an offer for their asking price of $42 million, and so, because of the…
- 2:05:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Rock law? What's the law called this? The state law that allows residents
- 2:05:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Right of first refusal. The park, first right of… right of refusal. So the community is coming together, trying to raise
- 2:06:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: $42 million, to be able to purchase their park and become resident-owned.
- 2:06:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And they're doing it all different kinds of ways. They're trying to, like, Bake sales and,
- 2:06:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: what's it called? Benefactors, fine benefactors, and then also just looking at what kind of city, county, state resources they might have. So, the county commissioners voted to give
- 2:06:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: 12.2? 11.2?
- 2:06:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I think it was in the 11… 11… $11.2 million, which is incredible,
- 2:06:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: The city has been meeting with, representatives from San Lazaro. My understanding is they're meeting every week to try and figure out some solutions.
- 2:07:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Initially, the dollar amount that was thrown out by the city is 1.2, which San Lazaro folks were hoping for significantly more. The challenge with the city is kind of what their,
- 2:07:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: allowed to do, because it's not within city limits. So what I'm reading on the City of Boulder website, press release from the city, is that the City offered them a $1.3 million loan. Yes.
- 2:07:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: that would be forgiven if they are annexed into the city. Yes.
- 2:07:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: So, it's my understanding that
- 2:07:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: The cost to annex into the city will be between $8 and $10 million as well.
- 2:07:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: So that's on top of the $42 million.
- 2:07:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: That is being offered just to.
- 2:07:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: boss.
- 2:07:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Property.
- 2:07:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: To the park, or the cost to the city?
- 2:07:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: the… the cost to the park to pay to annex in. So that would include upgrading to city utilities primarily, is my understanding.
- 2:08:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So they would get $1.3 million, but they'd have to pay.
- 2:08:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Yeah.
- 2:08:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: 18.
- 2:08:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Let me back up and be a little higher level. So… It sounds like a trap. We're standing under the bridge, it's pouring rain, and the… and the…
- 2:08:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: The kind of general consensus was
- 2:08:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: these are community… these are a large number of people that live in our community, and there is not a lot of deeply affordable housing in the city, and that's not in the city, I'll be clear with that. But,
- 2:08:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: in the area, right? But that is one. So…
- 2:08:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We, as a community, should be doing everything we can to be able to help these folks.
- 2:09:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Which is coming from lots of different entities. But…
- 2:09:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Basically, with the, conversation that night, and those of you that were standing on the bridge, please help fill in, but was like.
- 2:09:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We all need to try and do something, and we need to, support the powers that be that
- 2:09:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: could do something to be able to do what they can. So that's what this letter is. We don't have any
- 2:09:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: specific solutions to say, oh, well, have you thought about taking this money from here and doing it here? That wasn't the point. The point was
- 2:09:39 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: really, a part of it is to simply get it on record that HAB, the Housing Advisory Board, acknowledges that this is a big thing that has to do with housing in this city. Well, I have a question. Is the owner trying to sell it to another mobile park owner?
- 2:09:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Details have not been… No, it's a similar question. I mean, what… a developer couldn't buy it for $42 million, and…
- 2:10:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So they'll scrape it, and… Yeah, it's probably zoned through the county as a mobile home park, so whoever buys it's gonna keep running it as a mobile home park.
- 2:10:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: They're just good, they're good.
- 2:10:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Jack up the rents really high, is the worry.
- 2:10:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Yeah.
- 2:10:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I mean, I'll tell you, like… But they would never rezone it to not be a mobile home park, would they? If they did, that's a county… that's up to the county… If they have… if they…
- 2:10:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: As part of the condition of, like, paying for the repairs for the water issue, because there's, like, a pond that is very contaminated that is a large part of why the H10 million is…
- 2:10:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: There. So…
- 2:10:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: And I think Karin got it spot on. There's a lot that people are doing behind the scenes that we're not
- 2:10:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: privy to.
- 2:10:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: But I think the idea of the letter is just to say HAB understands the value of mobile home parks in our community. They're serving the lowest of the low-income residents that are working in our community. There's, I think, something like 140 kids in Boulder Valley School District.
- 2:11:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: And so just that HAB supports the city… city's involvement in trying to preserve this community.
- 2:11:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I guess my concern is, like, first of all, it's not in the city, and is the city gonna really
- 2:11:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: by intervening in county affairs gonna make this problem any better or worse?
- 2:11:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It's just like, I… at a human level, I understand, like, I'm empathetic to people who live in America and around the world, and right on Belmont Road by my post office, but it's not within absolute purview. It's not…
- 2:11:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Right, and I don't… I'm not in a position to, like… and the letter doesn't do this, but, like…
- 2:11:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I don't think we're in a position yet to weigh in on annexation, if it's a good idea. Okay, that's not the point. That's not the point. Yeah.
- 2:12:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I think what… so…
- 2:12:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We are the Housing Advisory Board to the City of Boulder. So, theoretically, who hears us say something is the City of Boulder. Yeah, no, I agree. We should use our voice to say, hey… But what are we saying here? Like, help them, but we don't… I don't think we're telling them how to do it, I think we're just saying it's important to preserve mobile home
- 2:12:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: housing as one of the housing options in the city of Boulder, or in the Boulder area. Yeah. Yeah, if you read, like, the second-to-last paragraphs… I do have it here if you want bigger.
- 2:12:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yes.
- 2:12:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It says in here, we asked the city to financially support annexation if required to facilitate the acquisition. I'm not going to recommend annexation if I don't know anything about it. It's like a really big technical move for the city to annex property, and if it's going to cost them 8 to 10 million dollars.
- 2:13:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: it's… it may not even be in their own financial interest, I'm just uninformed on this. That's a…
- 2:13:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: That's a policy recommendation that I'm not in a position to weigh in on right now, and for that reason, I'll vote no on this.
- 2:13:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: If that language right there specifically were amended?
- 2:13:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I think I would… I mean, I… I think I would support a letter that was kind of… that stated our…
- 2:13:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: concern and, like, understanding. I think probably a lot of that isn't there.
- 2:13:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I agree to the extent that there are policy recommendations that I have
- 2:13:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: reservations about that. Like, the… the resident-led purchase is…
- 2:13:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I think it poses serious, like, moral hazard concerns, in terms of how the… the… what would… what could happen elsewhere, and, like, how… like, I did, like, a deep dive into the mechanics of what was going on, and why this was, like, allowed to happen, and, like.
- 2:14:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Because you are not required to disclose who the offer's made by, like, you don't know if it's a bona fide offer, and so it…
- 2:14:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: One of the likely theories is just that it's…
- 2:14:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Some, like, another entity affiliated with the owner that is trying to extract money from the city.
- 2:14:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: and from the state and other entities to kind of bail them out for not making repairs that they should have made over the years while they were getting rents. And, like, rewarding that is…
- 2:14:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: potentially troublesome, and, like, could be a template for using that approach elsewhere. That said that, I think the law has also changed.
- 2:14:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: But it has changed effective January 2027, which is also very suspicious in terms of the timing of this offer. I'll just say, like, I think it's, like, I would definitely support something, and I…
- 2:14:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: really appreciate the letter, and I think that there's, like, I agree with a lot of it, probably most of it, but, like, would not be comfortable with making concrete, like, representations about, like, what the city should do, because I think it's really…
- 2:15:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: a very thorny problem. But that we could express support and, like.
- 2:15:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: support for the residents and, like, our hope that we can work something out so that they can remain in the kids, something along those lines, like, I would definitely be supportive of that.
- 2:15:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: But the… but the park is looking directly to the city for financial support, that's…
- 2:15:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Right, but I don't know if that's… from my perspective, like, I don't know if that's actually in the city's interest or in, like, a general public policy, like, it's a good public policy.
- 2:15:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Yeah, but, like, from the mobile home park's perspective, they're…
- 2:15:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: given the situation, and the state law is the state law, the residents can purchase it, or a governmental entity can purchase it, and nobody else can purchase it. So.
- 2:16:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I think my…
- 2:16:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: The overarching concern, I don't want to disagree or agree with any of you on the merits of this. Maybe it is a good idea, maybe it's not. I'm not in a position to make a decision on this, and that this is a recommendation, and I think in terms of, like, our procedures, like, if we're gonna weigh in on this sort of thing, we're talking about millions of dollars.
- 2:16:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: we should have a hearing, we should learn about it, we should educate ourselves and make informed decision, and I…
- 2:16:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: There is a time clock, though. Like, we're not gonna have time to sit and have a public hearing on all of this.
- 2:16:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Before.
- 2:16:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I noticed it said the deadline was fast approaching. That was December? December 8th, maybe? Or just early December? And then another thing I just want to point out was just… can I ask you a question? Are you saying that, like, our procedures would require
- 2:16:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: having, like, a hearing or something before making a recommendation, or just that that would be good practice? I'd have to consult with our rules that we rarely consult with. I mean, we generally handle things rather informally, but I do think before we make a policy recommendation, it's supposed to be noticed so that, in theory, someone could come and publicly comment.
- 2:17:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So it should…
- 2:17:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: what is that, beyond… because, Tiffany, you posted the agenda before every meeting. Was… was this, like, noticed? I guess it was, right? It was posted as part of the agenda? Yeah.
- 2:17:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Can we back… can we back up a little bit? I think this is the meeting to make a decision on if we want to
- 2:17:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: propose a letter to City Council on this. If there are policy recommendations that you want to strip from the letter or revise.
- 2:17:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: We could do that.
- 2:17:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Right now…
- 2:17:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah, I mean, I'll just be honest with you guys, I didn't know anything about this until I read the Meeting Packet today. And then I, you know, which, granted, it was sent out a week ago, I think.
- 2:18:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: But I just didn't really know this was an issue, and now I'm learning it seems like a pretty big thing. There's talk of annexation, millions of dollars.
- 2:18:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: personally, I'm not comfortable weighing in on something. It's also… it's not a general policy that we're talking about for the city. It's very specific to private property interests and private ownership, and I'm just not comfortable, like, weighing in on this until I learn more about it and understand it.
- 2:18:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I think… so, I think there's a couple of options. It's like, we could strip out the language if we wanted to have something that kind of just…
- 2:18:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: purely, kind of…
- 2:18:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: signaling support for, like, the importance of this type of housing in the community and for the residents. I would be fine with that. I'm also fine, like.
- 2:18:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: putting the letter with the policy recommendations to a vote. I don't… I have no problem with, like, you know, if folks want to make a policy recommendation, like, I don't think there's anything that prevents it. I don't think that I would support it in the current incarnation, but, like.
- 2:19:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: That's not a reason not to…
- 2:19:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: do it, like, if most people do support it, so… I'd rather have, like, people feel like they can…
- 2:19:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: propose recommendations than not. So, like, I'm very appreciative that you did this and, like, took the time to put it together. Yeah, and I don't want to come across as hurtful here, I'm just expensive.
- 2:19:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: my concerns about weighing in on something I don't know about.
- 2:19:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Philip, your thoughts?
- 2:19:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: In this moment.
- 2:19:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Boom.
- 2:20:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I do, yeah, it's… this is… this is tricky, because, for a lot of the reasons you said, I've actually had some of these concerns. I don't… when we had this conversation, I don't actually remember,
- 2:20:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I do want to give… like, I kind of want to have a book waves. I want to… I want to, like, signal support for this community that's in distress, and
- 2:20:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You know, I don't think a letter from us is gonna…
- 2:20:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: carry a whole lot of weight. It certainly doesn't come attached with $20 million, or however much… $30 million, or however much more they need.
- 2:20:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And so, You know,
- 2:20:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: A letter like this is almost literally, like, the least we can do.
- 2:20:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And yet, I'm also not certain that, you know, the way this whole structure of this
- 2:20:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Not on city, for-profit mobile home park.
- 2:21:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It doesn't… it doesn't,
- 2:21:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Like, just on the face of it, and this is, again, not being an expert or not having a complete insight on the whole situation.
- 2:21:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: it doesn't feel like the sort of thing where, yes, you want to help a community in distress, but in terms of policy, or in terms of, like, what's the best way to spend money to improve affordable housing in the community.
- 2:21:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: is… is that… Are… are we getting yanked around by this, this phantom,
- 2:21:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: offer for the… for the property, and then the extremely distressed properties. Would it be better to take $42 million and build a whole new community for… you know… I mean, it… it just…
- 2:21:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah, I… I… I feel conflicted about… about it.
- 2:22:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: One thing I just want to add to this is, I know, like, Boulder Meadows is privately owned mobile park.
- 2:22:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: it's also one of the largest sources of affordable housing, and, like, naturally occurring affordable housing in Boulder. So, I don't… again, I don't know the specific circumstances of San Lazaro. Maybe it is a problem, maybe it's good, but just because it's a privately owned mobile home park, or it's a private owner, doesn't mean
- 2:22:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It's gonna… it'll be…
- 2:22:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: it'll turn into luxury housing or something. Like, it still could be affordable. That is a model of providing affordable housing, is privately owned mobile home parks. So, I don't think we want to just say, oh, because it's being sold, this is necessarily a bad thing.
- 2:22:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So I just… I just don't know with this one, but I do know that there are…
- 2:22:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: affordable, privately owned mobile home parks, and is it possible that the city getting involved and opposing city requirements can make it more expensive for them? I just don't know. I don't know enough about this specific case, and that's why I'm uncomfortable
- 2:23:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: weighing in, because it's not, like, a generally applicable policy that we're weighing in on. It's also, like, very specific to
- 2:23:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: someone's home and stuff, and I feel like we need to be very careful in that situation.
- 2:23:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Ethan, what are you thinking?
- 2:23:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I guess I'd be in favor of…
- 2:23:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: stripping the letter down to be a little bit more general, because I think we…
- 2:23:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Are all probably agreeing that we don't know enough about the situation to offer specific
- 2:23:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Advice about what the city should do, just saying, I think it's in…
- 2:23:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Important to preserve, mobile home parks as a source of
- 2:23:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Affordable housing in the City of Boulder.
- 2:23:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And maybe just…
- 2:24:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: leave it at that. I don't… that's not super profound. A lot of people already know that, but,
- 2:24:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I'm not sure we can be more specific with policy than that, given how little we know about it.
- 2:24:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It looked great. As I was asking David what he was thinking, it looks like you were about to say something. What's up?
- 2:24:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You know, how… one of the things that,
- 2:24:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: was confusing to me about the format of these meetings when I first joined is,
- 2:24:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: They can and should be working meetings, and it's perfectly reasonable to
- 2:24:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: to hash out some edits to this letter, and we, you know, I think it wouldn't take very long to
- 2:24:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: To do that, if people have time and patience for that.
- 2:24:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It looks like the first paragraph and the…
- 2:24:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: second to last paragraph could be edited to something like, you know, we urge the city to do everything reasonably can to support the residents' efforts to maintain their community as an affordable option for housing in the… for workers in the city, or something like that.
- 2:25:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You know, change it to one sentence, and then maybe just reframe the first Paragraph as something,
- 2:25:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You know, it calls out
- 2:25:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Resident-like purchase, making the resident-led purchase a reality, so replace that with some…
- 2:25:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You know, at, like, a high level, I'm supportive of, like, the city taking measures to preserve mobile home parks.
- 2:25:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Like, that… that's a general theme that…
- 2:25:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I'm supportive of, not specific to this transaction, but just, like, from what we've learned as a board over the years.
- 2:25:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You know, this letter, it operates under the assumption that, like, we want the residents to buy this on their own. I… I just don't… I can't… I can't weigh in on that, you know? It's… I'm not comfortable.
- 2:26:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: as a very low-level policymaker weighing in on the fabric. Okay, okay, I think I see where you're going.
- 2:26:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Like, I wouldn't even want to specifically mention Sam Lonsaro.
- 2:26:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Yeah, it sounds like Chip will be a no on this no matter what, so I think if…
- 2:26:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: With the caveat, Lauren, I'm a no right now. My position on this could change if I learned more, but I'm a no today.
- 2:26:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Yeah, so if we… I guess if we have the time and willingness to just
- 2:26:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Make some of those revisions that… Philip was mentioning.
- 2:26:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Maybe we could get to an agreement.
- 2:26:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: That the rest of us could support.
- 2:27:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: I think the time is now. I'm very strongly supportive of
- 2:27:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: of even a generic letter to City Council supporting the residents of San Lazaro.
- 2:27:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I agree with that. I think if we're gonna do anything, it ought to be this evening, and, you know,
- 2:27:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Does someone have it open that we can edit it? I was gonna say, Brandon, do you have access? Could you… I do have access,
- 2:27:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Do you mind, and can we see if we can get to something that feels good?
- 2:27:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: No, I don't mind at all. Chip, do you think we could get to something that feels good, or see how it goes?
- 2:27:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Well, we cannot vote you, too. You should not vote, but… Also true. Depending on the language, I might be a no, or I could be an abstain. Okay. And then… Let's give it… there's certain things I could say yes on, but I'm not… I don't think I'm comfortable weighing in on just San… anything that says San Lazaro. I mean, what if it was, like, just an expression of, like.
- 2:28:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Support or concern for their situation with no recommendation whatsoever.
- 2:28:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah, I mean, I think we could say, like, the Housing Advisory Board supports preserving
- 2:28:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Before, mobile home parks. But even though there's a…
- 2:28:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: It needs to…
- 2:28:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I'll see your prescription.
- 2:28:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: It needs to reference San Lazaro.
- 2:28:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Absolutely. I'd be okay referencing San Lazaro.
- 2:28:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I mean, I think, like, one of the things that I've thought about is that, like, it's…
- 2:28:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It's not just about, like, preservation, like, it's like, how did we get here? And part of it is that, like, can you even build
- 2:28:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: you know, just mobile home parks, like, elsewhere in the city, like, what, like… we don't…
- 2:28:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: If we allowed mobile home parks to be built.
- 2:28:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: like, there would be competition, and you wouldn't necessarily have, like, this kind of monopoly power that this developer is exercising, so it's, like, it's a systemic issue. That's why I think it's, like, very complicated. It's not necessarily that we just want to be coming in and, like.
- 2:29:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: preserving things, it's also, like, we want to be able to build things and have a market where people can have mobile home parks and they're not prohibited by zoning or other rules. That's what I'm saying, like, more generally supporting mobile home parks as a…
- 2:29:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: concept. Preserving mobile home. That would cover that too, right? Or that it's an important part of, like, you know, it represents an important part of the housing, you know, affordable housing that is
- 2:29:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: That we should be…
- 2:29:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: whether it's this park or something else that's affordable that we should preserve. So, are you okay with, having a letter that's mostly like this, which is focused on San Lazaro?
- 2:29:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah, but they just removed the policy, so… But they said, like, it has come to our attention that the owner of the San Lazaro Mobile Home Park
- 2:30:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Is, offering the property for sale.
- 2:30:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: The Housing Advisory Board supports informed policy to preserve mobile home parks.
- 2:30:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: As affordable housing options.
- 2:30:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: as an important affordable housing option in and around the City of Boulder.
- 2:30:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: The preservation part is…
- 2:30:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I think preserve isn't… I think we're all sort of signaling we don't want this to turn into…
- 2:30:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: luxury housing, right? Is that kind of the…
- 2:30:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: But we don't want these… we don't want these people to be displaced.
- 2:30:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah, I think that's… it's from my radar. So, no, I would not agree with that.
- 2:30:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So, they would be… but what… we don't know what necessarily would displace them at this time. High cost of rent for the… the lots that they…
- 2:31:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: That's the… that's the distress they're worried about, right? You… you sell it for… They'll sell it and it'll go up? That's right.
- 2:31:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yes.
- 2:31:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Oh, the rents will go up. Well, yeah, I mean, they've done… I think there's… so, like, the county's done an appraisal of the
- 2:31:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: of the…
- 2:31:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Park, which has not been released, which is interesting, it may be released, but most people think that the appraisal would show that it's worth way less than $42 million.
- 2:31:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And so in order to make the $42 million purchase price work, assuming it's a bona fide price, which it may not be, and you may just see the buyer mysteriously back out, you would have to raise rents. There's no way that
- 2:31:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: you could have that price work without either rezoning the property or raising the rents. The math doesn't work out. That's the… So, why are they scrambling to raise $42? You seem to think it's worth less, which, honestly… Because 42 is the offer that…
- 2:32:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: San Lazaro has presented, with no…
- 2:32:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: really no substantiation. How much… do we know how much… how many acres is this property?
- 2:32:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: It's large, but it serves over 200 families.
- 2:32:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Right, I'm not… I don't want to discount the number of people there, it's more like, is 42 even,
- 2:32:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: a real number for this piece of land, because it's just the land. There's, you know, basically very little improvement for a mobile home park.
- 2:32:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I hear what you're saying. You have an established community that's paying rent today. Right, I'm just talking about this $42 million figure that Brendan's talking about.
- 2:32:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Like, where did it come from?
- 2:32:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Right, you're saying that's what the mobile home park prop proposed to buy it from? No, that's what they said, like, the park has said, we have an offer to buy it for 42… to buy this property for $42 million, we are invoking the state law that gives the right of first refusal. That's basically all we know. Okay. And that's… That's all…
- 2:33:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We know. That's all we know.
- 2:33:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: But even, I mean, I don't know that anyone else besides the Global Heart Pope mobile park.
- 2:33:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Whatever.
- 2:33:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: The homes, or whatever is behind it.
- 2:33:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I don't know if anyone else has the information.
- 2:33:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Well, my suggestion is we get the document on the,
- 2:33:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: on the screen, we edited, in real time.
- 2:33:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: If you're most likely going to vote no, maybe just sort of, hold back on commentary and edit suggestions. I can present the… or I don't know how this works, but I can send it. I was gonna say, if you want to jump on to…
- 2:34:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: the Zoom link, I can… Make you a presenter.
- 2:34:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Or you can send it to me. But then I have to make the edits. Yeah. Oh, that's…
- 2:34:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Or I can present, like, a tab or something.
- 2:34:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And is it shared in an editable form?
- 2:34:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: If you join the Zoom, you should be able to share a tab. I do it for depositions all the time, and I have my returning my notes in another room. Lauren, are you in front of your computer, and can you share with Brandon an editable version? You would have to make him a host.
- 2:34:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Let me see if I can find the… the…
- 2:34:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: the version, an editable version… I don't… not sure if I have the final version, Karin. I love it.
- 2:34:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: They just copy-paste, I don't know.
- 2:35:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Adobe into a Word. Lauren, would you like to edit?
- 2:35:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: I can try… hold on one second…
- 2:35:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Since you're already on June.
- 2:35:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Yeah, happy to do that.
- 2:35:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Just be careful, because if you do accidentally flash something from your screen, it's a public record, a YouTube video, so…
- 2:35:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Okay.
- 2:35:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It's not just a quick, oops.
- 2:35:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I have… I have a revised version, but…
- 2:35:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I can present with the caveat that it was… AI assisted.
- 2:35:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: But it reads pretty good to me.
- 2:35:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Well, as long as humans vote on it before it becomes effectual, I think that complies with ethical standards, right?
- 2:35:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Brendan, if you have a version, do you want to join the Zoom meeting?
- 2:35:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Sure…
- 2:35:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Okay, sorry.
- 2:35:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I do that? I… oh, you sent… no, Tiffany sent this earlier. So I have it. I've had it. I've always had it. Sim link. It's in the title.
- 2:36:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: -Oh.
- 2:36:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Join as panelists? Yeah.
- 2:36:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Excuse me.
- 2:36:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Here with 2, though, because… support.
- 2:37:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Just kind of show your vision, because I don't know how to get the original to be not in over formatting from PDFs.
- 2:37:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Sorry, I'm looking for the original word. Oh, yeah, if you have that, it'd be great. Access it.
- 2:37:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: their entire content.
- 2:37:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Just too.
- 2:37:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: At least I stuck around. Max Ford just walked out.
- 2:37:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: He doesn't get to vote, though. He wishes good luck in a completely unironic manner.
- 2:38:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: He's kind of like, I'm abstaining, but…
- 2:38:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: For my other thoughts.
- 2:39:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Attorneys are good at amending things on the fly.
- 2:39:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I have to enable… If they can get connected.
- 2:39:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: He's connected.
- 2:39:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: No, I had to, like, enable sharing on my computer.
- 2:39:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Oh, no.
- 2:39:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It, like, has to allow… I think I did it.
- 2:39:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Sure.
- 2:39:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Good.
- 2:39:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It looks like…
- 2:39:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Here we go.
- 2:39:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So this is the original, sort of formatting. This was the revised… Folks have visited.
- 2:39:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I should read it in more places.
- 2:40:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yes, can you make it bigger? One thing to keep in mind, we can advise city council, but we can also advise the city manager. So there are permeates, to the extent
- 2:40:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You guys want to… Help the city manager do something, you can do that.
- 2:40:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So, yeah, the first difference I see is the last phrase of that first paragraph.
- 2:40:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: To assist the title community.
- 2:40:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah, so there's no recommendation. Assist.
- 2:40:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I would think support would be a better word than assist, not to get too picky, but assist kind of sounds like a…
- 2:40:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: No, no, it has… has… it sounds more like,
- 2:41:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: adding money, you know. Financial. It sounds a little more financial than support. Yeah.
- 2:41:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Sorry, I should… no, this is… this is my,
- 2:41:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And I guess I want to just back up just a second. So, Brandon, some of the stuff you were saying about
- 2:41:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I don't.
- 2:41:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Do you feel comfortable in saying, we support
- 2:41:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Not quite sure how to say this.
- 2:41:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Do we need to be at a much higher level and just say.
- 2:41:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You know, with our learnings about mobile home parks, et cetera, in this last year, we just need to
- 2:42:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Support this form of deeply affordable housing.
- 2:42:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Like, do you feel okay with saying… Right, but in that first paragraph, do you… like, do you feel okay with saying we support the residents trying to figure this out, or does that make you uncomfortable? Because we don't actually know, is that the right thing to happen?
- 2:42:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah, I guess it's… I'm thinking… that's what I'm mulling over in my head, is like, I think it's fine to say, like.
- 2:42:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It's support for the residents, but not… it's not support for necessarily what the residents preferred.
- 2:42:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: approach is, but if this comes across like that, then… I'm voicing support for the residents. Okay. Yeah, so for me, it comes down to the last phrase of this first paragraph, and then just rewriting
- 2:42:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: the last or second… I mean, if we want to take out the financial part, we could get rid of private funders, and just cover that with… and other partners, because I think private funders… Funders are financial. But do we want to… you're saying maybe a different word than assist is…
- 2:43:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Or we could take out that clause.
- 2:43:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Did you change something just now? I didn't see it.
- 2:43:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: No. I'm on a different tab.
- 2:43:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah, I mean, that… that… That's fine with me.
- 2:43:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: as far as I'm concerned, we could move on to the We Urge paragraph.
- 2:43:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Trace the urge.
- 2:43:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Keep going. That's the one with the specific policy, right? Oh, I think I… this probably was taken out in this one.
- 2:43:52 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Oh, right, just a second. This is, like, a new version. You may have other features, so I would recommend reading it. Yeah, right, let's read the…
- 2:44:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: read the whole thing.
- 2:44:15 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Anyone notices a difference in that second paragraph? It doesn't look like it. Is the 140… I mean, that's the fact that I would want to make sure.
- 2:44:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: That's correct.
- 2:44:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah, okay. I did ask the prompt to change the letter, the original letter, as little as possible, so… Yeah, I don't see any changes in that paragraph.
- 2:44:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I guess I would want… I would maybe want to add, like, a sentence that's like, we… you know, we understand that this is, like, a very complicated dynamic, and…
- 2:45:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: you know, therefore we're not making a specific… like, I would feel more comfortable if we expressly said we are not making a recommendation. So I'll draft the sentence and add it.
- 2:45:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: People can't see the music.
- 2:45:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I guess I don't see any differences in the…
- 2:45:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: in the recent year HAB paragraph, but it looks like the next paragraph is different. Yes. Which one?
- 2:45:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So in your document, that one that starts with, we understand that the City is regularly meeting
- 2:45:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Bringing together public and private resources, so maybe that part is still…
- 2:45:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Oh, you know what? I think it just took off the first sentence on the draft that I had.
- 2:45:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I might propose, like…
- 2:46:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: These paragraphs, which is not showing up, but, basically, while we understand the City's regular meeting, we encourage the city to continue doing, everything, to do.
- 2:46:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It's our fruits.
- 2:46:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Now you're gonna… I'm gonna add my sentence.
- 2:46:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: This is gonna be a very rough,
- 2:46:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It's gonna be perfect.
- 2:47:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So, pretty. Yeah.
- 2:47:48 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: The revolution of… type of housing in the city.
- 2:47:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Preservation.
- 2:48:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: affordable housing options.
- 2:48:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Is there a way to say it somehow, this particular database used to work something like this, helping type?
- 2:48:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah.
- 2:48:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I feel like that's options is kind of like that.
- 2:48:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah.
- 2:48:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And it references San Mazaro, but it's a little less specific, because it says affordable housing options like San Mazaro. Okay. This is kind of like when a court makes a pivotal ruling, and they're like, but we just want to say our decision's very limited and doesn't apply to anything else except does.
- 2:49:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Analogies.
- 2:49:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Lauren, how you go over there?
- 2:49:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: I'm… this is great.
- 2:49:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: The last sentence of the next paragraph is a little bit, dramatic. I don't know. We stand in solidarity. I'm not super comfortable. Where does it say that? The last sentence. The last paragraph. The last sentence of the next paragraph.
- 2:49:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Thank you.
- 2:49:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah.
- 2:49:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Wake up.
- 2:49:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It's a little extreme. Yeah, maybe a little grandiose. I'm sorry if that was not saying that was AI. That sounds kind of like AI.
- 2:49:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: AI is very, like, supportive and…
- 2:50:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: you're like, am I good at my job? They'll be like, absolutely. You're the best. I was actually just thinking about how…
- 2:50:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We're, like, a collective large language model right now. We're, like, trying to predict what the next word should be. Yeah, their language model's probably studying how we talk.
- 2:50:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: This is so true.
- 2:50:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Alright, risk of displacement?
- 2:50:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: No.
- 2:51:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Excellent.
- 2:51:03 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We can't.
- 2:51:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: When I do, beautiful.
- 2:51:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Simple.
- 2:51:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Great. That's crazy.
- 2:51:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I think you can see behind what's there.
- 2:51:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Okay.
- 2:51:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Thanks for doing that, Brendan.
- 2:51:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Oh, for sure. No, thanks for, Karin, for doing most of the legwork.
- 2:52:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Lauren, help me out. And Lauren, you too.
- 2:52:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Let me know when you'll scroll down.
- 2:52:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I'm ready.
- 2:52:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Is it true that the city is still regularly meeting with residents?
- 2:52:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Parts of a week ago, yeah.
- 2:52:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Yes, that's my understanding.
- 2:52:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: What is that based on, just to know the…
- 2:52:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Back check. Like, what are they talking about? Like, what's… well, like, how do we know that they're regular meeting? What is…
- 2:53:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: What is that understanding based on?
- 2:53:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: City. Sorry, over here. Yeah, I would say I don't…
- 2:53:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I don't know the status of the regularity of the meetings, but… Let's say…
- 2:53:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You may know more than me.
- 2:53:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: What about has been Meeting? We understand City has-been Meeting? I know, I know that at least last week we met, too.
- 2:53:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: I think regularly is… is accurate.
- 2:53:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It is? So, it's… Okay, that's fine.
- 2:53:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: This is… it's definitely… it's not stable, or it's a… unincorporated Boller County. Okay.
- 2:53:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Excuse me.
- 2:54:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Just to be precise.
- 2:54:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: That's true.
- 2:54:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Do we want city capitalized or not capitalized? It looks like it's capitalized over us.
- 2:54:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Epilepsy.
- 2:55:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: In that paragraph, we encourage the city We need that,
- 2:55:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: words to support the San Luzara residents during this uncertain time?
- 2:55:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Because I'm that kind of…
- 2:55:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We encourage the city to continue its efforts and continue working collaboratively with the residents and other regional partners to…
- 2:55:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I'm fine with that. It's simpler. To continue and to continue.
- 2:55:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And then, it's a little hard to see, but it says, we encourage the city to continue its efforts and to continue working collaboratively. Oh, you're right.
- 2:55:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: to,
- 2:56:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Excellent.
- 2:56:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Where is that?
- 2:56:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Where did that piece was, yeah? It's right under the box. So, according to the CVS story, the park was listed at 42.5, and an investor offered
- 2:56:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: To buy it for that full amount, too.
- 2:56:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Amazing.
- 2:56:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: But I guess the question is, is it not an arm's length transaction?
- 2:56:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Someone's trying to profit off of public money or something.
- 2:56:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Like Brendan mentioned, though, they are receiving appraisals, and I'm sure that they've got
- 2:56:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Attorneys and real estate professionals involved to help them flesh out If it's a legitimate offer.
- 2:57:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Well, in the, organization…
- 2:57:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Rock? I mean, the… Yeah, Rock is involved. You mean for the San Lazar to know if it's a legitimate offer, or for Boller San J.
- 2:57:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Well, I mean, even the counties investing $11.2 million, they want to know that they're spending their money
- 2:57:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: In a legitimate way, right?
- 2:57:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You'd hope so, but our elected officials at the county are not even subject to competitive elections, so…
- 2:57:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I'm still looking for that to continue and continue.
- 2:57:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Because I saw that earlier, too, but I don't know where that was.
- 2:57:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Oh, to continue its efforts. I see. It's the We Understand paragraph, the second sentence. We encourage the city to continue its efforts.
- 2:58:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Oh, I guess, and to continue collaboratively.
- 2:58:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And how about just… and to work collaboratively?
- 2:58:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah.
- 2:58:13 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Can I delete this again.
- 2:58:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Feel good.
- 2:58:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: This is great, I just want to acknowledge it's, like, 1 minute till 9. We have a firm stop. I think we're about done. I just wanted to, like, throw it out there.
- 2:58:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Happy little bit.
- 2:58:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: That's what's going on.
- 2:58:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: to this focus.
- 2:58:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Standing with the workers and families contribute so much to Boulder, we help ensure our community remains accessible to those who help it thrive.
- 2:59:01 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I feel that there's some importance
- 2:59:04 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Talking about the risk of displacement.
- 2:59:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I'm quite sure how to…
- 2:59:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: How about anything with that?
- 2:59:20 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Displacement.
- 2:59:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I do want to avoid, like, It's implying that we should… That the city should, like… step into…
- 2:59:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Prevent displacement.
- 2:59:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: That was partly my concern of that. So I think, like, acknowledging
- 2:59:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Displacement, I think, is fine, but, like…
- 2:59:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: The only way to really prevent the displacement is to buy the property. I understand.
- 2:59:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Or to, sorry, get the loan, you know what I mean.
- 2:59:58 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Can I accept these edits that we have now, and then we can look at the…
- 3:00:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: See if it's ready for… I can add back in the…
- 3:00:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: The pattern was.
- 3:00:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Why don't I read it aloud, just because that's often helpful. As the deadline for San Lizard residents to raise around $42 million.
- 3:00:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: To purchase the mobile home community where they live is fast approaching. The City of Boulder Housing Advisory Board wants to voice our support for the residents and for a collaborative effort among the City, Boulder County, the state, and other partners to assist this vital community.
- 3:00:37 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: San Lazaro is more than a mobile home park. It is home to people who work in our community, keep our local businesses and institutions running, and contribute to Boller's vitality every day.
- 3:00:46 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: More than 140 San Lazaro children attend Boulder Valley School District schools, underscoring the importance of this community not only to its residents, but also to our local schools and families. Supporting these residents means helping workers and families remain in the community they help sustain. In recent years, the Housing Advisory Board has had guest speakers for a panel discussion
- 3:01:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I had it in recent years. Was it just one panel discussion, or…
- 3:01:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You can probably just take for a panel discussion out. Guest speakers. To deepen our… To deepen our…
- 3:01:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Has hosted guest speaker? Jazz hosted…
- 3:01:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Just change this to ending now.
- 3:01:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: He didn't quite get it. Didn't quite get it.
- 3:01:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: But… Hosted. Hosted. Hosted.
- 3:01:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Sorry, I know I'm trying to just figure out how to… You're doing awesome. …do this. Okay, here we go.
- 3:01:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I mean, does this letter conclude that, or suggest that resident-owned mobile home parks is the way to go? Because we've… we've heard… why don't we finish reading through it, you can decide if you want to vote yes or no.
- 3:01:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: In recent years, the Housing Value Board has hosted guest speakers to deepen our understanding of mobile home parks as a vital piece of Boulder's affordable housing landscape. One of the most striking takeaways was that these communities provide some of the only truly deeply affordable housing options in the Boller area. Preserving deeply affordable housing options is essential to maintaining a community
- 3:02:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: where people across a range of incomes can live and work. We understand that the City is regularly meeting with residents to discuss how the City can help, despite the property being outside the City's current limits. We encourage the City to continue
- 3:02:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I am, like, hesitant about,
- 3:02:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: because the City's proposal is annexation, I'm worried about saying we encourage the city's continuous efforts, thus being supportive of that. I'm wondering, can we say we encourage the city to continue
- 3:02:47 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I'm making really generic. We're working collaboratively with the residents on the regional parties to address the challenges they're facing.
- 3:02:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We understand the city… the situation is complex and dynamic. We are not offering specific policy recommendations to resolve this issue beyond expressing our support for preserving and growing affordable housing options like San Lazaro. By standing with the workers and families who contribute so much to Boller and who now face the risk of displacement, we help ensure our community remains accessible to those who help it thrive.
- 3:03:16 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We appreciate the City Council's ongoing attention to this matter.
- 3:03:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Seems… I think I'm comfortable with that.
- 3:03:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: just…
- 3:03:43 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And then maybe we can just, like, vote to put this back in the format that you had it in, which was a nice…
- 3:03:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah, I mean, I think… I think we can vote on it without having all the… Right.
- 3:03:59 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And, you know, not the editing stuff, but, you know, formatting? The formatting. Right, this would be whatever.
- 3:04:10 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: That's really necessary.
- 3:04:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Does that work?
- 3:04:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: That's fantastic.
- 3:04:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Okay.
- 3:04:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Should we vote on it?
- 3:04:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Are you ready?
- 3:04:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It's your letter, so I'm pretty sure you're comfortable with it.
- 3:04:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: What do I need to do? Okay, so, this letter, dated October…
- 3:04:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: 28th, I guess we're just putting this to approval, that this
- 3:05:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah, Lenny, I think you'd make a motion to vote for the letter as edited by… Do you want to make a motion?
- 3:05:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Well, I move that we, vote to accept this letter as edited by Brendan in this meeting.
- 3:05:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I second.
- 3:05:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: All in favor?
- 3:05:23 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Bye.
- 3:05:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: But I'm opposed. Opposed. Okay.
- 3:05:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: do you want to make a statement of… isn't that something that we're supposed to do? It's like, give… because doesn't the Board of Council want to know…
- 3:05:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I can say 10 seconds. My two con… I think I have three concerns. First is, I just… this is about a very specific property in Boulder, and I don't know enough about the actual issue here to weigh in on it.
- 3:05:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So that's number one. It doesn't feel like an informed decision at this juncture.
- 3:06:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: to… I think the letter does imply…
- 3:06:05 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Although it's careful, but it… I think it implies that the Housing Advisory Board supports the residents.
- 3:06:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: acquiring this property for $42 million. I take no position on that. I just don't know enough about it, so I don't want to imply that. And then third, I have concerns about making recommendations to Council about issues outside the city limits.
- 3:06:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Acknowledged and recorded. And ultimately, this does recommend City staff get involved, and I'd like to see our staff most focused on the residents of the City of Boller.
- 3:06:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: How do I… how can I transmit this to wherever it needs to go to, so it's not sitting on my computer?
- 3:06:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You could just email it to me, yeah? Okay. CCTiffany.
- 3:06:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It's all in the public record, just don't make somebody go back on YouTube and try to false. This is great, it's public, real-time editing. Okay, I'm gonna stop sharing my screen, and then I'm gonna email this.
- 3:07:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: To you.
- 3:07:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And Tiffany. Great. Does that work?
- 3:07:19 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And Tiffany, I'll make sure it's, you know, has the… Okay
- 3:07:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: All right, thank you all for that. Thank you. And thank you, Chip, for sharing your…
- 3:07:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: thoughts as well, I do appreciate it.
- 3:07:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Thank you. You're wrong. No, I'm just absolutely kidding. Disagreement is a fundamental part of democracy, and if we stop disagreeing, we have an unhealthy world. It is important, and if you want, I can send you some more information about San Lazaro if you want to learn more.
- 3:07:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I just replied in the thread, too, so I think…
- 3:07:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Okay, great. All right, I'm gonna move on then, okay? Matters from the staff?
- 3:08:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah, I mean, I know it's getting late, but I wanted to mention that we put out an RFP for a home share program.
- 3:08:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So we're trying to find a vendor to… That's super exciting. So… It's real. We have funding.
- 3:08:18 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: That's awesome. I feel like I'm not very enthusiastic about it now, because I wouldn't admire, but I am very enthusiastic. That's great.
- 3:08:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I assume, have you reached out to the…
- 3:08:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: to the woman who runs that nonprofit called Sharing Housing.
- 3:08:38 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: No, there was a… there's a woman who runs a nonprofit called Sharing Housing, and she might be a good one to reach out to for leads on other vendors who might submit stuff.
- 3:08:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: It's sharinghousing.org, I believe. I'm trying to remember her name.
- 3:08:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: That would be someone you could… you could ask about possible vendors. Yeah, we don't know the ecosystem. I was gonna say, I would be very curious to hear a follow-up, like, how many people have responded?
- 3:09:09 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: hopefully some of ourselves. Yeah, yeah. Did you guys ever reach out to, like, other college towns in America? Yeah. Yeah, for this one, we, have been talking a lot with the town of Bellingham, Washington. Okay.
- 3:09:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You love that town. Have you been? No, but I think I should. I think he should. It seems like something that maybe other, like a Gainesville, Florida, or an Athens, Georgia, or something like that might happen. Apparently Bellingham. Or Bellingham, Washington. We got some feedback on some things to avoid.
- 3:09:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Awesome. But I love the idea of a field trip.
- 3:09:49 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Sounds great. You know, don't go in January. Okay. Summer, next summer. Anything else? There's some events coming up, I don't know if you… on… so I have on my radar, you all should have had… have received
- 3:10:08 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Emails about a strategic, citywide strategic landing.
- 3:10:12 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: workshop? I think I forwarded that out to everybody this afternoon. Okay, I've seen that. November 14th, and you can RSVP if you're interested in going. It's November 19th and 14th, which is a Saturday, between 9.30 and 2 at the East Boulder.
- 3:10:28 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: community center. And then, do you know more about this?
- 3:10:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: the gathering, the board and commission gathering? Do you know anything about it? Yeah. Okay, so December 7th, I think, we've sent out the invites for… it's HHS boards and commissions. We'll be gathering, be hearing an update on HHS,
- 3:10:51 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: work plans, kind of things that have been happening, an opportunity for boards and commissions to kind of mingle together and discuss. It will be at the AgeWell West location on 909 Arapaho.
- 3:11:07 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: there'll be a meal and just kind of a chance for everybody to get together. There'll be a short, like, presentation from Kurt, some of the updates on HHS and things like that, but mostly just a chance for a gathering of all of the ones that support HHS.
- 3:11:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: There's a question with the one on November 14th, is that…
- 3:11:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: What is that?
- 3:11:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: how, like, substantive is that? Is it… is it, like, more pro forma, or is it more like… substantive.
- 3:11:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: You know, honestly, it's put on through city manager's office, so I'm not really sure what exactly the…
- 3:11:50 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: layout for that day is whether it's going to be a lot of,
- 3:11:55 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Presentation, or if it's gonna be a lot of, like, input.
- 3:12:00 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Yeah.
- 3:12:02 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So I'd be potentially interested, but if it's, like, I think I'd be more interested in input than the… I believe the goal is more input than just, like, kind of presenting out. They're hoping… they've extended the invites, first to boards and commission members, not as…
- 3:12:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: board and commission members, but as individuals in the community that are already active, with the city, so you wouldn't be participating as a board member, but because you are already
- 3:12:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: active as a board member, they're hoping for more participation. Do you know when we… like, when…
- 3:12:40 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Is it limited to… I know they said, like, two or three people per board, but is it, like, limited, or is it, like, whoever wants to attend? I believe anybody that wants to attend. I don't know that they're anticipating needing to cut it off right now.
- 3:12:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: For too many… too much participation.
- 3:12:57 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Are you going? I don't think so. I don't think it, calendar-wise, I can. It would… it would be really great if somebody from HAB
- 3:13:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I think I can go. I may be able to go as well. I will…
- 3:13:11 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Oh, check my… That'd be great. I'll double check. Cool. Anything else?
- 3:13:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Except, okay, final thoughts or suggestions from anybody?
- 3:13:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Oh, this was a productive meeting.
- 3:13:27 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Agreed.
- 3:13:32 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Anything else? I have two things. One is, I just want to remind everybody to be thinking that we potentially have
- 3:13:41 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Potentially 3 empty seats.
- 3:13:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: then 2027, and the, application period opens… it's, like, December and January for about 6 weeks, so as… as…
- 3:13:56 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: there's more details set. Tiffany, will you share that with us? Yeah, we haven't been given any dates yet, but usually they open the,
- 3:14:06 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: the window somewhere in that, like, first to second week of December. That's where someone's turned up besides me.
- 3:14:14 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So just two seats. I think, your term… I think, Lauren, your term is up in 2027?
- 3:14:21 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Correct.
- 3:14:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: warrant.
- 3:14:24 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And then, shira will be cycling off. Okay.
- 3:14:31 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Cycling notch will be all.
- 3:14:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So, yeah.
- 3:14:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: So just start… just start, you know, thinking about people that you think might be an asset to have that you would encourage to apply.
- 3:14:45 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: And then, the other thing I just wanted to say is, get out and vote if you have not yet.
- 3:14:53 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Where's that?
- 3:14:54 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I counted with 64 questions on my ballot. 64 bubbles that I have to go on. That's a lot of democracy. It's been a long time to research all those things. It's a while to get through it, for sure. It's been, like, sitting on my desk, like a to-do thing, and I'm, like, kind of putting it off. It's a lot of work.
- 3:15:17 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Okay, alright, I think that's it, so…
- 3:15:22 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: I'll make a motion to adjourn.
- 3:15:25 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Circus.
- 3:15:26 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: All in favor?
- 3:15:29 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Hi.
- 3:15:30 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Are you in favor?
- 3:15:33 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Great, okay.
- 3:15:34 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Sorry. Good.
- 3:15:35 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: I…
- 3:15:36 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: We couldn't see you raising your hands while you're sitting in front of your meter. Okay.
- 3:15:42 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker HAB Monthly Meeting 10.28.26: Thanks, everyone.
- 3:15:44 (opens the meeting video at this time) Unknown speaker Lauren Schevets: Okay, bye, everyone. See you next month.